Tiza Group

Home / Tools / PPC control tests

PPC control tests

Pick the test in the tabs, enter the controller settings and simulate the plant or paste your record. The tool finds each step, measures Tr, Te and overshoot with the 3 % bands, estimates the droop and deadband, measures the worst-minute ramp and the mean rate, and compares each result with CREG 060 and the CNO agreements.

CREG 060 de 2019§ art. 2 y 14 aTr, Te and voltage controlCREG 060 de 2019§ art. 12power and frequency controlCREG 060 de 2019§ art. 15start-up and shutdown rampCREG 101 104 de 2026§ art. 8 (num. 7.7)tests before commercial operationAcuerdo CNO 1987§ anexo 1, num. 4.2voltage control testsAcuerdo CNO 1826§ annex (pending)power and frequency testsAcuerdo CNO 1849§ Annexes 1 and 2 (pending)load take-up and drop rate

Example cases
PPC control tests

Only the basic data; the rest is taken with typical values.

ALearn

E1Plant and connection
kV
MW

Net effective capacity of the plant.

s
s
E2Voltage control test
MW

At maximum power it must be at least 80 % of Pn.

MVA

Grid of the simulated plant: with more short-circuit power the voltage moves less with the reactive power.

s

Below 1 gives overshoot and oscillation; 1 or more, a response without overshoot.

s
p.u.
Voltage test record

One row per sample at the point of connection: time, set point (p.u., Mvar or power factor depending on the mode), voltage and reactive power.

RowtsSet pointVp.u.QMvarRemove

E3Set point and mode settings
p.u.
p.u.
Mvar

Positive capacitive (delivered), negative inductive.

Mvar
%

A middle value of the range the controller allows.

% Pn
E2Power and frequency test
%
mHz

Controller setting: the resolution does not say whether the deadband is subtracted.

MW
MW
Hz
Hz

Same as the first for a single step. With two steps outside the deadband, the deadband is estimated too.

s
s
Frequency test record

One row per sample: time, frequency injected into the controller and active power at the point of connection.

RowtsfHzPMWRemove

E2Load take-up and drop ramp
% Pn/min

14 % at first; the CND may revise it.

MW/min

0 if you have not declared it yet.

%
MW
MW
MW/min
Ramp record

One row per sample: time and active power at the point of connection, from before the order until the power settles.

RowtsPMWRemove

Use a decimal point. The calculation runs in your browser and updates as you type.

Response time Tr

—

Settling time Te

—

Step overshoot

—

Droop estimated from the record

—

Worst-minute ramp

—

Measured mean rate

—

Plant, controller and test signal
The signals the test uses light up: the test kit sends the set point or the frequency to the controller, which sends set points to the inverters; voltage and current are recorded at the point of connection. The controller frame turns green if the test passes and red if it fails.
Recorded response with the 3 % bands
  • Recorded response
  • Set point or frequency
  • 3 % bands
Top: reactive power (voltage) or active power (frequency); bottom: the set point or the injected frequency. Each step has its ±3 % band of the change around the final value and its Tr and Te marks, counted from the set point change.
Droop estimated from the steady points of the record
  • Record points and fitted line
  • Setting characteristic
  • Deadband
Each point is the steady value of one plateau of the record. The slope of the fitted line is the droop; in frequency, the deadband is where the line crosses the axis.
Active power and worst minute of the ramp
  • Recorded power
  • Maximum ramp in force
  • 60 s window
The band marks the minute with the largest power change; the dashed line is the maximum ramp in force from the start of that window. The two points mark 3 % and 97 % of the change, between which the mean rate is measured.

Step-by-step calculation

What it is for

Before commercial operation, a solar or wind plant connected to the STN or the STR must show the CND that its power plant controller (PPC) regulates voltage, responds to frequency and limits its ramp as CREG 060 of 2019 requires. This tool reads the record of each test, or simulates a plant for practice, and gives the figures that are reported: Tr, Te and overshoot of each step, estimated droop and deadband, worst-minute ramp and mean rate.

Use it to prepare the tests, tune the controller before the site visit and review the records in the field, before writing the report.

The list of tests comes from numeral 7.7 of the Código de Operación, as amended by article 8 of CREG 101 104 of 2026: power and frequency control (ii), start-up and shutdown ramp, which accepts laboratory or factory certificates and field tests (iii), and reactive power and voltage control (iv). After commercial operation starts, the CND follows up with records of at least 10 samples per second; the voltage test record still requires 100 samples per second (CNO Agreement 1987). CREG 101 104 de 2026§ art. 8num. 7.7, tests

How it is calculated

CREG 060 de 2019§ art. 2Tr and Te Acuerdo CNO 1987§ anexo 1, num. 4.2steps

Step times

|y(t0 + Tr) − y0| = 0.03·Δ · |y(t) − yf| ≤ 0.03·Δ for t ≥ t0 + Te · Δ = |yf − y0|

t0 is the instant the set point or the frequency changes; y0, the steady value before the step, and yf, the expected final value. In voltage control the reactive power is read and Tr under 2 s and Te under 10 s are required; in frequency the active power is read and Tr of 2 s or less and Te of 15 s or less are required. The overshoot is how far the signal goes past yf, as a percentage of Δ.

CREG 060 de 2019§ art. 2voltage droop

Voltage droop from the record

Vref − V = s · Q/Qbase

A least-squares line is fitted to the steady value of each plateau; its slope is the droop s. It is compared with the droop set in the controller. The reactive power base is assumed to be 0.33 Pn.

CREG 060 de 2019§ art. 12droop and deadband

Frequency droop and deadband

ΔP/Pn = −(Δf − b)/(fn·R)

R is the droop and b the deadband. With two or more plateaus outside the deadband, the fitted line gives R by its slope and b by where it crosses the frequency axis; with a single plateau the deadband setting is used. The resolution requires R of 2 % to 6 % and b of 0 to 120 mHz, initially 30 mHz or less.

CREG 060 de 2019§ art. 15ramp Acuerdo CNO 1849§ considerationsdeclared rate

Ramp and load take-up rate

max |P(t + 60 s) − P(t)| ≤ r·Pn · v = 0.94·ΔP/(t97 − t3) · |tmeasured − tdeclared| ≤ 0.05·tdeclared

r is the maximum ramp in force, 14 % per minute at first. The mean rate v is measured between 3 % and 97 % of the change, our own criterion while the method of Annex 1 of CNO Agreement 1849 is pending. The 5 % tolerance on the declared time is the one that agreement quotes from numeral 7.6 of CREG 025 of 1995.

Limits of the calculation

  • Pending: the annex of CNO Agreement 1826, with the procedure of the power and frequency test (size and number of steps, record resolution and format), and article 5 of CREG 023 of 2001, which says how the response is verified at the point of connection. The tool applies only the values of article 12 of CREG 060.
  • Pending: Annexes 1 and 2 of CNO Agreement 1849, with the test plan, the rate calculation and the report format. The mean rate between 3 % and 97 % is our own criterion, and the 5 % tolerance is applied to the recorded span, although CREG 025 writes it from 0 MW to the effective capacity.
  • The expected final value of each step is taken from the record (mean of the last second of each plateau), unless you pick the set point or the droop law in Advanced mode.
  • The reactive power base of the voltage droop is not defined in the resolution: 0.33 Pn is assumed and can be changed.
  • The local and remote set point reception test, the capability curve, voltage dips and fast reactive current are not calculated here. SDL plants have other rules.
  • The simulated plant is our own teaching model, not the validated model of your plant.
  • A step whose record ends before the maximum Te plus the steady value window, or that is still changing at the end, stays pending: it is not taken as a pass.
  • The 5 % tolerance of the declared rate is read without a sign: the measured time must be within 5 % of the declared time, above or below.
  • CREG 101 104 of 2026 did not change the voltage control (num. 5.7 a), power and frequency (art. 12) or ramp (num. 5.8) requirements this tool uses.
  • On the SDL, CREG 070 (chapter 11, num. 11.2.1.2 g, and chapter 12, num. 12.2.1.2 g) requires the same Tr of 2 s or less and Te of 15 s or less from the power and frequency control, but chapter 12 sets no Tr or Te for the voltage control. This tool does not calculate SDL plants.

Frequently asked questions

How are Tr and Te measured in the voltage control test?

On the reactive power record at the point of connection, counted from the moment the set point is sent. Tr is the time for the reactive power to move 3 % of the expected change; Te, the time for it to enter the ±3 % band around the final value and not leave it again. CREG 060 requires Tr under 2 s and Te under 10 s in the voltage, reactive power and power factor modes.

What does the frequency control test of a solar plant require?

The control must have a droop adjustable from 2 % to 6 % and a deadband from 0 to 120 mHz, initially 30 mHz or less, and respond to a step with Tr of 2 s or less and Te of 15 s or less, without oscillating. Today solar and wind plants are exempt from the low-frequency response. The detailed procedure is in the annex of CNO Agreement 1826.

What ramp may a solar plant have at start-up?

CREG 060 sets an initial maximum ramp of 14 % of rated power per minute at start-up and shutdown, with the primary resource available; the CND may revise it. Separately, the agent declares its load take-up and drop rate to the CND and demonstrates it with a test, under CNO Agreement 1849.

Related guides

Other tools

All tools
WhatsApp