Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

Solar Farm Protection Settings at the PCC in Australia

How protection at the connection point of an Australian solar farm is set: network rules, DNSP requirements, what must not trip, with a worked relay case.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

network 22 kVVTCT 200/1PCC breakerfault on theplant feeder=~12 x 440 kVAPCC relay50/51 27/5981 59NPowerMeasure / trip5,280 / (1.732 x 22) = 138.6 Apickup 1.25 x 138.6 = 173.2 A120 MVA: 3.15 kA; phase-phase 2.73 kA2,730 / 173.2 = 15.8 times the pickupinverters 152.4 A: below the pickupA (log scale)1002005001.0002,0005,000rated 138.6 Ainverters 1.1 x rated = 152.4 Apickup 173.2 A = 0.866 A on 200/1min phase-to-phase fault 2,730 Amin three-phase fault 3,150 Asettings come in writing from the DNSPCheckRated currentPickupNetwork faultSensitivityInverter fault© tizagrp.comnetwork 22 kVVTCT 200/1PCC breakerfault on theplant feeder=~12 x 440 kVAPCC relay50/51 27/5981 59NPowerMeasure / trip5,280 / (1.732 x 22) = 138.6 Apickup 1.25 x 138.6 = 173.2 A120 MVA: 3.15 kA; phase-phase 2.73 kA2,730 / 173.2 = 15.8 times the pickupinverters 152.4 A: below the pickupA (log scale)1002005001.0002,0005,000rated 138.6 Ainverters 1.1 x rated = 152.4 Apickup 173.2 A = 0.866 A on 200/1min phase-to-phase fault 2,730 Amin three-phase fault 3,150 Asettings come in writing from the DNSPCheckRated currentPickupNetwork faultSensitivityInverter fault© tizagrp.com
Solar farm protection at the point of common coupling: the network at 22 kV, a VT and a 200/1 CT feeding the connection point relay, its trip to the PCC breaker for a fault on the plant feeder, and the 173.2 A overcurrent pickup against the 138.6 A rated current, the 152.4 A inverter contribution and the 2,730 A minimum network fault. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Protection at the point of connection of an Australian solar farm has two jobs: disconnect the plant when it should, and keep it connected when the Rules say it must ride through. For plants under the National Electricity Rules, clause S5.2.5.8 requires the settings to keep the plant in operation as far as the performance standards require. The values themselves come in writing from the network service provider or the distributor.

The protection at the point of common coupling (PCC) of a solar farm is the boundary between the plant and the network. In Australia it is set from three sources: the performance standards of the National Electricity Rules (NER) for larger plants, the distribution network service provider’s (DNSP) requirements for plants on its network, and the inverter certification. The settings must respect all three, and a worked relay case shows how to check them. The wider framework is in the Australian electrical codes and grid connection guide.

Short answer

Protection at the PCC has two jobs. It disconnects the plant when it must, and it keeps the plant connected when the Rules require ride-through. Under the NER, clause S5.2.5.8 sets the second job out. The plant’s protection settings must be set so that the plant remains in operation as the performance standards require. Unless AEMO or the network service provider (NSP) require otherwise, they must also maximise the plant’s capability to stay in operation in abnormal conditions where it is not required to disconnect. Safe operation within normal engineering margins still applies.

The values for each function come in writing from the NSP or the DNSP. The designer does not choose them from a table.

What the Rules say about settings

The Rules set three requirements that affect PCC settings directly:

  • Vector shift protection, or a similar function, must not operate for voltage phase angle changes of less than 20 degrees at the connection point.
  • AEMO or the NSP may require automatic disconnection by a local or remote scheme. It applies whenever the network the plant is on has separated from the national grid and supplies load.
  • The performance standards must record any condition where the plant must trip although it would otherwise ride through. They must also record any condition where it must not trip although it would otherwise be allowed to.

Clause S5.2.5.9 covers protection systems that affect power system security, and clause S5.2.5.10 covers detection and response to unstable operation. Both are part of the performance standards agreed for the plant, as described in negotiated access standards.

Functions at the PCC

A typical interface protection scheme for a medium voltage solar farm includes these functions:

FunctionPurpose
50/51 overcurrentFaults fed by the network, back-up for the plant feeder
50N/51N earth faultEarth faults on the plant side
27 and 59Under-voltage and over-voltage, set to the ride-through requirements
81U and 81OUnder-frequency and over-frequency
81RRate of change of frequency, if the network provider requires it
59NNeutral voltage displacement for earth faults on the network side
Intertrip or transfer tripDisconnects the plant when the network breaker opens
25Synchronism check for reconnection

The DNSP says which are required and gives the settings. Western Power’s Technical Rules, clause 3.6.10, are one example. They set protection requirements for small generating units and groups of them up to 10 MW aggregate, including a neutral voltage displacement function. Neutral voltage displacement and anti-islanding are covered in neutral voltage displacement and anti-islanding.

Worked example: an overcurrent check at the PCC

These values are illustrative. A solar farm has 12 inverters of 440 kVA, so 5,280 kVA in total, and connects at 22 kV. The network’s minimum three-phase fault level at the PCC is 120 MVA. The current transformer ratio is 200/1.

  1. Rated current: 5,280 ÷ (√3 × 22) = 138.6 A.
  2. Overcurrent pickup at 1.25 times rated current: 1.25 × 138.6 = 173.2 A primary, which is 173.2 ÷ 200 = 0.866 A secondary.
  3. Minimum network fault current, three-phase: 120 ÷ (√3 × 22) = 3.15 kA. For a phase-to-phase fault it is 0.866 × 3.15 = 2.73 kA.
  4. Sensitivity: 2,730 ÷ 173.2 = 15.8 times the pickup. The element is sensitive to network-fed faults.
  5. Inverter contribution, assuming 1.1 times rated current from the data sheet: 1.1 × 138.6 = 152.4 A. That is below the 173.2 A pickup.

The result in step 5 matters. A fault fed only by the inverters does not operate this element. The plant’s own protection and the voltage, frequency and neutral voltage functions must cover it. The relay time grading and the inverter’s actual fault current come from the DNSP’s requirements and the manufacturer’s data. For the grading method, see protection coordination step by step.

Figure: single-line diagram of a solar farm at the point of connection, with the relay, current and voltage transformers, the breaker and the connection to the network.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Obtain the DNSP’s or NSP’s settings in writing, with the edition of the document.
  • Compare every protection setting with the ride-through envelope in the performance standards. A trip setting inside the ride-through envelope disconnects the plant when it must stay connected.
  • Check that any vector shift element stays above 20 degrees, and that every voltage element respects the over-voltage ride-through in the performance standards.
  • Confirm the fault current of the inverters from the data sheet and check the pickup of every overcurrent element against it.
  • Define the intertrip or the local scheme for loss of the network, and test it.
  • Record every setting in a settings file the DNSP can review. See interconnection relays and 59 over-voltage trips in solar plants.
  • Plan the commissioning tests of each function, as in GPS compliance testing and hold points.

Who certifies

Engineer registration is a state matter in Australia. In Queensland, professional engineering services must be provided by, or under the direct supervision of, a Registered Professional Engineer of Queensland (RPEQ). Your RPEQ (in Queensland) or chartered engineer reviews and certifies the protection design and the settings. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify.

For related background, see short-circuit and protection coordination in solar plants and the DNSP connection routes.

How Tiza can help

If your project needs a protection settings study and the relay configuration for the connection point, Tiza prepares them remotely and in English. Tiza delivers engineering ready for your RPEQ (in Queensland) or chartered engineer to review and certify, and does not stamp, sign or certify itself. Contact us with the DNSP’s requirements and the relay model.

Frequently asked questions

Who decides the protection settings at the point of connection?

The network service provider or distributor gives the interface settings in writing, and the designer applies them. For plants under the National Electricity Rules, the performance standards also record any condition where the plant must trip or must not trip. The plant's own protection settings are then set so that the plant stays in operation as the performance standards require.

Should a solar farm's protection trip as early as possible?

No. Clause S5.2.5.8 of the National Electricity Rules requires the settings to keep the plant connected through the disturbances it must ride through, and, apart from what AEMO or the network service provider require, to maximise its ability to stay in operation. Early or sensitive settings that disconnect the plant during a fault elsewhere in the network are a performance standard problem.

Does the overcurrent relay at the connection point see inverter fault current?

Not necessarily. Inverters limit their fault current to a value close to their rated current, so an overcurrent element set above rated current may not operate for a fault fed only by the inverters. The overcurrent element mainly protects against faults fed by the network. Voltage, frequency, neutral voltage and anti-islanding functions cover the rest.

WhatsApp