Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

Interconnection Short Circuit and Power Flow Studies

What power flow and short circuit studies deliver in a US interconnection: inputs, results, acceptance logic and a worked fault-level and voltage example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

=~30 MVAinvertersplant bustransmissionlinePOI 34.5 kVexisting breaker12.5 kAgridequivalent600 MVAX/R = 8Study resultsvoltage, fault currentPowerMeasure / controlgrid: 600 / (1.732 × 34.5) = 10.04 kAplant: 1.1 × 30 / (1.732 × 34.5) = 0.55 kA10.04 + 0.55 = 10.59 kA, 84.7 % of 12.5 kAZ = 34.5² / 600 = 1.984 ohm, X/R = 8unity power factor: +0.62 % riseabsorbing 10 Mvar: -1.03 % dropSCR = 600 / 30 = 20grid 10.04 kAplant 0.55 kA, +5.5 %total 10.59 kA, 84.7 % of 12.5 kA12.5 kAsource impedance 1.984 ohmR 0.246X 1.9680unity power factor: +0.62 %absorbing 10 Mvar: -1.03 %SCR = 600 / 30 = 20illustrative values; screening approximationStudyInvertersTransformerLinePOIGrid equivalent© tizagrp.com=~30 MVAinvertersplant bustransmissionlinePOI 34.5 kVexisting breaker12.5 kAgridequivalent600 MVAX/R = 8Study resultsvoltage, fault currentPowerMeasure / controlgrid: 600 / (1.732 × 34.5) = 10.04 kAplant: 1.1 × 30 / (1.732 × 34.5) = 0.55 kA10.04 + 0.55 = 10.59 kA, 84.7 % of 12.5 kAZ = 34.5² / 600 = 1.984 ohm, X/R = 8unity power factor: +0.62 % riseabsorbing 10 Mvar: -1.03 % dropSCR = 600 / 30 = 20grid 10.04 kAplant 0.55 kA, +5.5 %total 10.59 kA, 84.7 % of 12.5 kA12.5 kAsource impedance 1.984 ohmR 0.246X 1.9680unity power factor: +0.62 %absorbing 10 Mvar: -1.03 %SCR = 600 / 30 = 20illustrative values; screening approximationStudyInvertersTransformerLinePOIGrid equivalent© tizagrp.com
Interconnection power flow and short circuit studies as a single-line diagram: the inverter plant, the step-up transformer, the plant bus, a transmission line, the point of interconnection at 34.5 kilovolts, an existing 12.5 kiloampere breaker and the grid equivalent of 600 MVA with an X over R ratio of 8, with the buses where voltage and fault current are reported, and the worked example of 10.04 kiloamperes from the grid plus 0.55 from the plant, 10.59 in total, 84.7 percent of the breaker rating, a voltage rise of 0.62 percent and a short-circuit ratio of 20. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Power flow and short circuit studies are the base of every US interconnection review. Power flow shows whether the new plant overloads equipment or moves voltage outside limits in normal and contingency conditions. Short circuit shows whether the fault current rises past the rating of breakers and other equipment. Good inputs and clear acceptance criteria decide how many questions the operator asks.

Before an operator accepts a new generation or storage plant, it asks two plain questions. Will the grid still carry the power without overloads or bad voltage? Will the fault current stay inside what the breakers can interrupt? Power flow and short circuit studies answer them.

Short answer

A power flow study solves the steady-state voltages and flows of the network with and without the new plant. It covers normal conditions and contingencies such as the loss of a line. A short circuit study calculates the fault current at the buses near the plant, before and after, and compares it with equipment ratings. They are the core of the system impact study in the study stages guide, and they are run by the operator or by a consultant for the developer.

The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide. The dynamic side is in the stability and EMT studies guide.

Figure: single-line diagram of a plant, its step-up transformer, a transmission line to the point of interconnection and the grid equivalent, with the buses where voltage and fault current are reported.

Power flow: what it delivers

The result is a set of tables and maps for each case:

  • Voltage at each bus compared with the operator’s normal and emergency limits.
  • Loading of lines and transformers compared with their ratings.
  • Losses and the change in flows caused by the plant.
  • Contingency results: which element overloads after which outage. The guide on N-1 contingency analysis explains the method, and the guide on the load flow study gives the base concepts.

The cases usually include peak and light load, plant at full output and at zero, and for storage both charging and discharging. The studies in the base case also include queued projects ahead of yours, so the result depends on the queue. See the guides on the PJM and CAISO processes.

Short circuit: what it delivers

The result is the three-phase and line-to-ground fault current at the plant bus, the point of interconnection and neighboring buses, before and after the plant. It is compared with the interrupting and withstand ratings of the breakers and equipment. The guide on short-circuit study methods covers the calculation approaches. Inverter-based plants need special care: their contribution is limited by the controls, so the model must use the manufacturer’s data. See inverter fault current contribution.

The study also supports protection settings and the marking of available fault current. See NEC 110.24 for the marking requirement on the customer side.

What the operator needs from you

  • A single-line diagram with the point of interconnection and the ratings.
  • Transformer data: rating, impedance, X/R ratio, winding connection and tap range.
  • Collector system and line data: lengths, conductor type and impedances.
  • Inverter data: rating, reactive capability and the maximum fault current.
  • The plant controller mode: voltage control, power factor or reactive power.
  • A model in the format the operator accepts, with the data checked. See NERC MOD-032 and MOD-033.

Worked example (illustrative)

Illustrative data, not from any project. A 30 MW inverter plant with 30 MVA of inverters connects at 34.5 kV. The grid equivalent at the point of interconnection has a short-circuit level of 600 MVA with an X/R ratio of 8. The inverters limit their fault current to 1.1 times rated current. The existing breaker interrupting rating is assumed to be 12.5 kA.

  1. Grid fault current: 600 / (1.732 x 34.5) = 10.04 kA.
  2. Plant contribution: 1.1 x 30 / (1.732 x 34.5) = 0.55 kA.
  3. Total, adding magnitudes as a conservative bound: 10.04 + 0.55 = 10.59 kA.
  4. Increase: 0.55 / 10.04 = 5.5%. Breaker loading: 10.59 / 12.5 = 84.7%. Acceptable under this assumption.
  5. Source impedance: Z = 34.5^2 / 600 = 1.984 ohm. With X/R = 8, R = 0.246 ohm and X = 1.968 ohm.
  6. Voltage change at unity power factor: P x R / V^2 = 30 x 0.246 / 34.5^2 = 0.62% rise.
  7. With the plant absorbing 10 Mvar: (30 x 0.246 - 10 x 1.968) / 34.5^2 = -1.03%, a drop.
  8. The short-circuit ratio: 600 / 30 = 20, a strong connection for this size.

The approximation in step 6 is a screening check; the operator’s power flow gives the exact result. It shows why the reactive power mode matters as much as the active power.

Acceptance logic

Operators usually accept a result when no new overload or voltage violation appears. They also accept it when an upgrade funded by the developer removes the violation. Fault current is accepted when equipment stays under its rating, with a margin the operator defines. The exact thresholds come from the operator’s planning criteria and tariff, so ask for them.

Reading the operator results

When the results arrive, check three things before accepting them. First, the base case: does it include the right queue position and the right topology? Second, the model: did the operator use your data as submitted? Third, the violations: is each one caused by your plant, or did it exist before? A violation that exists without your plant is usually not yours to fix. Ask the operator to show the case with and without the plant, so that the difference is visible.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Ask the operator for its planning criteria, base cases and model format.
  • Prepare the single-line diagram and the equipment data sheet.
  • Verify the transformer, line and inverter data against the nameplates.
  • Define the plant controller mode and the reactive capability.
  • Run a screening check of fault level and voltage before filing.
  • Review the operator results against the plant design and list the questions.
  • Keep the models and the data under version control for later studies.

Who signs and seals

Studies and drawings for a US project are normally reviewed and sealed by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. The operator issues its own results. Tiza delivers studies ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States.

How Tiza can help

A screening of fault level and voltage before the application shows what the operator is likely to find. Tiza runs power-system studies in English, remotely, for generation and storage, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with your single-line diagram and the point of interconnection.

Frequently asked questions

What does an interconnection power flow study answer?

It answers whether the grid with the new plant stays within thermal and voltage limits under normal conditions and after the loss of a line or transformer. It also shows how much the plant changes flows and voltages at nearby buses.

Why does a short circuit study matter if inverters add little fault current?

Inverters add less current than synchronous machines, but the sum still has to stay within the rating of breakers and equipment. The transformer connection and the fault current limit of the inverter also change the result at the plant.

Which software do operators use for these studies?

Operators use general-purpose power-system simulation tools for load flow and short circuit, and each operator states which models and formats it accepts. Ask the operator before building the model.

WhatsApp