Tiza Group

Home / Tools / Ground fault and neutral

Ground fault and neutral grounding

Enter your source, the capacitive current of the network and the neutral type: the tool calculates the single line-to-earth fault current, the neutral voltage and the voltage of the healthy phases and the coil tuning, and checks whether 50N, 67N, 59N and 64S see the fault.

IEC 60909-0§ 7.5single line-to-earth fault currentIEC 60071-2earth-fault factor, annex BIEEE 242§ 8.2grounding methodsIEEE C37.102§ 3.2generator grounding

Example cases
Ground fault and neutral grounding

Only the basic data; the rest is taken with typical values.

ALearn

E1Network and source
kV

Line to line.

MVA

Short-circuit power at the bus, with the transformer included.

E2Network capacitance
A

Of all the connected cables and lines, in a bolted fault. It comes from the cable data or from a measurement.

%
E3Neutral
A

IEEE 242-2001: 200 to 500 A, resistor of about 10 s.

A

IEEE 242-2001: equal to or slightly larger than the charging current. IEEE C37.102-2006 (generator): 3 to 25 A.

%

IEEE C37.102-2006: 25 to 100 %.

%

(IC − IL)/IC. Positive: the coil is short; negative: over-compensated.

A
E4Fault
Ω

0 is a bolted fault.

s

Until the protection opens. Without clearing: 3,600 s.

E5Feeder protections
A

Primary. 0 switches it off.

A

Primary. It compares the component the method uses: active with a coil, reactive with an isolated neutral, total in the others. 0 switches it off.

%

Of the phase voltage. 0 switches it off.

%
%
%
E6Generator (64S)
kV
A

With high resistance: 3 to 25 A (IEEE C37.102-2006).

V

IEEE 242-2001 and C37.102-2006: 120 or 240 V.

V

On the secondary. IEEE C37.102-2006: about 5 V as a minimum.

Use a decimal point. The calculation runs in your browser and updates as you type.

Single line-to-earth fault current

— A

Neutral current

— A

Neutral voltage

— V

Earth-fault factor

—

Ik1 over the three-phase current

— %

From the fault to the trip: instrument transformers, relay and coil
  • Active signal
  • Power circuit
The signals the fault activates light up: 3I0 from the core-balance transformer, 3V0 from the broken delta, the functions that pick up, the gates and the command to the trip coil.
Phase voltages, neutral displacement and sequence networks
  • Faulted phase
  • Healthy phases
  • Displaced neutral
The solid arrows are the phase-to-earth voltages during the fault; the dashed ones, those before it. The neutral arrow is the zero-sequence voltage. Below, the three sequence networks in series with 3·RF.
The same fault with each neutral type
  • Chosen method
Same source and same capacitance. The scale is logarithmic: each mark is ten times the previous one.
Residual current seen by each feeder
  • Faulted feeder
  • 50N and 67N pickups
The faulted feeder sees the current in the opposite direction to the healthy ones. With an isolated neutral or a coil that current is small and a simple overcurrent cannot tell which feeder it is.

Step-by-step calculation

Sensitivity of the protections

The methods side by side

Need it for a real project? We carry out the full study, with its report.

What it is for

The way the neutral is connected to earth decides how much current flows in a single line-to-earth fault, how much the voltages of the healthy phases rise, whether the fault can be kept or must be cleared, and which function detects it. This tool compares the five methods on the same network: solid neutral, low or high resistance, reactance, Petersen coil and isolated neutral.

With the capacitive current of your network and the source data it calculates the fault current, the neutral current and voltage, the earth-fault factor, the tuning of the coil and the resistor, and checks whether 50N/51N, 67N, 59N and 64S see the fault with the margin you choose.

How it is calculated

IEC 60909-0§ 7.5formula (54)

Single line-to-earth fault current

IF = 3·E / |Z1 + Z2 + Z0 + 3·RF|

The three sequence networks are connected in series. E is the phase voltage (with the IEC 60909-0:2016 c factor for the current), Z1 and Z2 come from the short-circuit power of the source and Z0 is the zero-sequence impedance seen from the fault.

A. Eberle§ IL 21zero-sequence circuit

Zero-sequence impedance

Z0 = 1 / [ 1/(Z0s + 3·Zn) + G + j·ω·C ]

Z0s is the zero-sequence impedance of the source, Zn that of the neutral (the resistor, reactance or coil, three times in the zero-sequence circuit), C the capacitance of one phase to earth and G the losses of the network. In an isolated neutral there is no path through the neutral and only the capacitance remains.

Schneider CT 203§ p. 14tuned coil

Tuning and residual current

L·3C·ω² = 1 · v = (IC − IL)/IC · Ires ≈ IC·√(v² + d²)

v is the detuning and d the damping (the loss current over IC). With exact tuning and no losses the fault current would be zero: what remains is the detuning and resistive current.

IEC 60071-2§ Anexo Bearth-fault factor

Earth-fault factor

k = max(|Vb|, |Vc|) / (E)

It is the highest voltage of the healthy phases during the fault divided by the phase voltage without the fault. It is calculated with the sequence voltages and Fortescue. It is 1 with Z0 = Z1 and tends to √3 in isolated or resonant networks.

What changes with each neutral

  • Solid: the fault current is high, close to the three-phase one or larger when Z0 is smaller than Z1 (IEC 60909-0:2016, §7.5); the healthy phases hardly rise. It should be cleared quickly (Schneider CT 203, p. 16).
  • Low resistance: the current is limited to a few hundred amperes and the fault is cleared with a 50N/51N. The resistor is sized for about 10 s (IEEE 242-2001, §8.2.3).
  • High resistance: the current is equal to or slightly larger than the capacitive one, a few amperes, and it reduces transients. The fault can be kept until a convenient time if the cable withstands the phase-to-phase voltage (IEEE 242-2001, §8.2.4).
  • Reactance: it limits the current to a fraction of the three-phase one. With X0/X1 of 3 or less the system is still effectively grounded (IEEE C37.102-2006, §3.2.3).
  • Petersen coil: it compensates the capacitive current and leaves about 2 to 20 A (Schneider CT 203, p. 14). Locating the fault needs a directional residual overcurrent or residual power protection (p. 15), which uses the active component.
  • Isolated: the current is only the capacitive one and the two healthy phases rise to the phase-to-phase voltage. Keeping the fault exposes the network to a second fault (Schneider CT 203, pp. 13-14; IEEE 242-2001, §8.2.5).

Protections

The tool evaluates the settings you enter; it does not propose settings. The 50N/51N compares the pickup with the fault current (with the fault resistance you choose) and with the capacitive current of the biggest healthy feeder, which must not trip it. The 67N uses the component of the residual current that the method allows to tell apart. The 59N compares its pickup with the zero-sequence voltage and with the natural neutral displacement.

For a generator with high resistance, the 59N with about 5 V on the secondary of the distribution transformer leaves 2 to 5 % of the winding near the neutral uncovered (IEEE C37.102-2006, §4.3.3.1.1). A low-frequency injection 64S or a third-harmonic one covers that zone; their settings depend on the manufacturer and are not calculated here.

Limits of the calculation

  • Fault model at the source bus, with the feeder represented by its capacitance: it does not calculate the voltage along a feeder or the touch and step voltages. For that, see the grounding resistance tool.
  • The single line-to-earth fault current of an isolated or resonant-earthed system is not a short-circuit current in the sense of IEC 60909-0:2016: here it is calculated with the capacitive circuit of A. Eberle's letter 21.
  • The damping, the natural neutral displacement, the split of the capacitance among feeders, the sensitivity margins and the relay settings have no typical value with a source: they are data of your network.
  • It does not model ferroresonance, intermittent faults with restriking or the harmonic current of the coil. The R0/X1 ≤ 1 value of IEEE C62.92 was not consulted: the «effectively grounded» check uses only X0/X1 ≤ 3.
  • It does not replace the network study, the design of the resistor or the coil, or the setting of the protections.

Frequently asked questions

What current flows in an earth fault with an isolated neutral?

Only the capacitive current of the cables and lines of the whole connected network, which leads the voltage by 90°. It is usually a few amperes in a plant and can exceed 10 A in a network of long cables. The faulted phase goes to zero and the two healthy ones rise to the phase-to-phase voltage, a factor of √3.

What does a Petersen coil do?

It is connected between the neutral and earth and its inductance is tuned to the network capacitance (L·3C·ω² = 1). In a fault, the inductive current of the coil cancels almost all the capacitive one and the current that remains, a few amperes, is the one due to detuning and losses. Many arcs extinguish themselves.

When is a system said to be effectively grounded?

The IEEE C37.102-2006 guide recommends keeping the X0/X1 ratio at 3 or less. With X0/X1 = 3 and no fault resistance, the earth-fault factor of the healthy phases is 1.25 (calculation with symmetrical components) and the single line-to-earth fault current is a large part of the three-phase one.

We study the grounding of your network

We calculate the capacitive current of your network, compare the neutral methods, size the resistor or the coil and set the earth-fault protections.

Related guides

Other tools

All tools
WhatsApp