Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

AEMO System Strength Requirements and SCR Studies

How AEMO's system strength framework works for a new inverter plant: preliminary and full assessments, remediation options and SCR studies, with example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

networkequivalentconnection point=~inverter plantsynchronous condenser(optional)PowerMeasure / controlΔAFL = -(SCR withstand - 1.2) × 100 MW3.0: -(3.0 - 1.2) × 100 = -180 MVA, 12 %2.5: -(2.5 - 1.2) × 100 = -130 MVA, 8.7 %stronger point: 130 / 3,000 = 4.3 %1, 2: remediation; 3: may be disregardedcase 1: assumed withstand SCR 3.0, AFL 1,500 MVA12 %case 2: tested withstand SCR 2.5, AFL 1,500 MVA8.7 %case 3: SCR 2.5 at a point with AFL 3,000 MVA4.3 %5 % threshold05 %10 %illustrative; reduction over existing AFLStrengthNetworkConnectionInverterCondenserAFL© tizagrp.comnetworkequivalentconnection point=~inverter plantsynchronous condenser(optional)PowerMeasure / controlΔAFL = -(SCR withstand - 1.2) × 100 MW3.0: -(3.0 - 1.2) × 100 = -180 MVA, 12 %2.5: -(2.5 - 1.2) × 100 = -130 MVA, 8.7 %stronger point: 130 / 3,000 = 4.3 %1, 2: remediation; 3: may be disregardedcase 1: assumed withstand SCR 3.0, AFL 1,500 MVA12 %case 2: tested withstand SCR 2.5, AFL 1,500 MVA8.7 %case 3: SCR 2.5 at a point with AFL 3,000 MVA4.3 %5 % threshold05 %10 %illustrative; reduction over existing AFLStrengthNetworkConnectionInverterCondenserAFL© tizagrp.com
Connection point of a new inverter plant: the network equivalent as a source behind resistance and reactance, the connection point on the bus, the inverter plant behind its transformer and an optional synchronous condenser closing as the remediation, with the worked reduction in available fault level of 180 megavolt-amperes (12 per cent), 130 megavolt-amperes (8.7 per cent) and 4.3 per cent at a stronger point against the 5 per cent threshold.. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

A new inverter-based plant in the National Electricity Market goes through a system strength impact assessment under AEMO's guidelines. A preliminary assessment estimates the reduction in available fault level and the plant's withstand SCR. A full assessment, where required, tests the effect in simulation. The applicant can then remediate the impact, fund works by the network provider or pay the system strength charge.

System strength is the ability of the grid to hold its voltage steady, and to keep inverter controls stable, when conditions change. In Australia’s National Electricity Market (NEM) it is managed through a framework in the National Electricity Rules (NER) and AEMO’s System Strength Impact Assessment Guidelines. A new solar, wind or battery plant meets this framework at the first stage of connection. The steps below rest on short circuit ratio (SCR) studies. The wider framework is in the Australia electrical codes and grid connection guide. A general introduction to the ratio is in short-circuit ratio and weak grids.

Short answer

Under clause 5.3.4B of the NER, System strength mitigation requirement, a new connection that includes a large inverter-based resource must address its system strength impact. The network service provider (NSP) first runs a preliminary assessment using AEMO’s guidelines. It may then run a full assessment. The applicant either remediates the impact, funds system strength connection works, or pays the system strength charge. The method is in version 2.2 of the guidelines, effective 1 July 2024, which AEMO is reviewing.

Who is covered

AEMO’s guidelines apply to the NSP that must assess the following “4.6.6 connections”, named after the NER clause that requires the guidelines:

  • A new generating system or integrated resource system, which includes large inverter-based resources.
  • A new market network service facility.
  • A new network user facility that includes an inverter-based resource.
  • An alteration to those plants.

For the size of a large inverter-based resource, AEMO’s key criterion is a minimum capacity of 5 MW or 5 MVA. Synchronous plant rarely needs a full assessment.

The two assessments

Preliminary assessment. The NSP starts it when it receives the connection enquiry, or the request for an assessment of an alteration. Its purpose is to estimate whether the connection causes a general system strength impact. Technically it does three things:

  1. It provisionally assesses the plant’s withstand SCR, which is the lowest fault level at which the plant can operate stably.
  2. It calculates the reduction in available fault level (AFL).
  3. It calculates the system strength locational factor and the system strength quantity, so the applicant can estimate the charge.

If site-specific PSCAD and PSS/E models exist, the withstand SCR comes from tests on a single machine infinite bus. If not, the applicant gives the proposed capacity and the technology, and the NSP assumes a withstand SCR of 3.0.

Full assessment. Where required by the NER, the NSP tests the effect in simulation, covering credible contingencies, operating conditions at maximum and minimum load, minimum synchronous generation and committed projects nearby. It also checks that any proposed remediation works.

The available fault level reduction

AEMO adapts a CIGRE method (technical brochure TB 671). The reduction in AFL is:

ΔAFL = -(SCR withstand - α) × P rated

Here α is a stability coefficient of 1.2, and P rated is the rated active power. AEMO notes that AFL is a proxy for the impact of inverter plant on system strength. It does not represent the fault current in the network, and it must not be used for protection grading or breaking capacity.

Ways to deal with the impact

  • Remediate it in the plant. A system strength remediation scheme sits behind the connection point. AEMO’s list includes control tuning, lower impedance transformers, synchronous condensers and other dynamic reactive plant, grid-forming technology and harmonic filters. Synchronous condensers and grid-forming technology can address the AFL reduction. Schemes are evaluated with time-domain simulation.
  • Fund works by the NSP. The applicant pays the NSP to carry out system strength connection works.
  • Pay the system strength charge. The NSP then procures the remediation from the system strength service provider.

Unless the applicant chooses the charge or funds the works, it submits the remediation scheme with the application to connect.

A threshold lets a small impact be disregarded: the reduction in AFL divided by the existing AFL is below 5 %, no adverse impact is found and the NSP is satisfied it is not otherwise material.

Where the SCR studies come in

The SCR enters twice. First, it is an access standard (clause S5.2.5.15, see the guide on S5.2.5.15): the plant must work stably at 3.0, or at the lower value it proves. Second, it sizes the AFL reduction. The fault level that feeds it comes from AEMO’s method, which the guide on short circuit models and fault level requirements explains. The model side is in the R1, R2 and model acceptance guide.

Worked example (illustrative)

These values are illustrative. A 100 MW battery plant connects at a point with an existing AFL of 1,500 MVA.

Case 1: no model yet. The NSP assumes a withstand SCR of 3.0.

  1. ΔAFL = -(3.0 - 1.2) × 100 = -180 MVA.
  2. Relative reduction: 180 / 1,500 = 12 %, above 5 %.

Case 2: models show a withstand SCR of 2.5.

  1. ΔAFL = -(2.5 - 1.2) × 100 = -130 MVA.
  2. Relative reduction: 130 / 1,500 = 8.7 %, above 5 %.

Case 3: same plant at a stronger point with an existing AFL of 3,000 MVA.

  1. Relative reduction: 130 / 3,000 = 4.3 %, below 5 %.

Result. In cases 1 and 2 the plant needs a remediation route: a synchronous condenser or grid-forming capability sized for the reduction, works by the NSP, or the charge. Proving a lower withstand SCR cuts the reduction from 180 to 130 MVA, which is why model evidence has commercial value. In case 3 the impact may be disregarded under the 5 % threshold, if the other conditions are met.

Figure: the connection point with the network equivalent, the inverter plant and an optional synchronous condenser as remediation, showing the fault level that feeds the ratio.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Check the plant is above 5 MW or 5 MVA and which category of connection it falls into.
  • Ask the NSP for the preliminary assessment, with the AFL reduction and the locational factor.
  • Build and benchmark the PSCAD and PSS/E models early, so that the withstand SCR is based on tests.
  • Compare remediation options on cost and simulation results, not on static fault level alone.
  • Submit the remediation scheme with the application, unless the charge is chosen.
  • Keep the assumptions behind the fault levels with the study report.

Next step

Tiza runs power-system studies for weak-grid connections: fault level cases, SCR sweeps, remediation sizing and the reports that go to the NSP and AEMO. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify: it delivers studies ready for your RPEQ in Queensland, or your registered or chartered engineer in other states, to review and certify. Contact us with the connection point and the plant data.

See clause 5.3.4A on negotiated access standards, NER Chapter 5 explained, maximum and minimum short-circuit current and short-circuit study sources, IEC 60909 and ANSI/IEEE.

Frequently asked questions

Which projects need a system strength impact assessment?

New generating systems, integrated resource systems, market network service facilities and network user facilities that include inverter-based resources, and alterations to them. AEMO's guidelines use a minimum capacity of 5 MW or 5 MVA as the key criterion for a large inverter-based resource.

What is the available fault level reduction?

A proxy for the impact of the plant on system strength, calculated as minus the difference between the plant's withstand SCR and a stability coefficient of 1.2, multiplied by its rated power. It is not the fault current the plant will deliver.

Can the impact be ignored if it is small?

A materiality threshold allows it when the reduction is below 5 % of the existing available fault level, if the plant also has no adverse system strength impact and the network provider is satisfied the impact is not otherwise material.

WhatsApp