Clause S5.2.5.16 of the National Electricity Rules, Voltage phase angle shift, was deleted by the Package 1 access standards rule from 21 August 2025. Its requirement now sits in paragraph (b6) of clause S5.2.5.8: vector shift protection and similar functions must not operate for phase shifts below 20 degrees. The same limit matters most for relay settings on weak grids.
Clause S5.2.5.16 of the National Electricity Rules (NER) was titled “Voltage phase angle shift”. It is no longer in the Rules. The Improving the NEM access standards, Package 1 rule, in force from 21 August 2025, deleted it. A project still reaches the same requirement, now inside the protection clause. A phase angle jump matters most for the settings of a plant on a weak grid. The wider framework is in the Australia electrical codes and grid connection guide.
Short answer
S5.2.5.16 on voltage phase angle shift was deleted from the NER on 21 August 2025. Its requirement moved to paragraph (b6) of S5.2.5.8: vector shift protection or similar protective functions must not operate for phase shifts of less than 20 degrees. The plant is expected to ride through ordinary jumps in the voltage angle, which switching and network faults cause.
What changed
Before the change, S5.2.5.16 applied to asynchronous plant. Its minimum access standard said the plant and each of its asynchronous units must not include a vector shift or similar function, acting on voltage phase angle, that might operate for phase angle changes below 20 degrees at the connection point. The settings were recorded in the performance standard.
In AEMO’s final report on its 2023 review of technical requirements for connection, the proposal was to move the S5.2.5.16 requirement to S5.2.5.8, because it relates to protection. The final rule of 2025 did exactly that. Paragraph (b6), in the general requirements of S5.2.5.8, now says that vector shift protection or similar protective functions must not operate for phase shifts less than 20 degrees. The heading of S5.2.5.16 shows “Deleted”.
Three points change in practice:
- The limit is the same, 20 degrees.
- It is now a general requirement of the protection clause, not a minimum access standard of its own, so there is no separate tier to negotiate.
- The new text no longer says “at the connection point”. The settings review should cover every relay or inverter function that measures phase angle, wherever it sits in the plant.
The transitional rule decides which text a given project follows. A connection enquiry that had not yet received technical requirements moved to the new standards. A project that had received requirements but no offer to connect kept the old ones, with the option to adopt the new ones. The NER Chapter 5 guide describes that rule, and the guide on clause S5.2.5.8 covers the rest of the protection clause.
What a phase angle jump is
When a line trips or a fault clears, the impedance between the plant and the strong part of the network changes suddenly. The power flow cannot change at once, so the angle across that impedance moves in a step. The plant sees the voltage waveform shift in time. A vector shift relay measures the cycle length, compares it with the previous cycle and trips if the change is large. It was designed to detect loss of mains for embedded generators. On a modern network it can trip a plant for events it should ride through.
AEMO’s dynamic model acceptance tests include a step on the grid voltage angle of 40 degrees, with 60 degrees as the upper case. The guideline expects the inverter model not to lose control at 40 degrees. These tests do not replace the connection requirements, which may involve other angles. The guide on AEMO model requirements for inverter-based plants lists the test families.
Worked example (illustrative)
These values are illustrative. A plant exports 100 MW at 132 kV. We model the network as a lossless reactance between two equal voltages of 1.0 per unit. The angle across it follows sin(δ) = P × X / V².
Case A: strong grid. Two parallel lines give an equivalent reactance of 10 ohm.
- V² = (132 000)² = 1.7424 × 10¹⁰ V².
- sin(δ) = 100 × 10⁶ × 10 / 1.7424 × 10¹⁰ = 0.0574, so δ = 3.29°.
- One line trips and the reactance doubles to 20 ohm: sin(δ) = 0.1148, so δ = 6.59°.
- Jump = 6.59 - 3.29 = 3.3°, far below 20°.
Case B: weak grid. The equivalent reactance is 60 ohm, doubling to 120 ohm after the contingency.
- Before: sin(δ) = 100 × 10⁶ × 60 / 1.7424 × 10¹⁰ = 0.3443, so δ = 20.14°.
- After: sin(δ) = 0.6887, so δ = 43.53°.
- Jump = 43.53 - 20.14 = 23.4°, above 20°.
Result. In the strong case a relay set at 20 degrees would not operate. In the weak case the jump exceeds 20 degrees. A relay set at 20 degrees may now operate for this event, so it is a risk to the plant. The sensible design removes the function, or sets it well above the jump studied, and shows in simulation that the controls ride through. Tripping on a jump the plant should survive is what the clause tries to avoid. The simplified model ignores resistance and voltage change, so the real study uses a full network model.
Figure: the plant connected to the network through two parallel lines, with the vector shift function in the protection relay and the tripping signal to the breaker.
The lesson is the link between system strength and angle jumps. The weaker the network at the connection point, the larger the angle step for the same change in impedance, so a relay setting that is harmless at a strong substation can be a risk at a weak one. Study the jump at the lowest fault level the network service provider gives, not at the average.
Checklist for the engineer
- Identify every function that acts on the voltage phase angle: vector shift, rate of change of frequency, and similar elements in relays and inverters.
- Check the setting against 20 degrees and record it in the proposed performance standard.
- Calculate the angle jump for the credible contingencies at the lowest fault level.
- Confirm in simulation that the inverter controls and the phase locked loop ride through the jump.
- Check which text applies to the project under the transitional rule.
- Coordinate the setting with the anti-islanding scheme, which the neutral voltage displacement guide describes.
Next step
Tiza prepares the protection settings review, the weak-grid simulations and the evidence that sits behind a vector shift proposal. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify: it delivers engineering ready for your RPEQ in Queensland, or your registered or chartered engineer in other states, to review and certify. Contact us with the relay list and the network data.
Related guides
See S5.2.5.15 on short circuit ratio, AEMO system strength requirements and SCR studies and solar farm protection and settings at the connection point.
Frequently asked questions
Is S5.2.5.16 still in the National Electricity Rules?
No. The Package 1 rule, in force from 21 August 2025, replaced the heading with the word Deleted and omitted the clause. The vector shift requirement now appears in paragraph (b6) of clause S5.2.5.8, Protection from power system disturbances.
What is the limit for vector shift protection?
Paragraph S5.2.5.8(b6) says vector shift protection or similar protective functions must not operate for phase shifts less than 20 degrees. The deleted S5.2.5.16 used the same figure, as a minimum access standard, for phase angle changes at the connection point.
Does an older project keep the old clause?
The transitional rule decides which standards a project follows, depending on how far its connection process had gone on 21 August 2025. Check the technical requirements your network service provider issued before assuming either text applies.