Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

EMT and Dynamic Stability Studies for IBR Plants

What EMT and dynamic stability studies check for inverter-based plants in the US: scenarios, models, EMT outputs and a worked weak-grid and run example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

gridequivalenttransformerVTcollector=~invertersF1F2F3Recordervoltage, powerPlant controllersetpointsPowerMeasure / controlSCR normal: 900 / 150 = 6.0SCR line out: 540 / 150 = 3.63 × 2 × 4 × 3 = 72 runs72 × 40 min = 2,880 min = 48 hshort-circuit ratio6.03.6about 3: weakrows: 3 dispatch × 2 grid strengths; columns: 4 faults × 3 placescomputing time: 48 hours012243648 hillustrative values; each EMT run assumed 40 minutesModelGrid equivalentTransformerInvertersControllerRecorder© tizagrp.comgridequivalenttransformerVTcollector=~invertersF1F2F3Recordervoltage, powerPlant controllersetpointsPowerMeasure / controlSCR normal: 900 / 150 = 6.0SCR line out: 540 / 150 = 3.63 × 2 × 4 × 3 = 72 runs72 × 40 min = 2,880 min = 48 hshort-circuit ratio6.03.6about 3: weakrows: 3 dispatch × 2 grid strengths; columns: 4 faults × 3 placescomputing time: 48 hours012243648 hillustrative values; each EMT run assumed 40 minutesModelGrid equivalentTransformerInvertersControllerRecorder© tizagrp.com
Dynamic stability and EMT study model as a block diagram: the grid equivalent, the transformer and collector, the inverters with their plant controller, three fault points F1, F2 and F3 and a recorder fed by the current and voltage measurements, with the worked example of a short-circuit ratio of 6.0 in the normal state and 3.6 with the line out, a matrix of 72 runs and 48 hours of computing time. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Dynamic and EMT studies show how an inverter-based plant behaves in the seconds and milliseconds after a disturbance. Positive-sequence stability studies handle ride-through and recovery on a large grid. EMT studies in general-purpose electromagnetic transient simulation tools capture fast control interaction, weak-grid behavior and switching effects. The operator asks for them when the plant is large or the grid is weak.

An inverter plant can pass every steady-state check and still misbehave in the first two seconds after a fault. Controls interact with a weak grid and with each other. Dynamic and electromagnetic transient (EMT) studies exist to find those problems before the plant is built.

Short answer

A dynamic stability study runs the grid and the plant in the time domain after a disturbance, using positive-sequence models. It checks that voltage and frequency recover and that the plant rides through. An EMT study, run in a general-purpose electromagnetic transient simulation tool, models the actual waveforms with very small time steps. It is used for weak grids, control interaction and fast phenomena that the other model cannot see. The models themselves and their validation are covered in the IEEE 2800 model guide and the guide on EMT model detail.

The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide. Steady-state work is in the power flow and short circuit guide.

Figure: block diagram of a study model with the grid equivalent, the transformer and collector, the inverters with their plant controller, and the points where faults are applied and signals recorded.

What each study checks

Positive-sequence stability. Faults near the plant and on the network, with the plant in service. The checks are whether the plant stays connected through voltage and frequency dips. They also cover recovery time of voltage and active power, and the stability of nearby generators. The requirements it checks against are in IEEE 2800 ride-through and reactive capability and in the NERC PRC-029 guide. ERCOT adds its own rules, see the ERCOT ride-through guide.

EMT. The study looks at fast inverter control behavior, sustained oscillations on a weak grid, interaction between inverters and nearby plants, overvoltages after switching or fault clearing and harmonics. Because the runs are expensive, they cover a limited set of cases chosen from the stability results.

Weak grids and the short-circuit ratio

The short-circuit ratio (SCR) compares the fault level of the grid at the plant with the plant rating. A low value means the grid voltage moves more when the plant changes its current, and inverter controls can become unstable. The guide on SCR and weak grids explains the concept. The operator’s screening usually asks for the SCR in the normal state and with an outage, because the worst case is often with a line out.

What the operator needs from you

  • An EMT model of the inverter from the manufacturer, in the program the operator uses, with the controls as installed.
  • A positive-sequence model of the same plant, consistent with the EMT one.
  • The plant controller model and its settings.
  • Collector, transformer and cable data, with saturation data where required.
  • The ride-through and reactive settings that the plant will use.
  • A report that explains the model, its limits and the checks run. See NERC MOD-026 and MOD-027.

Worked example (illustrative)

Illustrative data, not from any project. A 150 MW inverter plant connects to a grid with a fault level of 900 MVA in the normal state and 540 MVA with the strongest nearby line out. The operator runs a scenario matrix of 3 dispatch levels, 2 grid strengths, 4 fault types and 3 fault locations. Each EMT run is assumed to take 40 minutes.

  1. SCR in the normal state: 900 / 150 = 6.0.
  2. SCR with the line out: 540 / 150 = 3.6.
  3. A common screening practice treats a value below about 3 as weak, so 3.6 is near the area where control interaction deserves attention. The threshold varies by operator and by inverter design.
  4. Runs: 3 x 2 x 4 x 3 = 72.
  5. Computing time: 72 x 40 min = 2,880 min = 48 hours.

The 48 hours are the reason operators reduce the matrix. A good study plan picks the worst cases from the positive-sequence results and asks the operator to confirm them. The numbers show how the grid strength drops 40% with an outage and how fast the run count grows with each added scenario.

What the report should show

A useful report lists each case, the fault applied and its clearing time, and plots of voltage, active power, reactive power and current at the point of interconnection. It states whether the plant stayed connected and how long recovery took. It names the model versions and settings used, so that the operator and the owner can repeat the run. Without that traceability, a later model validation cannot be tied back to the study.

Where studies go wrong

  • Using a model that does not match the firmware that will be installed.
  • Delivering an EMT model that does not initialize or is not tied to the positive-sequence one.
  • Not studying the outage case with the lowest fault level.
  • Applying settings in the study that differ from those commissioned.
  • Waiting until late in the process to ask the manufacturer for the model.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Ask the operator for its trigger for an EMT study, the program and the case list.
  • Request the manufacturer models early and check the version.
  • Confirm the plant controller functions and settings to be modeled.
  • Calculate SCR in normal and outage conditions.
  • Agree the scenario matrix and the acceptance criteria with the operator.
  • Compare the positive-sequence and EMT model responses for the same fault.
  • Archive the model, the settings and the report for the later validation.

Who signs and seals

Studies for a US project are normally reviewed and sealed by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. The operator issues its own findings. Tiza delivers studies ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States.

How Tiza can help

If you need a screening before the operator’s study, or a review of the model package before submittal, Tiza runs power-system studies in English and remotely. The results are ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with your single-line diagram and the inverter data.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a stability study and an EMT study?

A positive-sequence stability study models the grid at the fundamental frequency and runs on large systems. An EMT study models the waveforms in the time domain with small steps, so it captures fast inverter controls, harmonics and switching, on a smaller part of the network.

When does an operator ask for an EMT study of an inverter plant?

Typically when the plant is large, when the grid at the connection point is weak, or when other inverter plants are electrically close. Each operator states its trigger in its tariff or study guidelines, so ask before you start.

Who provides the EMT model?

The plant owner provides a model supplied by the inverter manufacturer, together with the plant controller and collector data. The operator checks that the model is usable and that it matches the equipment.

WhatsApp