Tiza Group

Home / Tools / Synchronizing and closing

Synchronizing and closing 25 and 78

Enter the voltages, frequencies and angle of both sides, the breaker closing time and the 25 relay settings. The tool calculates the slip, the advance angle, when the timed relay gives permission, at what angle the breaker closes and the maximum slip; if you enable it, also the time between the 78 blinders.

IEEE C50.12 / C50.13generator limits, quoted by SEL 2012SEL 2012generator synchronizing (Thompson)SEL 2003§ pp. 10-1378 blinder timer (Tziouvaras and Hou)

Example cases
Synchronizing and closing 25 and 78
ALearn

E1Application
kV
E2Both sides
kV

Side in service, the reference.

Hz
kV

Generator or line being connected.

Hz
°

Angle of the incoming side minus the bus angle, between −180° and 180°.

E3Breaker and closing method
ms

Measured on site or from the test report.

ms

Relay output, auxiliary relays and wiring up to the coil.

ms

Variation from one close to the next, ±.

E4Relay 25 settings
%

Allowed difference, ± of the bus voltage.

Hz
°

± on each side of zero.

ms

Time the angle must stay in the window before permission.

% Vn
% Vn
E5Out-of-step 78
pu or Ω

All three impedances on the same base, pu or ohms.

pu or Ω
pu or Ω
pu or Ω

Distance to the total-impedance line.

pu or Ω
Hz

The fastest one in the stability study.

ms
°

From the stability study.

Use a decimal point. The calculation runs in your browser and updates as you type.

Closing angle with the timed relay

—

Slip

—

Voltage difference

—

Angle speed

—

Slip cycle

—

Advance angle

—

Residual angle of the compensated close

—

Time inside the window

—

Permission left after the timer

—

Maximum slip to close inside the window

—

Angle at the outer blinder

—

Angle at the inner blinder

—

Time between blinders

—

Largest slip the 78 detects

—

Electrical centre from the relay

—

Bus, synchronizing breaker and 25 relay
  • Live side
  • Changing signal
Time simulation with your data: the angle turns with the slip, the relay runs the timer inside the window, closes its permissive contact and the breaker closes one closing time later. Long times are sped up; the factor is shown on the diagram.
Angle and beat voltage over one slip cycle
  • Angle between voltages
  • Voltage across contacts
  • Time marks
Top: the angle of the incoming side minus the bus angle, from now on; the band is the relay window. Bottom: the voltage across the open breaker, lowest at zero and highest in phase opposition.
Angle passing through the 25 relay window
  • Angle at its slip
  • At the maximum slip
  • Permission and contacts
Time counts from the moment the angle enters the window. The relay gives permission when the timer expires and the contacts touch one closing time later.
Swing and blinders on the R-X plane
  • Total impedance
  • Swing path
  • Outer blinders
  • Inner blinders
Two-machine model with equal sources and all impedances at the same angle, drawn at 85°. The origin is the relay, at the generator terminals.

Step-by-step calculation

Loading these settings into a relay? We configure it remotely.

What it is for

Before closing a breaker between two sources, a generator onto the bus or a line between two substations, three things must be compared: voltage, frequency and angle. This tool calculates the slip, the speed at which the angle turns, the advance angle a synchronizer needs and what a timed 25 relay does with its window: when it gives permission, at what angle the breaker closes and up to what slip the close lands inside the window.

If the incoming side is a generator, it compares the close with the design limits SEL quotes from IEEE C50.12 and C50.13. With the 78 block enabled it calculates the angle at which the swing crosses each blinder, the time between them and the electrical centre, to review the timer of the out-of-step protection.

How it is calculated

Own derivationrotating phasor

Slip, angle speed and beat voltage

s = f2 − f1 · φ(t) = φ0 + 360·s·t · Vb = √(V1² + V2² − 2·V1·V2·cos φ)

The incoming side at frequency f2 turns relative to the bus at frequency f1. A positive slip (incoming side faster) brings the angle to zero from the negative side; a negative one, from the positive side. A full turn takes 1/|s| seconds. The beat voltage is what a voltmeter reads between the two sides of the open breaker.

SEL 2012advance angle

Advance angle and residual

θadv = 360 · s · tclose · error = 360 · s · Δt

tclose adds the breaker time, the relay output and the auxiliaries. The synchronizer sends the command θadv before zero so the contacts touch in phase; an uncertainty Δt in the closing time leaves a residual angle.

Own derivationtimed 25 relay SEL 2012permissive contact

Timed window

tw = 2·Δφ / (360·|s|) · smax = 2·Δφ / (360·(tsup + tclose))

The relay gives permission if the angle stays inside ±Δφ for tsup; permission comes with the angle at −Δφ + 360·|s|·tsup (with its real sign) and the contacts touch tclose later. Permission lasts tw − tsup; if that is shorter than tclose, the permissive contact opens while the closing coil is still energized. At zero slip the angle does not move: there is permission only if it already sits inside the window.

Own derivationtwo-machine model SEL 2003§ pp. 10-13blinder timer

Out-of-step blinders (78)

δ = 2·atan(|Ztot| / (2·d)) · tcross = (δin − δout) / (360·fslip)

With equal sources and all impedances at the same angle, the impedance measured during the swing travels along the perpendicular bisector of Ztot = Zg + Zt + Zs, at a distance (|Ztot|/2)·cot(δ/2) from that line. The electrical centre, at δ = 180°, is the midpoint of Ztot. The function recognizes the swing if tcross exceeds the timer; the largest slip it detects is (δin − δout)/(360·t78).

Limits of the calculation

  • The voltage, slip and angle windows, the timer, the live and dead thresholds and the blinders are data of your installation: the relay manufacturer, the study and the grid operator set them. The tool does not propose settings.
  • The limits of ±10°, 0 to +5 % and ±0.067 Hz are design limits of the generator that SEL (Thompson, 2012) quotes from IEEE C50.12 and C50.13; those standards were not consulted. They are shown only when the incoming side is a generator and they are not settings of an installation.
  • The slip is assumed constant while the angle crosses the window: generator acceleration, the voltage regulator and breaker pole scatter are not modeled.
  • The dead-bus or dead-line state is classified with the thresholds you enter; the logic that allows closing under those conditions depends on how it is enabled in your relay.
  • The 78 block uses our own two-machine model with sources of equal magnitude and all impedances at the same angle. With unequal sources the path is no longer a straight line. Blinders, timer and slips are set from the stability study (SEL, Tziouvaras and Hou, 2003).
  • IEEE C37.102, IEEE 1547-2018 and the IEC 60255 parts on synchronism check were not consulted. It does not replace the stability study or the tests of the synchronizing scheme.

Frequently asked questions

What is the advance angle and how is it calculated?

It is the angle the phase difference travels while the breaker closes. If the command goes out as the angle passes through zero, the contacts touch later, with the angle already moved on. The synchronizer sends the command that many degrees early: 360 × slip × closing time. With 0.1 Hz and 100 ms of closing time that is 3.6°. The closing time includes the breaker, the relay output and the auxiliaries; an error in that time leaves a residual angle of 360 × slip × error.

Why does a timed 25 relay limit the slip?

The relay gives permission only if the angle stays inside the window for the supervision timer. The angle crosses a ±Δφ window in 2·Δφ/(360·|s|) seconds; if that time is shorter than the timer, there is no permission. That is why the timer replaces a slip measurement: with ±10° and 300 ms, permission is given up to 0.185 Hz, and the close stays inside the window up to a somewhat lower slip, because the closing time adds to the timer.

How are the 78 blinders related to the slip?

During a swing the measured impedance moves with the angle between the sources. Each blinder corresponds to an angle, and the time between the outer and the inner blinder is the angle difference divided by 360 times the slip. If the impedance crosses faster than the timer, the function does not recognize the swing; that is why the timer is set from the fastest slip of the stability study.

We review your synchronizing scheme

We review the settings of the 25 relay or the synchronizer against the real time of your breaker, and the 78 blinders against your stability study, with no travel.

Related guides

Other tools

All tools
WhatsApp