Tiza Group

Home / Tools / 87 differential setting

Setting the 87T, 87N and 87B differential

Choose the function. For the 87T, enter the transformer and CT data: the tool calculates the TAP and compensation, plots the characteristic and the fault points, and checks harmonic blocking and CT saturation. For the high-impedance 87N and 87B, it calculates Vs, Rs, the operating current, the required knee point and the peak voltage.

SEL-387A§ 3characteristic and maximum errorSiemens 7UT6x§ 2.2.7settings and harmonicsGE P14x§ 9high impedanceIEC 61850-7-4:2010logical nodes PDIF and PHIZ

Example cases
Setting the 87T, 87N and 87B differential

Only the basic data; the rest is taken with typical values.

ALearn

E1Function

The diagram lights the signals of this case. In high impedance, external faults are simulated with the CT saturated.

E2Transformer and CTs
MVA
kV
kV
A
A
E3Errors to cover
%

SEL-387A uses ±10 % as the worst-case error; with properly sized CTs it is lower.

± %

Siemens: slope 1 must cover the percentage of the regulation range. Zero if there is no tap changer.

%
%
E4Relay characteristic
pu

In the base you chose: rated current of the protected object (Siemens), TAP (SEL) or CT of the reference winding (GE).

%
pu

Siemens: where branch 1 meets the restraint axis. GE: BREAK 1. Not used in the SEL shape.

pu

Siemens: where branch 2 meets the restraint axis. SEL: IRS1, where slope 2 begins. GE: BREAK 2.

%
pu
pu
E5Harmonic blocking
%

Not a standard value: measured or simulated data for your transformer.

%

Siemens 15 %, SEL 15 %, GE 20 %.

%
%

Siemens 30 %, SEL 35 %, GE 10 %.

E6External fault and CT
A

Primary current on the side of the CT being checked.

A

Primary current fed from the high-voltage side.

%

Share of the current the saturating CT still delivers.

V
Ω
Ω
Ω
%
ms
E7High impedance
A/A

Primary divided by secondary, for example 1500/5 = 300.

Ω
Ω

The resistance of the farthest lead; the loop counts it twice.

A

Primary: the largest fault current passing through the zone.

GE P14x: 1.0 in the REF example and 1.2 in the busbar example.

For the CT waveform and for the X/R method, which is only valid up to X/R = 25.

A
Ω

For the REF of one transformer: 3 phase CTs and 1 neutral CT.

A

From the CT excitation curve, at voltage Vs.

V
A

Primary; defines the peak voltage across the relay.

A

Of the protected winding or circuit, to give the sensitivity in %.

A
A

Use a decimal point. The calculation runs in your browser and updates as you type.

Tolerance or setting voltage

—

External fault or resistor Rs

—

Internal fault or operating current

—

CT

—

Signal path and trip logic
Top: the primary plant, the CTs with their polarity and star point, the relay and the trip down to the breaker coils. Bottom: the trip logic drawn with gates. What lights up in yellow is what acts in the simulated case.
Idiff against Irestraint or voltage scale
  • Characteristic
  • Unrestrained stage
Above the curve the relay operates; below it, it restrains. Each point is a fault with the restraint convention you chose: green when the result is the right one (restrain external faults, operate on the internal one), red when it is not. In high impedance the voltages are drawn on a logarithmic scale.
Secondary current with full offset
  • Actual current
  • Ideal current
The solid line is what the CT delivers; the dotted line is what it would deliver without saturating. The difference between the CTs on the two sides is the false differential current.

Step-by-step calculation

Loading these settings into a relay? We configure it remotely.

What it is for

Differential protection compares the current entering its zone with the current leaving it. If the transformer, neutral or busbar is healthy, the difference is almost zero; an internal fault creates a difference that the relay recognises. Its setting has three tasks: match the currents (CT ratio and vector group), cover the errors without losing sensitivity (slope), and not mistake inrush or overexcitation for a fault (harmonics).

This tool does those three tasks with the data of your transformer and CTs, and checks whether an external fault with a saturated CT stays inside the restraint region. For busbars and restricted earth fault protection, it calculates the high-impedance setting, which is stabilised by a voltage instead of a slope.

How it is calculated

SEL-387A§ 3TAP and compensation

Tap of each winding

TAP = S·1000 / (√3 · UkV · CTR) · C

S in MVA, U the winding line-to-line voltage and CTR the CT ratio. C is 1 with wye-connected CTs and √3 with delta-connected CTs. The tool reuses the calculation from "87T vector group compensation": the matrix that rotates the currents according to the vector group and removes zero sequence when there is no earth path inside the zone. SEL-387A requires the ratio of the largest to the smallest TAP not to exceed 7.5.

SEL-387A§ 3maximum error, pp. 3-21 to 3-23

Tolerance the slope must cover

ε = (2e + a + a·e)/(1 + a) + excitation + relay error

e is the CT error and a the tap changer range, as a fraction. With e = a = 0.1, the error from CT and tap changer is 28.18 %; adding 3 % for excitation and 5 % for the relay, SEL-387A reaches 36 %. In an external fault of current I, the expected differential current is ε·I.

Siemens 7UT6x§ 2.2.1Idiff and Irestraint GE T60§ 5.7.6.2restraint

Differential and restraint current

Idiff = |I1 + I2| · Irest = |I1| + |I2| (Siemens) · (|I1| + |I2|)/2 (SEL) · max(|I1|, |I2|) (GE)

The currents are the already compensated ones, in per unit. Each brand defines restraint in its own way, so a Siemens 25 % slope is not equivalent to a GE 25 % slope. For a through current I, restraint is 2I in Siemens, I in SEL and I in GE. Choose the convention of your relay.

Siemens 7UT6x§ 2.2.7harmonics SEL-387A§ 3PCT2, PCT5

Harmonic blocking

blocks if I2f/If > 2nd harmonic setting · or I5f/If > 5th harmonic setting

The 2nd harmonic identifies inrush current; the 5th identifies overexcitation. Values from the manuals: Siemens 15 % and 30 %, GE 20 % and 10 %, SEL 15 % and 35 % (suggested). Harmonic blocking does not affect the unrestrained stage.

Stability with saturated CT

In an external fault with asymmetrical current, a CT can saturate because of the DC component and remanence. If one CT saturates and the other does not, the false differential current can become almost equal to the fault current. That is why the tool calculates two things with the "CT saturation" engine: the time it takes to saturate (IEEE C37.110-2007 criterion) and whether the knee point is sufficient for Ktd·(If/N)·(RCT + burden), the SEL criterion form with the Siemens transient factor.

The "saturated CT" point plots the worst case explicitly: Idiff = (1 − delivered fraction)·I. If it falls above the characteristic, the relay depends on its saturation detector or on a high second slope (GE recommends 98 %). This is not a tool error: it is the reason those mechanisms exist.

High impedance

GE P14x§ 1.1Vs

Stabilising voltage and resistor

Vs ≥ K · If · (RCT + 2RL) · Rs = Vs/Ir − Rr

If is the largest external fault current in the CT secondary, RL the one-way resistance of the farthest lead and K a constant that depends on the application (1.0 and 1.2 in the GE P14x examples). For fault X/R up to 25 there is an advanced method, Vs = (0.0123·X/R + 0.68)·If·(2RL + RCT), used when it gives less than the equation with K = 1.0; it lowers the knee point needed.

GE P14x§ 1.3Iop

Primary operating current and knee point

Iop = CTR · (Ir + n · Ie) · VK ≥ 4 · Vs

n is the number of CTs in parallel and Ie the excitation current of each one at voltage Vs. On busbars, the operating current must be less than 30 % of the minimum fault and greater than the full load of the largest circuit.

GE P14x§ 7peak voltage and Metrosil

Peak voltage in an internal fault

Vp = 2√2 · √(VK · (Vf − VK)) · Vf = If · (RCT + 2RL + Rs + Rr)

If Vp exceeds 3,000 V peak, a varistor (Metrosil) is connected across the relay and its resistor. In the REF of a transformer or a generator the fault current is limited by the impedance and it is normally not needed.

Limits of the calculation

  • The factory values are those of the cited manuals, in the versions indicated (Siemens 7UT6x V4.67, GE T60 7.3x, SEL-387A 2007). Newer relay versions may have different ones. No ABB default value was verified.
  • The characteristic has three shapes: branches from base points (Siemens 7UT6x), slope from the origin (SEL-387A) and two breakpoints (GE T60), whose spline transition is approximated with a straight line. It does not model the overload zone of some relays. GE settings are converted to this tool's base with the ratio between the CT of the reference winding and its rated current.
  • The saturation detector, the dynamic additional restraint (Siemens) and the external-fault algorithm (SEL) are not modelled. The tool tells you when a fault with a saturated CT would fall outside the slope restraint and depend on them.
  • The inrush and overexcitation data, the CT excitation current, the fault currents and the errors are yours: no standard fixes them. The example cases are illustrative, except the two that reproduce the GE P14x examples.
  • It does not replace your relay settings or the coordination study. IEC 60255-187-1:2021 and IEEE C37.91-2021 were not consulted.

Frequently asked questions

What slope should be set on a transformer differential?

The slope must cover CT error, the tap changer range, excitation current and relay error. SEL-387A calculates 28.18 % from CT and tap changer alone (CT ±10 %, tap changer 90-110 %) and 36 % with excitation and relay error; with a CT error of 1 %, it uses a first slope of about 25 %. This tool adds up those errors with your data and shows you the external fault point on the characteristic.

Why can the differential trip for an external fault?

Because a CT can saturate from the DC component and remanence, and then the relay sees a differential current that does not exist. The GE T60 manual states that, with one saturated CT and one that is not, the Idiff/Irestraint ratio can reach 95-98 %; that is why the second slope is set high and relays have saturation detectors. The tool calculates the time the CT takes to saturate and compares it with the time-to-saturation you specify.

When is high-impedance protection used, and what settings does it need?

On busbars and in restricted earth fault protection, when CTs with the same ratio and similar magnetising characteristics are available. You set a voltage Vs above K·If·(RCT + 2·RL), using the external fault current and the resistance of the winding and of the farthest lead; a stabilising resistor Rs = Vs/Ir; and a CT knee point of at least 4 times Vs. If the peak voltage in an internal fault exceeds 3,000 V, a varistor (Metrosil) is connected.

We set your differential remotely

We review your transformer and CT data, calculate the TAP, slopes, blocking and high impedance, and load the settings into the relay, with no travel.

Related guides

Other tools

All tools
WhatsApp