Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

IEEE 1547 Frequency Trip Settings and Ride-Through

How IEEE 1547 frequency ride-through and trip settings work for inverters, what the published defaults mean and how to check them against relay settings.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

breakerDC=~inverter, 60 Hzfeeder81 O/UrelayPowerProtection and controldefault trips: time counts as levelA: 61.5 Hz for 120 s < 300 s, no tripB: 61.5 Hz for 320 s > 300 s, 61.2 Hz tripC: 56.0 Hz for 0.2 s > 0.16 s, fast tripfrequency (Hz)6062.0 Hz (+3.33%), 0.16 s61.2 Hz (+2.00%)after 300 s58.5 Hz (-2.50%)after 300 s56.5 Hz (-5.83%), 0.16 s0.16 s120 s300 s320 stime, not to scaleABCEventsDefaultsEvent AEvent BEvent CLesson© tizagrp.combreakerDC=~inverter, 60 Hzfeeder81 O/UrelayPowerProtection and controldefault trips: time counts as levelA: 61.5 Hz for 120 s < 300 s, no tripB: 61.5 Hz for 320 s > 300 s, 61.2 Hz tripC: 56.0 Hz for 0.2 s > 0.16 s, fast tripfrequency (Hz)6062.0 Hz (+3.33%), 0.16 s61.2 Hz (+2.00%)after 300 s58.5 Hz (-2.50%)after 300 s56.5 Hz (-5.83%), 0.16 s0.16 s120 s300 s320 stime, not to scaleABCEventsDefaultsEvent AEvent BEvent CLesson© tizagrp.com
IEEE 1547 frequency trips: an inverter with an 81 relay, the four default trips 62.0 and 61.2 Hz above and 58.5 and 56.5 Hz below, and three events: 61.5 Hz for 120 s rides through, 61.5 Hz for 320 s trips at 300 s, 56.0 Hz for 0.2 s trips fast. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

IEEE 1547-2018 lets an inverter-based resource stay connected through frequency excursions for defined times and then trip. The utility or regulator publishes the settings, and the inverter must be configured to them. The default trips are 62.0 and 61.2 Hz on the high side and 58.5 and 56.5 Hz on the low side, and plant relays must not trip inside the ride-through range.

Frequency is the grid-wide signal. When generation and load are out of balance, frequency moves everywhere at once. So the question of when an inverter must stay on, and when it may trip, matters for the whole system. The background is in the IEEE 1547-2018 guide and the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide.

This guide is based on IEEE 1547-2018 (active, amended by 1547a-2020). IEEE has a revision in development.

Short answer

IEEE 1547-2018 sets ride-through and trip requirements for frequency, in the same performance categories used for voltage. Inside the ride-through range the DER must keep operating. Beyond it, the DER trips after a settable time. Fast trips apply to large excursions, and slower trips apply to smaller ones that last longer. The utility or the interconnection rules choose the settings, within the ranges the standard allows.

Published default values

The default frequency trips of IEEE 1547-2018 are the same in all three categories, and New England utilities publish them in their default-settings requirements. Over-frequency: 62.0 Hz after 0.16 s and 61.2 Hz after 300 s. Under-frequency: 58.5 Hz after 300 s and 56.5 Hz after 0.16 s. These are defaults in one region. Another utility, a different regional operator or a later edition of the rules can change them, so use the document that applies to your project.

How ride-through and trip fit together

Think of a staircase in frequency and time:

  • Near nominal, the inverter operates continuously.
  • Moving away from nominal, the inverter must ride through for the time set in the category.
  • At the outer edge, a short trip time disconnects it quickly, because a very large deviation means a serious disturbance.
  • Between those, a long trip time, minutes rather than fractions of a second, lets the inverter support the grid during a long event.

The reason for the long step is practical. A frequency that stays slightly high for several minutes is a system event that generation is helping to correct, and losing inverters at that point would make it worse. For the grid-side story see the guide on frequency variation and DC component in the grid.

Worked example: where an event lands

This is illustrative. Use the four default trips above as the example settings.

  1. Distance from 60 Hz: 62.0 is +3.33%; 61.2 is +2.00%; 58.5 is -2.50%; 56.5 is -5.83%.
  2. Event A: frequency at 61.5 Hz for 120 s. It is above the 61.2 Hz threshold but below its 300 s limit, so no trip yet.
  3. Event B: the same 61.5 Hz for 320 s. It passes 300 s above 61.2 Hz, so the 61.2 Hz trip operates.
  4. Event C: a short dip to 56.0 Hz for 0.2 s. It is below 56.5 Hz and longer than 0.16 s, so the fast trip operates.

The practical lesson is that time matters as much as the level. A relay that trips at 61.2 Hz after 0.1 s would disconnect the inverter in Event A, which the defaults say should ride through.

Why the settings differ between regions

Grids are not all alike. A large interconnection with many synchronous machines moves slowly, and a small or island-prone system moves fast. A regional operator that sees lower inertia may ask for different thresholds or longer ride-through. That is why the standard gives ranges and the utility selects values. In practice, the interconnection office will hand you a settings table. Your job is to apply it exactly and to show it was applied.

Rate of change of frequency

A fast-moving frequency can trip protection even when the level is still inside the band. IEEE 1547-2018 includes a rate-of-change-of-frequency ride-through requirement, which sets how fast the frequency may move before the DER is allowed to stop. The required ride-through rate is 0.5 Hz/s in category I, 2.0 Hz/s in category II and 3.0 Hz/s in category III. When a plant relay uses a rate-of-change function, compare it with that requirement as well.

Check against the plant relays

If the plant has a frequency protection function at the point of connection, compare it with the inverter settings. The type-test side of frequency relays is covered in the type test report of a frequency protection guide. Harmonics can disturb the measurement, as explained in the guide on harmonics and interharmonics in frequency protection.

Questions to put to the utility

  • Which performance category applies, and which edition of its rules?
  • Are the trip times the defaults of the standard or adjusted values?
  • Is there a regional operator whose requirements sit above the utility’s?
  • Who may change the settings after commissioning, and how is that change reported?
  • Does the project need a study of frequency response, for example when it is large for its feeder?

The answers belong in the project file, because the settings are part of the interconnection agreement.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Get the utility’s frequency settings in writing, with the edition of the rules.
  • Make one table with inverter and relay thresholds and times, side by side.
  • Check that no relay trips inside the inverter ride-through range.
  • Check the time resolution of the measurement against the shortest trip time.
  • Record the settings applied at commissioning and the file or screenshot that proves them.
  • Link the settings plan with voltage ride-through so both are consistent.

Who signs and seals

In the United States, drawings and studies are normally signed and sealed by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Our work is delivered ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States.

Our remote relay and inverter configuration service builds the comparison table of inverter and relay frequency settings, so your engineer of record can review it with the utility’s requirements. Contact us with the relay and inverter data.

Frequently asked questions

What are the IEEE 1547 default frequency trip settings?

The standard gives default trip settings and allows the utility to adjust them within ranges. A US utility publishes defaults of 62.0 Hz after 0.16 s and 61.2 Hz after 300 s on the high side, and 58.5 Hz after 300 s and 56.5 Hz after 0.16 s on the low side. Confirm the values your own utility requires.

Is frequency ride-through the same as frequency trip?

No. Ride-through is the range where the inverter must keep operating. Trip is where it is allowed, or required, to disconnect. The trip settings sit at the edge of the ride-through range, so the two have to be read together.

Can a plant relay trip before the inverter does?

Yes, if the relay settings are tighter than the inverter ride-through. That defeats the ride-through. The relay and inverter settings should be compared in a single table and agreed with the utility.

WhatsApp