Tiza Group

Home / Tools / MV feeder coordination

Medium-voltage feeder coordination

Choose the fuse, the recloser and its sequence, and enter the fault currents of your branch. The tool plots the curves on a time-current chart and checks fuse saving, coordination with the slow curve, the sectionalizer, cable and transformer damage, inrush and cold load.

IEEE C57.109-1993transformer damageIEEE 141-1993§ 5.6.2cable damage

Example cases
Medium-voltage feeder coordination

Only the basic data; the rest is taken with typical values.

ALearn

E1Fault currents
A

At the end of the fuse zone, at feeder voltage.

A

Next to the fuse.

s
E2Recloser
A

Open reference: 1.25 with one fast operation; with two, 1.35 if the reclose time is 60 cycles or longer and 1.8 if shorter. Other sequences: your manufacturer's value.

s
s
s
E3Fuse
%

Current in amperes and time in seconds, separated by spaces.

E4Sectionalizer
A
A
E5Transformer and load
kVA
%
kV

The primary fuse sees less current than the winding: the damage curve shifts to the left by that factor.

A

Of everything the fuse feeds, at feeder voltage.

E6Cable
mm²
°C
°C
A
E7Diagram

The diagram lights the signals and the sequence of this case with the fuse minimum fault.

Use a decimal point. The calculation runs in your browser and updates as you type.

Fuse saving

—

Fuse against the slow curve

—

Inrush and cold load

—

Cable and transformer damage

—

Signal path of the recloser, the sectionalizer and the fuse
  • Active signal
  • Signal at rest
The recloser CT feeds its control: it trips on the fast curve in the first operations and on the delayed curve afterwards, and the 79 recloses until lockout. On the lateral, the sectionalizer counts the openings and the fuse clears the permanent fault.
Feeder time-current curves
  • Fast × k (maximum clearing)
  • Slow (minimum trip)
  • Fuse: melting and clearing
  • Damage and fault
The fast curve is drawn at its maximum clearing multiplied by k. For fuse saving, the minimum melting of the fuse must stay above that curve. The total clearing of the fuse must stay below the slow curve. The squares are inrush and cold load: the minimum melting must pass above them.
Recloser operating sequence
  • Fast operation
  • Slow operation
  • Reclosing interval
Maximum clearing times at the maximum fault at the fuse. With a permanent fault the recloser goes through the whole sequence to lockout; the sectionalizer counts each operation.

Times at the fault currents

Loading these settings into a relay? We configure it remotely.

What it is for

On a medium-voltage feeder the recloser opens and recloses, and the branch fuses must blow only on permanent faults. This tool puts the recloser's fast and slow curves, the fuse, the transformer and the cable on one chart and checks that each device operates in the right order.

To coordinate relays and reclosers in series with IEC or IEEE curves, up to six devices on a full path, use the relay coordination tool. This one deals with the feeder: reclosing sequence, k factor, sectionalizer, cable damage, inrush and cold load.

What is checked

Source: Hosseinzadeh (UWO, 2008), §3.2; k from PDHonline E405

Fuse saving

tmin melting(I) ≥ k · tfast max(I)

The minimum melting of the fuse, with the preload you enter, must exceed the fast curve at its maximum clearing multiplied by k, over the whole fault range of the fuse. Applying k to the maximum clearing, which already includes the tolerance and the interrupting time, is more conservative than applying it to the average curve. Where the fast curve crosses the fuse, saving ends: above that current the fuse melts together with the fast operation.

Source: Hosseinzadeh (UWO, 2008), §3.2

The fuse blows on permanent faults

tfuse clearing(I) < tslow min(I) − margin

The total clearing of the fuse must stay below the slow curve with no factor, and the recloser must have two or more slow operations. The slow curve is taken at its minimum trip time.

Source: Hubbell PRS sectionalizer catalog (2016)

Sectionalizer

count ≤ recloser operations − 1 · Imin fault ≥ Iactuating · Iactuating ≤ 0.8 × Ipickup

The actuating current must not exceed the recloser pickup, or the sectionalizer does not count the trips between the two. The catalog works with 0.8 times the pickup (160 % against 200 % of the rated currents).

IEEE 141-1993§ 5.6.2copper cable

Cable damage

(I / A)² · t = 0.0297 · log10[(T2 + 234) / (T1 + 234)]

A is the cross-section in circular mils (1 mm² = 1,973.5 cmil), T1 the operating temperature and T2 the maximum short-circuit temperature; the equation is valid up to about 10 s. For a #6 AWG copper conductor with thermoplastic insulation from 75 to 150 °C it gives 21,500 A for a quarter cycle and 10,800 A for one cycle. The tool adds up the times of every operation the cable sees with a permanent fault (the fast operations and the fuse clearing) over the whole fault range, ignoring cooling between reclosings: a conservative check.

Source: CIGRE US NC 2017, session 4C, paper 3; FMPA/FMEA 2021

Inrush and cold load

inrush 12 × In at 0.1 s and 25 × In at 0.01 s · cold load 6 × 1 s, 3 × 10 s, 2 × 1,000 s

The fuse minimum melting must stay above those points. If a point falls outside the published curve (current below its first point or time beyond its longest one), the tool does not count it as passing: it flags it for review. The same source warns that default cold-load values should be questioned for lateral reclosers: use them as a reference and replace them with measurements from your feeder.

Where the curves come from

The 6 to 200 A K and T fuses come from the data files that Hubbell Power Systems (Chance) publishes on its product pages. Each curve is reduced to 26 points and interpolated on a logarithmic scale. The published value for a 40T at 2400 A (0.0185 s) matches the curve used. Minimum melting curves start with no load.

The recloser curves are the equations that S&C publishes in its bulletin 461-211, which emulate Cooper and other manufacturers' curves, with the tolerance of ±10 % or ±3 A in current, ±0.0167 s in time and 0.03 s of interruption that S&C declares for its TripSaver II. That tolerance is applied only when both curves are S&C emulations; IEC, IEEE, ABB, SEL and own curves are used as they are. If your recloser uses another curve, enter A, B, C and p from your manufacturer.

Limits of the calculation

  • There are no fuses from other manufacturers, no current-limiting fuses, and no N, QR or SloFast types: no published numerical data were found. You can enter I:t points of another fuse.
  • The recloser curves are S&C emulations. The curve published by the manufacturer prevails in a real study: compare them at the points that decide the setting.
  • The k factor from the manufacturer's full table, the one for other sequences, the cooling factors and the preload are not in open sources: they are your data. A fuse upstream of the recloser is not calculated here.
  • The cable equation is the IEEE 141-1993 copper one. Aluminium is not included yet: its constants still have to be checked on the original page. The 250 °C of thermoset insulation comes from a secondary source.
  • The transformer damage curve (IEEE C57.109-1993) comes from a secondary source and its categories are those of three-phase transformers. The fuse curves end near 0.01 s: below that time they are extrapolated with constant I²t and the tool says so.
  • All currents are at feeder voltage. The transformer connection enters only as the factor that shifts the damage curve. It does not model CT saturation.
  • It does not replace the coordination study of your system. The example cases are illustrative.

Frequently asked questions

What is fuse saving?

It means letting the recloser open on its fast curve before the fuse of a branch melts, so that a temporary fault does not leave the branch without supply. It holds if the minimum melting of the fuse is above the fast curve multiplied by a factor k, which covers the accumulated heating of the fuse in each operation.

What is the value of the k factor?

It depends on the sequence and the reclosing time, and the recloser manufacturer gives it. One open source gives 1.25 with one fast operation, and 1.35 or 1.8 with two fast operations depending on whether the reclose time is 60 cycles or longer, or shorter. For other sequences the tool asks for the manufacturer's value.

How many counts do I set on the sectionalizer?

At most one less than the operations of the recloser that backs it up: with a 4-shot recloser, a count of 3 at most. Also, the minimum fault current at its location must exceed the actuating current of the sectionalizer.

We do your protection coordination study

We gather the short-circuit data of your feeder and the curves of each recloser and fuse, and deliver the settings with their coordination chart, without travelling.

Related guides

Other tools

All tools
WhatsApp