Tiza Group

Home / Tools / Insulation co-ordination

Insulation co-ordination of a substation

Choose the highest voltage for equipment (Um), the altitude and the earth-fault factor, and enter the data of the arrester, the line and the separation: the tool calculates the required withstand voltages, selects the standard level, checks the arrester Uc and Ur, and gives you the maximum distance to the equipment and the minimum insulator creepage.

IEC 60071-1:2006§ 5.9.1, tabla 2standard levels of range IIEC 60071-2:1996§ 2.3, 3.3, 4.2.2, 4.3.4, anexo Fapplication guideIEC 62271-1:2017§ 4.2.2altitude of switchgearSiemens 2012§ pp. 38, 105metal-oxide surge arresters

Example cases
Insulation co-ordination of a substation

Only the basic data; the rest is taken with typical values.

ALearn

E1Network and site

It is not the nominal voltage: 13.2 kV → 17.5 kV; 34.5 kV → 36 kV; 115 kV → 123 kV; 230 kV → 245 kV. Range I only, up to 245 kV.

kV

Optional, phase-to-phase and not above Um. Empty: Um is used.

m

Above sea level.

Solidly earthed neutral: up to 1.4. Isolated or resonant neutral: 1.73.

E2Lightning and separation
kV

Lightning impulse residual voltage at the nominal discharge current, from the datasheet.

With two or more lines on the bus the wave splits. One line is the most severe case.

m
years
/100 km·year
kV/µs
m

From the arrester to the transformer or equipment with internal insulation, including the connections.

m

Up to the farthest yard equipment: insulators, disconnectors, bushings.

E3Surge arrester
kV
kV
× Ur

From the manufacturer's curve for the fault duration (for example 1.1 for 1 s).

E4Insulator and pollution

I to IV: mm per kV of Um phase-to-phase. a to e: mm per kV of Um/√3, per Siemens.

Gives an informative value for the insulator; air clearances keep m = 1.

mm

Optional, from the datasheet.

Use a decimal point. The calculation runs in your browser and updates as you type.

Lightning impulse level (BIL)

— kV

Power-frequency level

— kV

Required external, lightning

— kV

Required internal, lightning

— kV

Altitude factor Ka

—

External co-ordination Ucw

— kV

External margin

—

Maximum separation, external

— m

Maximum separation, internal

— m

Temporary overvoltage

— kV

Minimum arrester Uc

— kV

Minimum arrester Ur

— kV

Minimum creepage

— mm

The bay: lightning surge, arrester and protected equipment
  • Lightning surge
The surge arrives on the line, the arrester limits it to Upl and it travels on to the equipment: with the separation, the voltage at its terminals rises. Green: covered by the chosen BIL; red: not enough.
Required voltage against standard levels
  • Chosen level
  • Other levels of the Um
Each bar is a required withstand voltage; the lines are the standard levels of IEC 60071-1 for that Um. The chosen level is the first one that covers both bars on each side.
Required voltage against the distance to the arrester
  • External
  • Internal
  • Chosen BIL
Where each line crosses the BIL is the maximum separation. The dots are your separations.
Minimum creepage distance by pollution
  • Chosen level
  • Your insulator
Minimum values without correction for insulator diameter or shape. The vertical line is the creepage of your insulator, if you entered it.

Step-by-step calculation

Standard levels of the chosen Um

Need it for a real project? We carry out the full study, with its report.

What it is for

When you specify the equipment of a substation you must ask for an insulation level: the voltage it must withstand under lightning impulse (BIL) and at power frequency. That level depends on the network voltage, the site altitude, the surge arrester and how far the equipment is from the arrester. This tool walks through that calculation for a range I bay (Um up to 245 kV) and selects the standard level of IEC 60071-1.

It also checks that the continuous operating voltage and the rated voltage of the arrester cover the temporary overvoltage of an earth fault, gives you the maximum separation between arrester and equipment, and calculates the minimum creepage distance of the insulator for the site pollution.

How it is calculated

IEC 60071-2:1996§ 4.2.2eq. 11 IEC 62271-1:2017§ 4.2.2altitude

Altitude factor

Ka = em·H/8150

H is the altitude in metres. For lightning impulse and for air clearances at power frequency m = 1. For a polluted insulator at power frequency m may drop to 0.5 (normal) or 0.8 (anti-fog): the tool shows it as an informative value. Only external insulation is corrected.

IEC 60071-2:1996§ anexo Feq. F.18 and F.19

Lightning co-ordination voltage from the line

Ucw = Upl + (A/n) · L/(Lsp + La) · La = Ra/Rkm

A depends on the type of line, n is the number of connected lines, L the separation between arrester and equipment, Lsp the span, Ra the acceptable failure rate of the equipment (one every so many years) and Rkm the lightning outage rate of the line. With the wave steepness S the tool uses instead Urp = Upl + 2·S·L/c, with c = 300 m/µs, while Upl ≥ 2·S·T; otherwise 2·Upl (2.3.4.5).

IEC 60071-2:1996§ 3.3.1, 4.3.4safety factors

Required withstand voltages

Internal: Urw = 1.15 · Ucw · External: Urw = 1.05 · Ka · Ucw

At power frequency the co-ordination voltage is the temporary overvoltage k·Us/√3, with the same factors. The chosen level is the first standard combination of IEC 60071-1:2006 for that Um that covers the highest required lightning value and the highest power-frequency value. The maximum separation is the L that makes the required value equal to the chosen BIL.

IEC 60071-2:1996§ 2.3.2.1, 2.3.2.7surge arrester Siemens 2012§ p. 385 % allowance

Surge arrester

Uc ≥ Us/√3 (or ≥ k·Us/√3 with a sustained fault) · T · Ur ≥ k·Us/√3

T is the temporary overvoltage capability of the arrester for the fault duration, from the manufacturer's curve. With a sustained fault the overvoltage is continuous and the real check is Uc. The Siemens 5 % harmonics allowance is shown as an informative line.

IEC 60071-2:1996§ 3.3.1.1levels I to IV Siemens 2012§ p. 105classes a to e

Minimum creepage distance

Levels I to IV: creepage = fe · Um · Classes a to e: creepage = USCD · Um/√3

fe is the minimum specific creepage of the level, in mm per kV of the phase-to-phase voltage, for glass and porcelain insulators. USCD is the unified specific creepage of each class, in mm per kV of the phase-to-earth voltage. No diameter correction is applied.

Limits of the calculation

  • Range I only (Um up to 245 kV) and deterministic method. From 123 kV, energizing or reclosing long lines can set the power-frequency voltage: the tool does not convert slow-front overvoltages nor check phase-to-phase insulation.
  • The bracketed levels of IEC 60071-1:2006 may not be enough to prove phase-to-phase insulation: if the chosen level is one of them, an additional phase-to-phase test may be needed.
  • When the separation is not limited by equation (1), IEC 60071-2:1996 (2.3.4.5) asks for caution with transformers: the tool says exactly that, never «no limit».
  • The creepage distance does not include the correction for insulator diameter, shape or altitude. Classes a to e are read in the Siemens publication; IEC TS 60815 was not consulted.
  • The arrester data (Upl, Uc, Ur and its temporary overvoltage curve) come from the manufacturer's datasheet. It does not replace the project's insulation co-ordination study or the manufacturer's calculation.

Frequently asked questions

Why does the BIL of equipment rise with altitude?

Because the air is less dense and flashes over at a lower voltage. IEC 60071-2:1996 (4.2.2) multiplies the required withstand of external insulation by Ka = e^(m·H/8150); at 2600 m and with m = 1, Ka is about 1.38. IEC 62271-1:2017 (4.2.2) applies that correction only to external insulation: the oil, paper or SF6 inside the equipment do not change with height. That is why 115 kV equipment that would pass with 450 kV at sea level may need 550 kV on a high plateau such as Bogotá.

How far from the transformer should the surge arrester be?

As close as possible. The lightning wave keeps travelling past the arrester and reflects at the equipment: the voltage at its terminals grows with the separation. The tool calculates that voltage with annex F of IEC 60071-2:1996 (or with the wave steepness, eq. 1 to 3) and gives you the maximum separation for the chosen BIL. Count the whole connection: the incoming lead, the arrester height, its earth down-lead and the distance to the equipment.

How are the Uc and Ur of a surge arrester chosen?

The continuous operating voltage Uc must cover the phase-to-earth voltage of the network (Us/√3) or, if the network keeps operating with a sustained earth fault, the full temporary overvoltage. The rated voltage Ur is chosen with the manufacturer's temporary overvoltage curve: Ur multiplied by the capability T for the fault duration must cover k·Us/√3 (IEC 60071-2:1996, 2.3.2.7). Siemens also recommends a 5 % allowance on the continuous voltage for harmonics.

We carry out the insulation co-ordination of your substation

We calculate the insulation levels with the altitude and pollution of the site, select the surge arresters and check their distances, with the study report.

Related guides

Other tools

All tools
WhatsApp