Home / Tools / Breaker failure 50BF
Breaker failure 50BF and transfer trip
Enter the times of your protection, your breaker and your teleprotection channel: the tool calculates the minimum 50BF delay and the total backup clearing time with the transfer trip, compares it with the critical time and tells you what happens with a fault in the dead zone.
ABB REB670§ 3.6.3equation 46 of the backup delayCDEC-SING 1406-UIS-GT3§ 4.4detector and timersIEC 61850-7-4logical node RBRF
Results
— ms
— ms
— ms
—
Charts
- Failed breaker
- Timer and channel
- Healthy breaker
- Power
- Protection zone
How it was calculated and standards
Step-by-step calculation
Loading these settings into a relay? We configure it remotely.
What it is for
Breaker failure protection (ANSI 50BF, logical node RBRF in IEC 61850) operates when a protection has ordered a breaker to open and current keeps flowing. After its delay it trips the adjacent breakers and, in a line bay, sends a direct transfer trip to the remote end.
That delay has two limits. If it is too short, the 50BF trips the bus even though the breaker opened correctly. If it is too long, the backup clearing exceeds the time the system tolerates without losing stability. This tool calculates both sides with the times of your installation.
How it is calculated
ABB REB670§ 3.6.3.2equation 46 and figure 69
Minimum backup trip delay
t2 ≥ t1 + tbreak + treset + tmargint1 is the retrip delay (zero without retrip), tbreak the maximum time in which the breaker interrupts the current, treset the maximum time in which the 50BF current detector recognises that the breaker opened, and tmargin a safety margin. The manual gives a typical t2 setting of 90 to 200 ms, with 150 ms by default, and a t1 of 0 to 5 ms.
ABB REB670§ 3.6.3.2critical time
Total backup clearing time
Tlocal = tprot + t2 + t86 + tbreak adjacent · Tremote = tprot + t2 + t86 + tchannel + tremote relay + tbreak remoteThe total clearing time is the longer of the two. It is compared with the critical clearing time given by the stability study, measured from fault inception: the ABB REB670 manual states that the total clearing time is usually required to be shorter than that critical time.
CDEC-SING 1406-UIS-GT3§ 4.4current detector
Current detector setting
0.1 × In CT ≤ Ipickup ≤ 0.8 × Ifault minThe CDEC-SING technical guide (Chile) recommends that window for phase or residual faults. If the minimum fault is lower than 0.125 times the CT rated current, the window is empty: the auxiliary contact criterion (52a) is needed, which the same guide combines with the current criterion in an OR gate.
Dead zone and transfer trip
The dead zone is the section between the CT and the breaker. With the CT on the line side, the bus protection sees the fault and opens the breaker, but the line keeps feeding it from the other end: the remote end must be tripped. With the CT on the bus side, the line protection opens the breaker, but the bus keeps feeding the fault: the bus section must be tripped. With the breaker closed, those faults clear with the 50BF delay or by remote backup (ABB REB670 application manual, pp. 100-102).
With the breaker open, the same manual describes taking the CT measurement out of the bus zone after a time, for example 400 ms on cable or transformer feeders, or the longest reclosing dead time plus 300 ms on overhead lines, and enabling a fast overcurrent element, usually with a 40 ms delay, that trips only the remote end.
The trip to the remote end is direct: it opens without waiting for the remote protection to see the fault. In a permissive scheme such as PUTT the remote end trips only if its own element sees the fault, so it does not work as a breaker failure trip.
Limits of the calculation
- The typical values come from a manufacturer (ABB REB670) and a system operator (CDEC-SING, Chile, installations above 100 kV). They are not a national standard. The IEEE C37.119 guide was not consulted for this tool.
- The safety margin, the breaker, lockout relay and channel times and the critical time have no sourced typical value: they are data of your installation, of the breaker timing test and of the stability study. The example cases are illustrative.
- It does not model each manufacturer's logic (2-out-of-4 criterion, multi-phase start, faulty breaker alarm) or the residual current of a saturated CT, which lengthens the detector reset.
- It does not replace the stability study or the setting of your relay. It is a timing check.
Frequently asked questions
How is the 50BF delay calculated?
The backup trip delay t2 must be at least the sum of the retrip delay t1, the maximum break time of the breaker, the reset time of the current detector and a safety margin. It is equation 46 of the ABB REB670 application manual. With a healthy breaker the detector resets before t2 expires and there is no backup trip.
What is the typical breaker failure timer setting?
The ABB REB670 manual gives a typical setting of 90 to 200 ms, with 150 ms by default. The CDEC-SING technical guide (Chile) recommends 100 to 200 ms and suggests 150 ms when the breaker has no mechanical particularities. The value for your project comes from the calculation with the measured times of your breaker and relay.
Why does the 50BF of a line send a transfer trip?
Because if the line breaker does not open, the fault is still fed from the remote end. The 50BF opens the adjacent breakers in the substation and sends a direct transfer trip to the remote end, which opens without waiting for its own protection to see the fault.
We set your 50BF remotely
We review the times of your breaker and relay, calculate the delay and the backup trip destinations, and load the settings into the relay, without travelling.
Related guides
Other tools
All tools
Solar energy
PV system sizingPV production and energy costPV I-V curveAGPE classifier and connection proceduresCable voltage dropSolar plants and the grid codeP-Q capability testPPC control testsPlant model validationCND supervision indicatorsPMU tests and commissioningRenewable energy tax incentives (Colombia)
Protection
Function 50/51 overcurrentFunction 27/59 voltageFunction 81 frequencyFunction 67/67N directionalFunction 46 negative sequenceFunction 49 thermal overloadFunction 25 synchronism checkFunction 32 reverse powerFunction 51V voltage overcurrentFunction 64G stator groundFunction 27TN third harmonicFunction 64F rotor groundFunction 78 out-of-stepFunction 50/27 inadvertent energizationFunction 37 undercurrentFunction 38 bearingsFunction 48 incomplete sequenceFunction 66 starts per hourFunction 51LR locked rotorFunction 14 underspeedFunction 47 phase sequenceFunction 59N residual overvoltageFunction 60 fuse failureFunction 55 power factorFunction 46BC broken conductorFunction 68 power swing blockingFunction 87N restricted earth faultFunction 63 Buchholz and pressureFunction 26 oil temperatureFunction 71 oil levelFunction 87B bus differentialFunction 60C bank unbalanceFunction 51G neutral groundFunction 79 reclosingFunction 86 lockoutFunction 94 tripFunction 74 trip supervisionFunction 87L line differentialPhasor diagramRelay coordinationCurrent transformer: burden and saturationVector group compensation (87T)Frequency df/dt ramp87 differential settingCT and VT selectorDistance setting 21MV feeder coordinationMotor protectionBoundary meteringGenerator protectionLoad shedding 81 and UVLSShunt reactorSynchronizing and closing 25/78Secondary arc and single-pole reclosing
Analysis and communications
COMTRADE records: viewer and generatorOscillography analysisIEC 61850 SCL viewerIEC 61850 SCL auditorIEC 61850 network: GOOSE/SV addresses and process busIEC 60870-5-104 APDU decoderIEC 61850 to IEC 60870-5-104 and 101 mappingICCP bilateral table checkerIP and VLAN planDNP3 and Modbus decoderTeleprotection channel timeOptical and radio link budgetTime synchronisationMMS control sequenceGOOSE simulatorIEC 61850 station networkInterlocking table and CILO equationsCause-and-effect matrix and logic checkerZones and conduits (IEC 62443-3-2)Zone firewall rule reviewerRoles and permissions (IEC 62351-8)IED X.509 certificate verifierDevice hardening baselineIncident response exercise (CNO 2188)Cybersecurity gap: CNO and IEC 62443
Equipment testing and diagnostics
Commissioning checklistCurrent transformer testsDisconnector and GIS switchgear testsGrounding system testsPower cable testsVoltage transformer testsInsulation diagnosis: dissolved gases (DGA) and temperature correctionTransformer TTR testTransformer winding resistanceTransformer insulation, PI and DARTransformer power factor and capacitanceTransformer excitation currentTransformer SFRATransformer leakage reactanceTap changer dynamic resistanceCalibration and uncertaintyPCB equipment: classification and deadlinesRETIE pre-inspectionTransformer test interpreterCircuit breaker testsTest budgetMaintenance plan and health indexSF6 inventory and leakage
Electrical studies
Lightning protectionShort circuit and per-unit systemGround fault and neutralShort-circuit checkerPower transformerTransformer noiseSafety clearancesArc flashGrounding resistancePower-frequency electric and magnetic fieldsCurrent split factor SfApproach boundariesSubstation configuration selectorBusbar stressesInsulation co-ordinationTRV and short-line faultGenerator circuit-breakerInductive load switchingSwitch-fuse combinationDisconnector and earthing switchMV switchgear and GIS specifierMV cable insulation levelInsulator strings: mechanical checkSeismic qualification of substation equipmentSurge protective device selectionElectric vehicle charging station
Yard equipment control
Circuit breaker controlDisconnector controlTransformer controlMV switchgear controlCapacitor bank controlAuxiliary services controlIEC 61850 bay controllerRecloser control
Industry and power quality
Motor startingHarmonic distortion THD and TDDEquipment harmonic emissionHarmonic emission allocationCapacitor bankBattery sizingRegulatory quality indicatorsCapacitor bank protectionSubstation DC systemsPower qualityGenerating sets to ISO 8528Lighting design to RETILAPControl valve Cv and Kv and affinity laws
