Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

AEMO Fault Level and Short-Circuit Model Requirements

How AEMO says that the fault level at a connection point is calculated for the SCR, what your models must represent and a worked example for your plant.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

synchronousmachines onlyRjXconnection pointbolted three-phase fault=~plant side:not countedPowerMeasure / control150 MW, 132 kV: synchronous fault levelnormal: 1,050 / 150 = 7.00critical contingency: 780 / 150 = 5.20Z = 100 / 780 = 0.1282 pu; angle 82.87°0.0159 + j0.1272 pu = 2.77 + j22.17 ohmshort circuit ratio7.005.203.0048X = 0.1272 puR = 0.0159 puZ = 0.1282 puillustrative values; per unit on 100 MVAFault levelSourceR + jXConnectionFaultPlant out© tizagrp.comsynchronousmachines onlyRjXconnection pointbolted three-phase fault=~plant side:not countedPowerMeasure / control150 MW, 132 kV: synchronous fault levelnormal: 1,050 / 150 = 7.00critical contingency: 780 / 150 = 5.20Z = 100 / 780 = 0.1282 pu; angle 82.87°0.0159 + j0.1272 pu = 2.77 + j22.17 ohmshort circuit ratio7.005.203.0048X = 0.1272 puR = 0.0159 puZ = 0.1282 puillustrative values; per unit on 100 MVAFault levelSourceR + jXConnectionFaultPlant out© tizagrp.com
Network equivalent for the fault level of the short circuit ratio: a source of synchronous machines behind a resistance and a reactance, a bolted three phase fault at the connection point and the inverter plant on the other side drawn dead because it is excluded from the fault level, with the worked ratios of 7.00 and 5.20 and the impedance of 0.0159 plus j0.1272 per unit.. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

For the short circuit ratio, AEMO's guidelines calculate the fault level with synchronous machines only, inverter-based plant removed, a flat start at 1.0 per unit and a bolted three phase fault at the connection point. The result is repeated for critical contingencies, and the lowest ratio applies. The plant's own contribution is excluded.

The fault level at the connection point drives the short circuit ratio (SCR), and the SCR drives much of a connection in the National Electricity Market (NEM). AEMO’s guidelines set out how the fault level is calculated for that purpose, and how it differs from a conventional fault study. The wider framework is in the Australia electrical codes and grid connection guide.

Short answer

For the SCR, AEMO’s System Strength Impact Assessment Guidelines say to calculate the synchronous three phase fault level at the connection point. The network case keeps synchronous machines and removes the inverter-based devices. Terminal voltages are set at 1.0 per unit, the machines are represented with their sub-transient impedance, and a bolted three phase fault is applied. The result in MVA is divided by the plant’s MW. The calculation is repeated for critical contingencies, and the lowest ratio applies.

The definition behind it

The National Electricity Rules (NER) define the short circuit ratio as the synchronous three phase fault level in MVA at the connection point divided by the greater of the plant’s active power capability and maximum demand, in MW. The definition excludes any fault current contribution from the plant side of the connection point. The plant under study does not make its own grid look stronger.

AEMO’s guidelines (version 2.2, effective 1 July 2024) also make clear that this is different from the assessment of the withstand SCR, which uses dynamic simulation. They give the same worked case: a 100 MW wind farm on a network with 500 MVA at the connection point has an SCR of 5. The S5.2.5.15 guide explains how the ratio becomes an access standard.

How the calculation is run

The guidelines tell the network service provider (NSP) to use the network data of AEMO’s operations and planning case in PSS/E. For a distribution connection, the NSP may add a more detailed representation of the distribution network.

  1. Keep synchronous machines only. Remove all inverter-based devices. What remains is the minimum number of synchronous units, synchronous condensers and other plant providing system strength.
  2. Set the network around the date when the applicant and the NSP expect to notify AEMO of the connection agreement.
  3. Use system normal conditions, meaning the configuration that applies for the majority of the time in a year. Planned or short-term outages are not included.
  4. Set terminal voltages to 1.0 per unit, a flat start, and use the sub-transient impedance of the machines.
  5. Apply a bolted three phase fault at the connection point.
  6. Express the result in MVA, with the X/R ratio and the R plus jX impedance in per unit on a 100 MVA base.
  7. Divide by the plant’s MW. The ratio is reported with at least two and no more than three decimals.

Then repeat for critical contingencies, and for full outages of synchronous machines near the plant that are vital to local system strength. The lowest result is the lowest applicable SCR. Protected events and the constraints that apply during them are also considered. The method follows the steady-state setup in AEMO’s system strength reports.

What the NSP gives you and what the models must show

Clause S5.2.4 requires the NSP, on request, to give the applicant the connection point data, including the highest and lowest fault levels and the X/R ratio. The control tuning in the plant models must be consistent with the range of three phase fault levels and system impedances the NSP specifies. The releasable user guide records the levels used. The AEMO model guidelines guide covers this in detail.

AEMO’s dynamic model acceptance tests then run the PSS/E and PSCAD models at defined grid strengths. They include a case where the equivalent matches the conditions at the connection point. The R1, R2 and model acceptance guide explains the stages. The fault level for the ratio is a synchronous quantity and is not the fault current the plant delivers. AEMO’s guidelines say the available fault level must not be used to grade protection or check breaking capacity. Those studies need the fault current contribution of the inverters, as in converter sources in IEC 60909.

Worked example (illustrative)

These values are illustrative. A 150 MW plant connects at 132 kV. The synchronous fault level at the connection point, with the inverter plant removed, is 1,050 MVA in normal conditions and 780 MVA for the critical contingency. The X/R ratio in the contingency case is 8.

Step 1: the ratios

  1. Normal: 1,050 / 150 = 7.00.
  2. Contingency: 780 / 150 = 5.20.

Step 2: the network equivalent for the contingency case

  1. Impedance on 100 MVA: 100 / 780 = 0.1282 per unit.
  2. Angle from X/R = 8: arctan 8 = 82.87°, so R = 0.1282 × cos(82.87°) = 0.0159 per unit and X = 0.1282 × sin(82.87°) = 0.1272 per unit.
  3. In ohm at 132 kV: 132² / 780 = 22.34 ohm, so R = 2.77 ohm and X = 22.17 ohm.

Result. The lowest applicable ratio is 5.20, so the equivalent used for the weak-grid cases is 0.0159 + j0.1272 per unit on 100 MVA. That is well above 3.0, so the plant has margin for the access standard, but the dynamic tests still run at 3.0 and at the lowest ratio the manufacturer declares. A second contingency or a nearby synchronous unit out of service would lower the number again, and the calculation has to be repeated for it.

Figure: the network equivalent as a source behind R plus jX, the fault point at the connection and the plant on the other side, which is excluded from the fault level.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Request in writing the fault levels, the X/R ratio and the system normal definition from the NSP.
  • Confirm that the inverter plant is removed from the case when the ratio is calculated.
  • List the critical contingencies and the machine outages studied.
  • Keep the flat-start and sub-transient assumptions in the report.
  • Report the ratio with two or three decimals, and the impedance in per unit on 100 MVA.
  • Use the lowest ratio for the model tests, and keep the fault current study separate.
  • Re-run the case when the committed projects or the network change.

Next step

Tiza runs the fault level calculations, builds the network equivalents and prepares the reports for the NSP and AEMO. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify: it delivers studies ready for your RPEQ in Queensland, or your registered or chartered engineer in other states, to review and certify. Contact us with the network data you have received.

See AEMO system strength requirements and SCR studies, network feeder impedance and short-circuit power and maximum and minimum short-circuit current.

Frequently asked questions

Which fault level does the SCR use?

The synchronous three phase fault level at the connection point, excluding any fault current from the plant side of the connection point. AEMO's method sets terminal voltages to 1.0 per unit and uses sub-transient impedance of the synchronous machines.

Does it include the inverter plant in the network?

No. In AEMO's SCR assessment method, inverter-based devices are removed from the network case, so the fault level comes from synchronous machines and other plant providing system strength.

Why must the contingencies be studied?

Because the lowest applicable SCR is what the plant must withstand. The assessment repeats the calculation for each critical contingency, and for outages of synchronous machines that are vital to the local system strength.

WhatsApp