Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

California Rule 21: Distribution Interconnection Guide

California Rule 21 explained: which generators it covers, the Fast Track and Supplemental Review path, smart inverter rules and how it differs from CAISO.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

4.0 MW peak loadWhutility metermain breakerprotectionrelaytrip=~=~existing 0.35 MWnew 0.45 MWPowerMeasure / tripApplication + single-line diagramFast Trackscreens pass?yesAgreement withoutdetailed studynoSupplemental ReviewClears theconcern?yesnoDetailed study(upgrades possible)total: 0.35 + 0.45 = 0.80 MW0.80 / 4.0 = 20% > 15% (assumed limit)fails the screen: Supplemental Review0.25 MW: 0.60 / 4.0 = 15%, meets itPathApplyFast TrackSupplementalDetailedAgreement© tizagrp.com4.0 MW peak loadWhutility metermain breakerprotectionrelaytrip=~=~existing 0.35 MWnew 0.45 MWPowerMeasure / tripApplication + single-line diagramFast Trackscreens pass?yesAgreement withoutdetailed studynoSupplemental ReviewClears theconcern?yesnoDetailed study(upgrades possible)total: 0.35 + 0.45 = 0.80 MW0.80 / 4.0 = 20% > 15% (assumed limit)fails the screen: Supplemental Review0.25 MW: 0.60 / 4.0 = 15%, meets itPathApplyFast TrackSupplementalDetailedAgreement© tizagrp.com
Rule 21: a single-line diagram of a distribution connection with the utility meter, main breaker, protection relay with its current and voltage transformers, the existing 0.35 MW and the new 0.45 MW inverter, and the review path from Fast Track to Supplemental Review and detailed study, where an assumed 15 percent screen fails at 20 percent. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Rule 21 is the California tariff, approved by the California Public Utilities Commission, that sets how generators and storage connect to the distribution systems of the large investor-owned utilities. Projects pass screens in a Fast Track review, move to Supplemental Review if they fail, and otherwise need a detailed study. Smart inverter functions are part of the technical requirements.

Short answer

Rule 21 is the California tariff that governs interconnection of generation and storage to the distribution system of the state’s investor-owned utilities, such as Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E), Southern California Edison (SCE) and San Diego Gas & Electric (SDG&E). The California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) approves it and each utility files its own copy. It is not a process of the California Independent System Operator (CAISO). CAISO studies resources that connect to the CAISO-controlled grid, which is covered in the CAISO cluster guide. The wider US picture is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide.

The review path

Rule 21 sets a staged path, in plain terms:

  1. Application. The customer applies to the utility with a single-line diagram and equipment data.
  2. Fast Track. The utility runs a set of screens, such as the effect on the local line and on fault current. A project that passes all of them can go on to an agreement without a detailed study.
  3. Supplemental Review. A project that fails a screen can ask for this additional review, which looks at the specific concern. If it clears, the project proceeds.
  4. Detailed study. A project that does not clear the earlier steps gets a full interconnection study and may need upgrades.

The thresholds, fees and times are in each utility’s current tariff, and they have changed over the years as the CPUC revised the rule. Use the tariff on the utility’s website and the CPUC’s rulemaking record for the current text.

Smart inverter requirements

Rule 21 requires advanced inverter functions. In Decision D.14-12-035, the CPUC adopted the recommendations of its Smart Inverter Working Group, and later work added communication and operational details. The functions are the grid-support behaviors, such as voltage and reactive power control and ride-through, that the inverter must provide. The technical basis is built on IEEE 1547 and on UL 1741 certification. See IEEE 1547-2018, UL 1741 SB and volt-var, watt-var and volt-watt for the standards. A comparison of 1547 with other countries is in IEEE 1547 vs G99 vs AS/NZS 4777 vs CSA.

In practice the utility and CPUC decide which functions are enabled and how they are set. The installer needs the current settings table from the utility, not the factory default.

Where Rule 21 sits among other rules

  • Wholesale sales. A generator on the distribution system that sells into the wholesale market normally connects under the utility’s Wholesale Distribution Access Tariff (WDAT), which FERC regulates, not under Rule 21. Confirm which one applies.
  • The building code. The National Electrical Code applies inside the customer’s installation, as described in NEC Article 705.
  • Other regions. See PJM, MISO and ERCOT.

Worked example (illustrative)

The threshold below is an assumption chosen to show how a screen works. Do not use it as the current Rule 21 value.

Assumptions. A feeder section has an annual peak load of 4.0 MW. Existing generation on the section is 0.35 MW. A customer applies to add a 0.45 MW solar-plus-storage system. Assume a screen compares total generation to section load and uses a limit of 15 percent.

Step 1. Total generation after the project. 0.35 + 0.45 = 0.80 MW.

Step 2. Ratio to load. 0.80 ÷ 4.0 = 0.20, or 20 percent.

Step 3. Compare with the assumed limit. 20 percent is above 15 percent, so the project fails this screen.

Step 4. Options. The project can go to Supplemental Review, reduce its size, or limit export. A size of 0.25 MW gives (0.35 + 0.25) ÷ 4.0 = 15 percent, which just meets the limit. Whether export limiting counts depends on the tariff.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Identify the utility and its current Rule 21 tariff and application forms.
  • Confirm whether the project is retail, export or wholesale.
  • Prepare the single-line diagram, equipment data and certification documents.
  • Check the screens against the feeder data the utility provides.
  • Get the utility’s current smart inverter settings and apply them.
  • Plan commissioning tests and the utility’s permission to operate.
  • Have the engineer of record review the package before submission.

The path above is general orientation. The utility’s Rule 21 tariff and the CPUC’s decisions decide each case. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States. We deliver engineering ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp.

How Tiza can help

A Rule 21 package needs a clear single-line diagram, protection details and inverter data that agree with each other. Tiza provides engineering design for solar and storage, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with your site data and the utility’s feeder information.

Figure: single-line diagram of a distribution connection with the inverter, the main breaker, the protection relay and the utility meter.

References

  • Electric Rule 21 of PG&E, SCE and SDG&E, as approved by the CPUC, and the CPUC rulemaking record on Rule 21.
  • CPUC Decision D.14-12-035 on smart inverter functions.
  • IEEE Std 1547-2018 and UL 1741.

Frequently asked questions

Is Rule 21 a CAISO rule?

No. Rule 21 is a tariff of the California investor-owned utilities approved by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC). CAISO runs a separate process for resources that connect to the CAISO-controlled grid, described in the CAISO cluster guide.

What happens if a project fails the Fast Track screens?

It can go to Supplemental Review, where the utility studies the concerns the screens raised. If that is not enough, a detailed interconnection study follows. The utility's current Rule 21 tariff sets the screens, steps and fees.

Do smart inverter functions apply to every project?

Rule 21 includes smart inverter requirements that come from the CPUC's work with its Smart Inverter Working Group. Which functions apply and how they must be set depends on the current tariff and the utility's instructions, so read both before design.

WhatsApp