The short-circuit ratio (SCR) is the grid short-circuit power at the connection point divided by the rated power of the plant being connected. A low SCR indicates a weak grid: the voltage changes a lot with the power the plant injects and the inverter control can become unstable.
Short answer
The short-circuit ratio (SCR) is the grid short-circuit power at the connection point divided by the rated power of the plant being connected. If the grid has 180 MVA of short-circuit power and the plant is 60 MW, the SCR is 3. The lower the SCR, the weaker the grid: its voltage changes a lot when the plant injects power, and the inverter control can oscillate or become unstable.
What a weak grid is
A strong grid has a small impedance at the connection point: a change of power barely moves the voltage. A weak grid has a large impedance: the same change of power moves the voltage noticeably. Short-circuit power summarizes that impedance, because it is the square of the voltage divided by the grid impedance seen from the point (see external grid impedance and short-circuit power). The SCR compares that strength with the size of the plant: a small plant on a strong grid hardly disturbs it; a large plant on a weak grid does.
How it is calculated
- Simple SCR: short-circuit power at the connection point (MVA) divided by the rated power of the plant (MW).
- Composite SCR: if there are other inverter-based plants electrically close, the short-circuit power is divided by the sum of the ratings of all of them. The new plant feels the effect of those already there.
- Effective SCR: some operators ask to subtract the reactive power of the capacitors and filters connected at the point. Use the definition your operator sets.
Three rules to make the number useful:
- Use the minimum short-circuit power. The one left with the system’s minimum generation and with the most important element out of service (the N-1 criterion: the network is studied with one element out). The SCR is calculated for the weakest condition, not the most comfortable one.
- Define the point. The SCR changes depending on whether it is measured at the plant’s high-voltage bus or at the connection point with the operator. Use the point set by the connection contract.
- Write the reference power. Rated power of the plant at the connection point, not the sum of the inverters if there is a limit to a lower power.
What happens when the SCR is low
- Voltage rises and falls with power. A weak grid does not hold the voltage: when active power is injected, the voltage at the point rises in proportion to the grid resistance, and when a cloud passes over a solar plant the voltage follows the variation.
- The control interacts with the grid. Inverter controls measure the grid voltage and angle to synchronize. In a weak grid that measurement moves with the inverter’s own injection and the control can oscillate.
- Faults weigh more. A close-in fault produces a deeper voltage drop at the connection point.
Load-flow and phase short-circuit studies (rms values) do not reproduce the second effect well, since it depends on the control. When the SCR is low, the study moves to a time-domain model; see the electromagnetic transient study.
Worked example: a 60 MW plant at 34.5 kV
Example data. Connection point at 34.5 kV. Minimum short-circuit power: 180 MVA, with a grid X/R ratio of 5. New plant: 60 MW. Another 40 MW plant is electrically nearby. If the main line trips, the short-circuit power drops to 120 MVA. Weakness threshold for the example: SCR of 3 (in a real project the operator sets it).
- Simple SCR, complete grid: 180 / 60 = 3.0. It is right at the threshold.
- Composite SCR with the neighboring plant: 180 / (60 + 40) = 1.8. Below the threshold.
- SCR with the main line out: 120 / 60 = 2.0 and composite 120 / 100 = 1.2.
- Grid impedance: Z = V² / Ssc = 34.5² / 180 = 1,190.25 / 180 = 6.61 Ω. With X/R = 5: R = Z / √(1 + 25) = 6.61 / 5.10 = 1.30 Ω and X = 5 × 1.30 = 6.48 Ω.
- Voltage rise when injecting 60 MW at unity power factor: ΔV ≈ R·P / V² = 1.30 × 60 / 1,190.25 = 6.5 %. It is an approximate value that ignores reactive power, and on its own it forces a review of the permitted voltage band at the point.
Reading: the plant, seen alone, is at the edge of the threshold, but with the neighboring plant and with the line out it falls to 1.2. The connection study must include those scenarios, and must move to a transient model.
- How much is the SCR in the weakest scenario?
- Well above the threshold: load flow and phase short circuit are enough
- Near the threshold: add the voltage-variation calculation and review the control with the manufacturer
- Below the threshold: transient model with the inverter model, and reinforcement or limiting measures
What it delivers and how to read it
A good report shows the SCR table by scenario (complete grid, line out, with and without neighboring plants), the threshold used and who set it, the calculated voltage variation and, if the SCR is low, the transient model with its conclusion. Check that the weakest scenario has not been left out.
Checklist
- The weak-grid threshold is set in writing by the operator or the manufacturer.
- The SCR was calculated with the minimum short-circuit power.
- The measurement point matches the connection point.
- The composite SCR with neighboring plants is included.
- It was calculated with the main element out of service.
- The voltage variation from power injection was calculated.
- If the SCR is low, the transient study with the inverter model was requested.
Related guides
- External grid impedance and short-circuit power
- Maximum and minimum short-circuit current: what changes
- Electromagnetic transient study: when it is required
- P-Q capability curve of a solar plant
- Studies the CNO requires to connect generation
- IEEE 519 with inverters and generation: when it applies
References
- NERC, Reliability Guideline: Integrating Inverter-Based Resources into Low Short Circuit Strength Systems, RSTC, November 2017.
- IEEE Std 2800-2022, Standard for Interconnection and Interoperability of Inverter-Based Resources (IBRs) Interconnecting with Associated Transmission Electric Power Systems.
Do you need this study?
We calculate the SCR and the voltage variation at the connection point, with the weak-grid scenarios, and prepare the transient study when needed. It is engineering design and studies work done remotely, valid for projects in any country. If you need it to connect to a grid, see the connection studies. Contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What SCR value counts as a weak grid?
There is no single value. Studies usually treat with care connection points with an SCR near or below 3, but the threshold that applies to your project is set by the grid operator and the inverter manufacturer. Ask for it in writing before the study starts.
Which short-circuit power should I use to calculate the SCR?
The minimum that can occur at the connection point: with the grid's minimum generation and with the most important line or transformer out of service. An SCR calculated with the maximum short-circuit power gives an optimistic value that does not represent the most demanding condition.
Why do neighboring plants matter?
Because they all inject power into a network that shares the same impedance. If another plant is electrically close, the short-circuit power your plant sees has to be shared between the two. That is why a composite SCR is also calculated, dividing by the sum of the nearby ratings.