Tiza Group

Home / Tools / Oscillography analysis

Oscillography analysis

Open the COMTRADE record of the fault and enter the relay settings: the tool identifies the fault type, direction and distance, works out which functions should have picked up and how fast, and compares that with the trip and breaker opening in the record. The files never leave your computer.

IEEE C37.111COMTRADE formatIEC 60255-24COMTRADE formatIEC 60255-151inverse-time curvesIEEE C37.112inverse-time curvesIEEE PC37.114fault location

Example cases
Oscillography analysis

Only the basic data; the rest is taken with typical values.

ALearn

E1Record

Sample record (synthetic)

Choose the .cfg and the .dat together, or a .cff; you can also drag them here. The file is read in your browser and is not uploaded to any server.

Sample files: .cfg · .dat

E2CT and VT ratios
A
A

1 A or 5 A, as on the CT nameplate and in the relay setting.

kV

Line to line.

V

Line to line.

E3Line
Ω/km
Ω/km
Ω/km
Ω/km
km
°
E4Phase overcurrent 50/51
A sec
A sec
s
E5Ground overcurrent 50N/51N
A sec

On secondary 3I0.

A sec
s
E6Distance 21 (mho)
Ω sec
°
s
Ω sec
°
s
Ω sec
°
s
E7Times and tolerances
ms

From the trip to current interruption. Use the nameplate value or the one from the timing test.

ms
ms
%

Use a decimal point. The calculation runs in your browser and updates as you type.

Fault type

—

Reactance distance

— km

Relay time

— ms

Protection verdict

—

The line bay as the record sees it
From the busbar come breaker 52, the CT and the VT that feed the relay analog inputs; the TRIP output goes to the trip coil and the 52a contact returns to a binary input. The fault is marked on the line at the reactance-method distance. In yellow, what acted: the faulted phases, the functions that pick up (the fastest one framed), the trip and the breaker open after clearing.
Currents and voltages of the record
  • Phase A
  • Phase B
  • Phase C
  • Neutral
Currents on top and voltages below, in primary values, with time measured from fault inception. The vertical lines mark inception, the relay trip and clearing.
Mho zones and fault impedance
  • Zones
  • Line
Each circle is a mho zone in secondary ohms. The straight line is the whole line. The dots are the impedance measured in the fault loop: inside a circle, that zone picks up.
Prefault and fault phasors, and symmetrical components
  • Phase A · sequence 1
  • Phase B
  • Phase C · sequence 2
  • Neutral · sequence 0
On top, the phase currents and voltages during the fault; prefault is dotted. Below, their symmetrical components. Angles are referred to prefault VA.
Expected and measured times
  • Record
  • Expected
Everything is measured from fault inception. The bars on top are what the record shows; the ones below, the expected time of each function with the entered settings.

Functions and verdict

FunctionMeasuredSettingMultiple or indexPicks upExpected

Times, distance, sequences and direction

Times in the record

Location

LoopPrimary ZSecondary ZReactanceTakagi

Symmetrical components

ComponentPre-faultFail

Direction

CriterionAngleDirection

Event report

What it is for

After a trip, the relay's oscillography record tells what happened: the bay currents and voltages, the instant of the trip and when the breaker opened. This tool reads that record in COMTRADE format and answers three questions: what fault it was, where it was and whether the protection operated as set.

You enter the CT and VT ratios, the line data and the settings of the 50/51, 50N/51N and 21 functions. The tool measures the fault with the same quantities as the relay, works out which functions should have picked up and their expected time, and compares it with the trip in the record. It also checks the breaker time.

How it is calculated

Phadke y Thorpone-cycle phasor

Phasors and secondary quantities

Isec = Iprim / CTR · Zsec = Zprim × CTR / VTR

The prefault and fault phasors are computed with a one-cycle window; the fault window starts one and a half cycles after inception and absorbs most of the dc offset. CTR and VTR are the CT and VT ratios. The symmetrical components I0, I1 and I2 give the fault type and, with the voltages, the direction.

IEC 60255-151inverse-time curve IEEE C37.112inverse-time curve

Expected overcurrent time

t51 = TMS · k / (Mα − 1) + top · t50 = tdelay + top · M = Isec / Ipickup

The 51P uses the current of the highest phase and the 51N the residual current 3I0. IEEE curves have a different form: t = TD · (A / (Mp − 1) + B). top is the relay operating time up to the trip contact.

Phadke y Thorpmho characteristic

Self-polarized mho zone

Inside if |Z|² ≤ Re(Z · Zr*) · index = |Z|² / Re(Z · Zr*)

Zr is the zone reach with its angle. The circle passes through the origin and has Zr as its diameter. An index of 100 % or less means the loop impedance falls inside the circle and the zone picks up; its expected time is the delay plus the relay operating time.

IEEE PC37.114loops and single-ended methods

Distance to the fault

Zloop = VA / (IA + k0 · 3I0) · mX = Im(Zloop) / X1L · mTakagi = Im(V · ΔI*) / Im(Z1L · I · ΔI*)

For a ground fault the loop is compensated with k0 = (Z0L − Z1L) / 3Z1L; for a phase-to-phase fault the voltage and current between those phases are used. ΔI is the fault current minus the prefault current. The formulas are those of Zimmerman and Costello, who follow the IEEE PC37.114 guide.

Fortescuesequence networks

Direction and verdict

Forward if |∠(−V2/I2) − θ| < 90° · tolerance = max(trel · texp, tmin)

With the fault in front of the relay, the negative- and zero-sequence sources are behind it and −V2/I2 has the angle of the source impedance. The verdict takes the fastest function that picks up and compares its expected time with the trip in the record: within the tolerance the operation is correct; outside it, slow or faster than expected.

Limits of the calculation

  • The functions are textbook elements: self-polarized mho without memory or cross polarization, IEC and IEEE curves, definite time. It does not reproduce the logic of a particular relay, nor teleprotection, the 87 or the 67.
  • Single-ended location is pulled off by fault resistance combined with load, zero-sequence mutual coupling, remote infeed and errors in the line data.
  • The 51 currents are taken from the main fault window. If the current changes during the fault, through CT saturation or a changing infeed, the relay integrates a different current.
  • The thresholds marked “Tiza” and the default tolerance are conventions of the tool. The example cases use a synthetic record made with the COMTRADE generator, not a real event.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know from a COMTRADE record whether the protection operated correctly?

The fault is measured in the record with the same quantities the relay uses, secondary amperes and ohms, and compared with the loaded settings. Each function that picks up has an expected time: its delay plus the relay operating time, or the time of its curve. If the trip in the record matches the fastest function within the tolerance, the operation was correct; if it comes late or early, check the actual settings or which other function tripped.

What is the difference between the reactance method and the Takagi method?

The reactance method divides the imaginary part of the loop impedance by the line reactance per kilometer. It is exact for a bolted fault, but fault resistance combined with load pulls it off. Takagi uses the superimposed current, the fault current minus the prefault current, to remove the effect of the load; that is why it needs at least one prefault cycle in the record.

Do my files leave my computer?

No. The .cfg and .dat, or the .cff, are read by the browser and analyzed on your computer. The page does not send them to any server or store them; if you close or reload the page, the record is gone.

Related guides

Other tools

All tools
WhatsApp