Tiza Group

Home / Tools / Generator circuit-breaker

Generator circuit-breaker: asymmetry, delayed zeros and classes G1/G2

Type the data of the generator, the step-up transformer, the network and the breaker, and choose where the fault occurs. The tool draws the current of each phase with its DC component, finds the first zero after contact separation and compares it with the maximum arcing time. It also checks class G1 or G2 and the current when closing out of phase.

IEC/IEEE 62271-37-013:2015§ 4.101 a 4.104, 8.103.6, 8.103.9generator circuit-breakerIEEE C37.013-1997§ 5.8.2, 6.2.9.2, 7.3.9generator circuit-breaker

Example cases
Generator circuit-breaker: asymmetry, delayed zeros and classes G1/G2

Only the basic data; the rest is taken with typical values.

ALearn

E1Fail
°

0° is the voltage zero crossing: phase A gets the maximum asymmetry.

°

For phase opposition: 90° is the basis of the rated current and 180° full opposition.

E2Generator
MVA
kV
pu

The maximum generator voltage over the rated one.

pu
pu
pu
s
s
s

Sets how long the DC component lasts.

pu
E3Step-up transformer and network
MVA
kV
%
kA
E4Generator circuit-breaker
kA
kA
ms
ms

Declared by the manufacturer from its tests.

V

0 = no arc: the prospective current. With a value, the tool estimates when it forces the zero.

cycles

Use a decimal point. The calculation runs in your browser and updates as you type.

AC current at contact separation

—

Degree of asymmetry

—

First zero after separation

—

Breaker class

—

Out-of-phase current

—

Generator, breaker, transformer and network
The chosen fault and the path of the current the breaker interrupts. Each chamber shows its first current zero after contact separation: green inside the maximum arcing time, red if the arc goes on.
Current of each phase and DC component
  • Most offset phase
  • Other phases
  • DC component
  • Separation and maximum arc
The dashed line is the DC component. While it stays above the AC peak, the current does not cross zero. The band runs from contact separation to the maximum arcing time.
Asymmetry and current against the class
Each class covers a zone: G1 reaches 110 % with its full current and 130 % with 74 % of it; G2 reaches 130 % with the full current. The point is the no-load fault started at a voltage zero.
Voltages and current when closing out of phase
The voltage across the contacts is the difference between the generator's and the network's. The current follows it lagging 90°, because the circuit is almost pure reactance.

Step-by-step calculation

Need it for a real project? We carry out the full study, with its report.

What it is for

The generator circuit-breaker sits between the generator and its step-up transformer. It must break two very different faults: the one fed by the network through the transformer, with a lot of current, and the one fed by the generator itself, with less current but with a DC component that can keep the current from passing through zero.

This tool simulates both, finds the first current zero of each phase and compares it with the maximum arcing time of the breaker. It also checks the class G1 or G2 the application needs and the current if the generator is connected out of phase.

How it is calculated

IEC/IEEE 62271-37-013:2015§ anexo E.4generator-source fault

AC component of the generator

I(t) = E·In·[1/xd + (1/x′d − 1/xd)·e−t/T′d + (1/x″d − 1/x′d)·e−t/T″d]

The DC component of a phase is √2·E·In/x″d·cos α·e−t/Ta with x″q = x″d (otherwise the mean of 1/x″d and 1/x″q is used), with α the angle of its voltage at fault inception. The degree of asymmetry is the DC over the peak of the AC.

IEC/IEEE 62271-37-013:2015§ 8.103.6.3.3system-source fault

System current and asymmetrical capability

Isc = E·U/(√3·|Znet + ZT|) · Iasym = Isc·√(1 + 2·Asy²) · Asy = e−t/τ

The standard tests the breaker with τ = 133 ms and a separation equal to the half-cycle delay plus the minimum opening time.

IEC/IEEE 62271-37-013:2015§ 8.103.9.1phase opposition

Out-of-phase current

Ioph = δ·In/(x″d + xt + xs) · δ = 2·sin(φ/2)

δ is √2 at 90° and 2 at 180°. The rated out-of-phase current is 50 % of the system-source breaking current, on a 90° basis.

Limits of the calculation

  • The generator is at no load before the fault. With load and a leading power factor the asymmetry can be higher, and the standard asks for a simulation with the real data.
  • The arc at the fault location, which lowers the asymmetry, and the contribution of the auxiliary motors are not included.
  • The class is checked only with the generator at no load (8.103.6.3.7.3). With previous lagging or leading load the standard also asks for a simulation (8.103.6.3.7.2 and 8.103.6.3.7.4), and the three conditions must be met at the same time.
  • Each phase is looked at on its own: the change in the other phases after the first pole clears is not calculated.
  • The arc-voltage effect is an estimate. The capability proof is made with the manufacturer's arc characteristic.

Frequently asked questions

Why may the generator current not pass through zero?

Because the AC component decays with the subtransient and transient constants of the generator and the DC decays with the armature one, which is longer. If at contact separation the DC exceeds the AC peak, the asymmetry passes 100 % and the current takes a while to cross zero. The breaker must force that zero with its arc voltage within its maximum arcing time.

What is the difference between classes G1 and G2?

Both are defined in IEC/IEEE 62271-37-013:2015. A class G1 is tested with an asymmetry of 110 % with its rated generator-source current and of 130 % with 74 % of that current. A class G2 is tested with 130 % with the full current.

Which fault gives the generator circuit-breaker more current?

In almost every power plant the system-source one, through the step-up transformer, because the reactance of the transformer and the network is lower than the generator's. The generator-source fault gives less current but more asymmetry.

We review the application of your generator circuit-breaker

We calculate the fault currents of your power plant and check the class and timing of the breaker with the data of your equipment.

Related guides

Other tools

All tools
WhatsApp