Home / Tools / Plant model validation
Plant model validation
Choose the control and the test, and use an example record or paste your own with time, measured signal and simulated signal. The tool computes the coherence indices of CNO Agreement 1954 in their window, compares them with the thresholds of that test, groups the plant's units into equivalent units and reviews the contents of the report.
Acuerdo CNO 1954§ anexo 3coherence indicesAcuerdo CNO 1954§ anexo 1equivalent unitsAcuerdo CNO 1954§ anexo 2report contentsAcuerdo CNO 1954§ art. 10 y 14tests and follow-upCREG 101 104 de 2026§ art. 4 y 9plant models
Results
—
—
—
—
—
—
Charts
- Measured
- Simulated
- ±3 % bands
- Measurement error
- Simulated − measured
- ± EAMN
- ± measurement error
How it was calculated and standards
Coherence indices of the test
| Index | Measured | Simulated | Value | Criterion | Result |
|---|
Equivalent units
| Unit | Blocks | Equipment | Set-up | Units | MW | Minimum in service | Impedance |
|---|
Report review checklist
| Part | What it must have | Status |
|---|
What it is for
A solar or wind plant connected to the STN or STR hands the CND the model of the plant and its controls, and must show that it reproduces what the plant does in the field. This tool compares a test record with the model's simulation and computes the coherence indices of CNO Agreement 1954, with the window and threshold of each test.
It also groups the inverters or wind turbines into equivalent units with the criteria of the agreement, computes how many units must be in service in each test and reviews the contents of the report before you send it.
How it is calculated
Acuerdo CNO 1954§ anexo 3curve shape
Correlation, mean error and combined error
CCL = Σ(Ri − R̄)(Si − S̄) / √(Σ(Ri − R̄)² · Σ(Si − S̄)²) · EAMN = mean |Ri − Si| / min(contribution R, contribution S) · 100R is the measured signal and S the simulated one. The contribution of each signal is its maximum difference from its initial value. In validation tests they are computed from the disturbance to the maximum settling time of CREG 060 (10 s for voltage, 15 s for frequency); in follow-up, from 1 s before the event to the end of the record. The combined error is EC = EAMN + 100·(1 − CCL)²; with EAMN = 0, the 30 % limit requires a CCL of 0.452 or more.
Acuerdo CNO 1954§ anexo 3times and values
Initial and final values, overshoot and times
SI = (vmax − vf)/(vf − vi)·100 · EVF = |vfR − vfS|/|vfR − viR|·100 · ETE = |TER − TES|/TE060·100The initial and final values are averages over windows you define. The initial response time is when the signal leaves ±3 % of the step around the initial value; the settling time, when it enters and stays within ±3 % around the final one. Both are checked on the measured and the simulated signal against the CREG 060 maximums. The delay-time error (at 50 % of the change) is computed like the ramp error and shown without a threshold.
Acuerdo CNO 1954§ anexo 3ramp
Ramp error
ER = |RR − RS|/RR·100, with R² > 0.5The slope of each signal comes from a least-squares line through the points between 20–30 % and 70–80 % of the change. If the coefficient of determination is 0.5 or less, the slope is not used.
Acuerdo CNO 1954§ anexo 1, art. 10grouping
Equivalent units
units in service ≥ ⌈0.1 · n⌉Blocks that share equipment and rating, mounting (and in solar the tilt or tracking algorithm) and settings set are grouped. A block whose aggregation shifts P, Q or V at the point of connection by more than 1 % stays as a separate unit. In the test of each equivalent unit at least 10 % of its units must be in service, rounded up to the next integer.
Limits of the calculation
- The 2 in the EC formula is read as a square: EC = EAMN + 100·(1 − CCL)². Confirm it with the official text; the alternative reading, the sum divided by 2, is in Advanced mode.
- Pending: annex 5 of the agreement (results template, initial and final value windows and test names) is not in the tool. The windows are your inputs.
- The simulated signal must be on the same time stamps as the measured one (resample it first) and with the same disturbance time.
- Assumptions: the overshoot is taken from the extreme of the signal in the direction of the change; the ±3 % band is computed with the measured step and applied to both signals; the delay time is the time the signal takes to reach 50 % of the change; TE and TRI are compared as «less than or equal» to the CREG 060 maximums, as in the agreement tables.
- CREG 101 104 of 2026 requires RMS and EMT models. The tool compares field records with the RMS simulation; the maximum times used by the indices are those of CREG 060, which 101 104 did not change.
- The tool does not simulate the plant: the model is simulated in the CND tool and the records are compared here. The examples are our own records generated with a second-order response.
- The deviation when aggregating collectors comes from your study with 10 % voltage and frequency steps; the tool takes it as an input.
Frequently asked questions
Which indices does the CND check to validate a solar plant model?
CNO Agreement 1954 compares the curve measured in the field with the one simulated in the CND tool. In an unlimited set-point step it checks the overshoot error, the final-value error, the initial response and settling times and their errors, the correlation (CCL) and the normalized mean absolute error (EAMN). Limited tests, ramps and events check fewer indices, and events only the combined error (EC).
How are inverters grouped into equivalent units?
Units go together when they share inverter type (maker, model and rating), protection and control settings, the plant controller and, in solar, the tilt and the mounting type; in wind, the turbine type. Collectors are aggregated as long as 10 % voltage and frequency steps give at most 1 % difference in P, Q and V at the point of connection against the aggregated model, with the fewest units.
How many tests must pass to approve the model?
80 % of the tests of each control mode must meet all their indices, and the ones that fail must be due to something outside the control. Voltage control with droop and without droop count as different modes.
Related guides
Other tools
All tools
Solar energy
PV system sizingPV production and energy costPV I-V curveAGPE classifier and connection proceduresCable voltage dropSolar plants and the grid codeP-Q capability testPPC control testsCND supervision indicatorsPMU tests and commissioningRenewable energy tax incentives (Colombia)
Protection
Function 50/51 overcurrentFunction 27/59 voltageFunction 81 frequencyFunction 67/67N directionalFunction 46 negative sequenceFunction 49 thermal overloadFunction 25 synchronism checkFunction 32 reverse powerFunction 51V voltage overcurrentFunction 64G stator groundFunction 27TN third harmonicFunction 64F rotor groundFunction 78 out-of-stepFunction 50/27 inadvertent energizationFunction 37 undercurrentFunction 38 bearingsFunction 48 incomplete sequenceFunction 66 starts per hourFunction 51LR locked rotorFunction 14 underspeedFunction 47 phase sequenceFunction 59N residual overvoltageFunction 60 fuse failureFunction 55 power factorFunction 46BC broken conductorFunction 68 power swing blockingFunction 87N restricted earth faultFunction 63 Buchholz and pressureFunction 26 oil temperatureFunction 71 oil levelFunction 87B bus differentialFunction 60C bank unbalanceFunction 51G neutral groundFunction 79 reclosingFunction 86 lockoutFunction 94 tripFunction 74 trip supervisionFunction 87L line differentialPhasor diagramRelay coordinationCurrent transformer: burden and saturationVector group compensation (87T)Frequency df/dt rampBreaker failure 50BF87 differential settingCT and VT selectorDistance setting 21MV feeder coordinationMotor protectionBoundary meteringGenerator protectionLoad shedding 81 and UVLSShunt reactorSynchronizing and closing 25/78Secondary arc and single-pole reclosing
Analysis and communications
COMTRADE records: viewer and generatorOscillography analysisIEC 61850 SCL viewerIEC 61850 SCL auditorIEC 61850 network: GOOSE/SV addresses and process busIEC 60870-5-104 APDU decoderIEC 61850 to IEC 60870-5-104 and 101 mappingICCP bilateral table checkerIP and VLAN planDNP3 and Modbus decoderTeleprotection channel timeOptical and radio link budgetTime synchronisationMMS control sequenceGOOSE simulatorIEC 61850 station networkInterlocking table and CILO equationsCause-and-effect matrix and logic checkerZones and conduits (IEC 62443-3-2)Zone firewall rule reviewerRoles and permissions (IEC 62351-8)IED X.509 certificate verifierDevice hardening baselineIncident response exercise (CNO 2188)Cybersecurity gap: CNO and IEC 62443
Equipment testing and diagnostics
Commissioning checklistCurrent transformer testsDisconnector and GIS switchgear testsGrounding system testsPower cable testsVoltage transformer testsInsulation diagnosis: dissolved gases (DGA) and temperature correctionTransformer TTR testTransformer winding resistanceTransformer insulation, PI and DARTransformer power factor and capacitanceTransformer excitation currentTransformer SFRATransformer leakage reactanceTap changer dynamic resistanceCalibration and uncertaintyPCB equipment: classification and deadlinesRETIE pre-inspectionTransformer test interpreterCircuit breaker testsTest budgetMaintenance plan and health indexSF6 inventory and leakage
Electrical studies
Lightning protectionShort circuit and per-unit systemGround fault and neutralShort-circuit checkerPower transformerTransformer noiseSafety clearancesArc flashGrounding resistancePower-frequency electric and magnetic fieldsCurrent split factor SfApproach boundariesSubstation configuration selectorBusbar stressesInsulation co-ordinationTRV and short-line faultGenerator circuit-breakerInductive load switchingSwitch-fuse combinationDisconnector and earthing switchMV switchgear and GIS specifierMV cable insulation levelInsulator strings: mechanical checkSeismic qualification of substation equipmentSurge protective device selectionElectric vehicle charging station
Yard equipment control
Circuit breaker controlDisconnector controlTransformer controlMV switchgear controlCapacitor bank controlAuxiliary services controlIEC 61850 bay controllerRecloser control
Industry and power quality
Motor startingHarmonic distortion THD and TDDEquipment harmonic emissionHarmonic emission allocationCapacitor bankBattery sizingRegulatory quality indicatorsCapacitor bank protectionSubstation DC systemsPower qualityGenerating sets to ISO 8528Lighting design to RETILAPControl valve Cv and Kv and affinity laws
