Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Protection, control and communications

Recloser Coordination and Telecontrol: Fuse-Saving Criteria

Fuse saving, 150 ms and 200 ms margins between recloser and relay, minimum pickup and the GPRS or fibre link a utility norm requires for reclosers.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

Short answer

A utility construction norm for medium- and low-voltage networks adopts fuse saving: the recloser clears temporary faults before the fuse and the fuse clears permanent ones. It asks for at least 150 ms between the recloser's fast curve and the relay's definite-time element, 200 ms between its slow curve and the relay's neutral curve, a pickup above load and below minimum fault, and a GPRS or fibre link for remote measurement and control.

Short answer

In its protection coordination section, a utility construction norm for medium- and low-voltage networks applies fuse saving: the recloser clears temporary faults before the fuse melts, and the fuse clears permanent faults. It also requires every recloser to be remotely measurable and controllable.

General recloser setting practice is in recloser settings: reclosing and curves.

Fuse saving in one sequence

A fault on a fused branch under the fuse-saving philosophy
  1. Recloser: Fault on the branch. Detected by the recloser
  2. Recloser: Fast-curve trip. The fuse does not melt
  3. Recloser: Reclose. Tests whether the fault was temporary
  4. Recloser: Does the fault persist? Yes: continue; No: go to step 7.
  5. Recloser: Slow curves. Fast element disabled
  6. Fuse: Melts and isolates the branch. Before the recloser locks out
  7. Recloser: Service restored. On the rest of the feeder

Time margins

The norm gives minimums, to be validated on the coordination plot.

PairCriterion
Recloser and relayFast curve faster than the relay’s definite-time element, at least 150 ms apart
Recloser and relay, neutralSlow curve faster than the relay’s neutral time-delay curve, at least 200 ms apart
Recloser and fuseFuse operates after the fast curve and before the slow one; the fuse must not clear on the fast operations
Electronic reclosers in seriesMore than 200 ms; curve tolerances typically ±10 %
Hydraulic reclosers in seriesMore than 12 cycles, about 200 ms, checked against manufacturer data
Relay and fuse0.2 to 0.3 s between the fuse maximum clearing curve and the relay inverse curve

For electronic reclosers the norm adds two checks: the minimum trip current must be below the minimum fault current of the protected branch and above the maximum load, and the fault level at the site must be below the recloser’s interrupting rating.

Telecontrol

A note under the norm’s table of protective devices requires any recloser on the utility’s network to include a GPRS or fibre link for remote measurement and control from the control centre. The signal list and protocol are agreed during approval.

Worked example (assumptions)

A branch with 140 A maximum load and 900 A minimum fault current.

  1. Pickup must lie between 140 A and 900 A. Choosing 300 A gives ratios of 300 ÷ 140 = 2.1 to load and 900 ÷ 300 = 3.0 to the minimum fault; both ratios are study choices, not norm values.
  2. If the relay’s definite-time element operates at 0.30 s, the recloser fast curve must operate at 0.15 s or less.
  3. If the relay’s neutral curve operates at 0.60 s, the recloser slow curve must operate at 0.40 s or less.

Checklist

  • Fuse-saving behaviour shown on the coordination plot.
  • 150 ms and 200 ms margins to the relay.
  • Pickup between maximum load and minimum fault.
  • Interrupting rating above the site fault level.
  • GPRS or fibre link installed and signals tested end to end.

How Tiza can help

We carry out the coordination study, calculate the recloser settings and configure the control remotely: see remote recloser configuration. Contact us with the study and the utility’s requirements.

Sources

  • IEC 60255-151:2009, functional requirements for over/under current protection, reference for the standard inverse characteristic.

Frequently asked questions

What coordination philosophy does the norm use?

Fuse saving. A definite-time element on the breaker or recloser operates before the fuse and clears short faults; then a reclose is attempted. If the fault persists the fast element is disabled and the fuse clears it.

What time margins does it ask for between recloser and relay?

At least 150 ms between the recloser fast curve and the relay's definite-time curve, and at least 200 ms between the recloser slow curve and the relay's neutral time-delay curve. They are minimums; a real case may need more.

Must the recloser be remotely controllable?

Yes. The norm says any recloser installed on the utility's network must include a GPRS or fibre link for remote measurement and control from the control centre.

WhatsApp