Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

IEEE 1547 Commissioning Tests: DER Verification Checklist

IEEE 1547 commissioning tests: what a utility checks before a DER runs in parallel with the grid, with a volt-var example and an engineer's checklist.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

utility gridbreakerQanalyzer=~500 kVAPV arraysettings readfrom the deviceapprovedsettings tablematch?signed recordPowerMeasureCommstest source holds 1.035 pu0.015 / 0.030 = 0.50 of the slope0.50 x 44% x 500 kVA = 110 kvarmeasured 104 kvar: 6 / 500 = 1.2%inside the 2% band: this point passesV (pu)Q absorbed, % of rated kVA0.981.021.051.035expected 110 kvarmeasured 104 kvarsecond point at 1.05 pu confirms the slope endChecksSettingsProtectionFunctionsReconnectRecord© tizagrp.comutility gridbreakerQanalyzer=~500 kVAPV arraysettings readfrom the deviceapprovedsettings tablematch?signed recordPowerMeasureCommstest source holds 1.035 pu0.015 / 0.030 = 0.50 of the slope0.50 x 44% x 500 kVA = 110 kvarmeasured 104 kvar: 6 / 500 = 1.2%inside the 2% band: this point passesV (pu)Q absorbed, % of rated kVA0.981.021.051.035expected 110 kvarmeasured 104 kvarsecond point at 1.05 pu confirms the slope endChecksSettingsProtectionFunctionsReconnectRecord© tizagrp.com
IEEE 1547 commissioning: a 500 kVA inverter with its breaker, power analyzer, settings read from the device and the approved settings table, and the volt-var check at 1.035 per unit. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

IEEE 1547 commissioning tests confirm, on site, that a distributed energy resource behaves the way the interconnection agreement says before it runs in parallel with the utility. They check the installed settings, the protection and the grid-support functions, and they leave a record the utility can accept.

IEEE 1547 commissioning tests are the last gate between a finished installation and permission to operate in parallel with the utility. The inverters have a listing and the single-line diagram has been approved. The open question is whether the installed equipment actually does what the agreement says.

This guide is based on IEEE 1547-2018 with its 2020 amendment, and on IEEE 1547.1-2020 for test procedures. Your utility’s technical requirements decide which parts apply and which values are used.

Short answer

IEEE 1547 commissioning tests verify, on site and before parallel operation, that a distributed energy resource (DER) has the settings, protection and grid-support functions required by the interconnection agreement. Typical evidence is a settings table compared with the installed values, a functional check of each enabled function, an anti-islanding or trip check, and a signed record. The utility defines the acceptance test and its tolerances.

Figure: single-line view of a DER with the measurement points used during commissioning and the reporting path to the utility.

The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide. How IEEE 1547 compares with other regimes is in the IEEE 1547, G99 and AS/NZS 4777 comparison.

Three layers of evidence

Utilities usually look at three kinds of evidence, and each answers a different question.

  1. Type evidence. The inverter carries a listing, normally to UL 1741, built on the test procedures of IEEE 1547.1. It shows the product design can perform the functions. See who certifies what under IEEE 1547 and UL 1741 SB.
  2. Installation evidence. Photographs, labels, drawings and inspections show the equipment was installed as designed. This is usually verified by the authority having jurisdiction (AHJ).
  3. Commissioning evidence. Measurements and records show that the unit, as set up, performs as required. Commissioning tests produce this evidence.

A project that has the first two and skips the third has no proof that the settings in the field match the settings in the agreement.

What a commissioning test usually covers

IEEE 1547-2018 groups the behavior of a DER into themes: voltage and frequency response to abnormal conditions, ride-through, voltage and reactive-power regulation, active-power response, islanding and communications. The commissioning scope draws from these themes, scaled to the size of the plant.

  • Settings audit. Read every setting from the device and compare it with the approved settings table. It is quick and catches settings left at factory values.
  • Protection check. Confirm that the interface protection thresholds and times are the agreed ones, and that the trip signal reaches the interrupting device.
  • Function checks. For each grid-support function enabled, apply a controlled condition, such as a voltage shift from a test source or a setpoint change, and record the response.
  • Cease-to-energize and reconnection. Confirm that the unit stops energizing for a trip condition and waits the agreed time before it reconnects.
  • Communications. Confirm the data points and the protocol the utility needs, and the security settings. The guide on IEEE 1547.3 cybersecurity covers the security side.
  • Plant controller. For plants with a power plant controller, see the PPC testing guide.

A small residential unit may need only the settings audit and a witness inspection. A multi-megawatt plant adds a written commissioning plan agreed with the utility in advance.

Where commissioning fits in the whole test sequence

Commissioning tests for the interconnection come after the plant’s own cold and hot tests. The guides on solar plant commissioning tests and on testing a solar plant by stage describe that sequence. The capacity test is a separate, later check of plant output and does not replace the interconnection commissioning.

Worked example (illustrative)

A 500 kVA inverter is commissioned on a 480 V system. The approved settings table gives a volt-var curve with these illustrative values: no reactive power between 0.98 and 1.02 per unit voltage, and then a linear response to 44 percent of rated kVA absorbed at 1.05 per unit. The agreement says the plant must be within 2 percent of rated kVA of the curve.

The test source holds the voltage at 1.035 per unit.

Step 1. Position on the curve. 1.035 is 0.015 per unit above the end of the dead band. The sloped section runs from 1.02 to 1.05, which is 0.030 per unit wide.

Step 2. Fraction of the slope. 0.015 / 0.030 = 0.50.

Step 3. Expected reactive power. 0.50 × 44% × 500 kVA = 110 kvar absorbed.

Step 4. Compare with the measurement. The analyzer shows 104 kvar absorbed. The difference is 6 kvar, which is 6 / 500 = 1.2 percent of rated kVA.

Step 5. Decision. 1.2 percent is inside the 2 percent band used in this example, so this point passes. A second point, for example at 1.05 per unit, confirms the end of the slope.

The values are chosen for the example only. The actual curve, the tolerance and the number of test points come from the utility agreement and the standard.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Obtain the utility’s commissioning requirements and the approved settings table before ordering the test equipment.
  • Confirm the inverter listing and the firmware version recorded on the nameplate and in the device.
  • Read all settings from the device and compare them line by line with the approved table.
  • Test the interface protection and confirm the trip path to the interrupting device.
  • Test each enabled grid-support function at no fewer than two points.
  • Confirm the reconnection delay after a trip.
  • Confirm communications points, protocol and security settings with the utility.
  • Record measurements with date, instrument, calibration reference and the person who made them.
  • Issue a signed commissioning record and file the as-left settings with the as-built drawings.
  • Keep the evidence together for a later audit by the utility or a client.

Who signs and seals

In the United States the design and the commissioning plan are normally signed and sealed by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Our engineering and review work is delivered ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States.

How Tiza can help

If the commissioning plan and the settings table have been prepared by someone else, an independent review before the field test catches mismatches while they are still cheap to fix. Tiza provides independent review of a third-party design, remotely and in English, and delivers a written list of findings ready for your engineer of record to review. Contact us with the commissioning plan and the settings table.

Frequently asked questions

Are IEEE 1547 commissioning tests the same as the factory tests behind a UL 1741 listing?

No. The listing shows that a type of inverter passed laboratory tests. Commissioning shows that this installed unit, with these settings, at this site, behaves as the interconnection agreement requires. The utility usually asks for both.

Who decides which commissioning tests are required?

The utility, through its interconnection agreement and technical requirements, within the framework of IEEE 1547-2018. Some utilities require a witnessed test, others accept a signed report. Ask for the commissioning requirements before the design is frozen.

What happens if a setting does not match the agreement?

The unit should not be released for parallel operation until the setting is corrected and the check repeated. The corrected value and the date go into the commissioning record, so the final settings table and the installed settings agree.

WhatsApp