Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

S5.2.5.3 Frequency Disturbance Ride-Through in the NEM

S5.2.5.3 response to frequency disturbances: how long a NEM generator must stay online off-nominal, the ROCOF limits and the 47.5 Hz transient limit rule.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

NSP busfrequency eventbreakerVT81RROCOFplanttransformerLV busGGGGrelay 2.5 Hz/s for 0.5 sevent 3.2 Hz/s for 0.8 sautomatic limit 3 Hz/s, 1 s4 x 9 MVA = 36 MVAthreshold 25 MWPowerMeasure / tripautomatic: shaded, white outlineminimum: magenta, 47.5 Hz for 9 sROCOF exempt above 4 / 3 Hz/s3.2 x 0.8 = 2.56 Hz movedHztimeupper extreme limitupper operational edgelower operational edge47.5 Hzlower extreme limitnormal band: indefinite9 sTsTrTs stabilisation, Tr recovery; illustrativeRide-throughBandsTimesROCOFSettingCheck© tizagrp.comNSP busfrequency eventbreakerVT81RROCOFplanttransformerLV busGGGGrelay 2.5 Hz/s for 0.5 sevent 3.2 Hz/s for 0.8 sautomatic limit 3 Hz/s, 1 s4 x 9 MVA = 36 MVAthreshold 25 MWPowerMeasure / tripautomatic: shaded, white outlineminimum: magenta, 47.5 Hz for 9 sROCOF exempt above 4 / 3 Hz/s3.2 x 0.8 = 2.56 Hz movedHztimeupper extreme limitupper operational edgelower operational edge47.5 Hzlower extreme limitnormal band: indefinite9 sTsTrTs stabilisation, Tr recovery; illustrativeRide-throughBandsTimesROCOFSettingCheck© tizagrp.com
Response to frequency disturbances S5.2.5.3: four 9 MVA units with a plant transformer, connection point breaker, PT and a rate of change of frequency relay set at 2.5 Hz per second for 0.5 s that trips during an event of 3.2 Hz per second for 0.8 s, and the frequency-time ride-through envelopes of the automatic and minimum access standards around the normal, operational and extreme bands with 47.5 Hz for 9 s in the minimum standard. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Clause S5.2.5.3 of the National Electricity Rules says how long a generating plant must stay connected when system frequency leaves its normal band. The automatic standard requires continuous operation across the whole extreme excursion range for the times in the frequency operating standard. The minimum standard shortens some of those times and uses a transient limit of 47.5 Hz for 9 seconds. Both allow a trip when the rate of change of frequency exceeds stated values.

S5.2.5.3 response to frequency disturbances is the clause of Schedule 5.2 of the National Electricity Rules (NER) that keeps generation online when the grid frequency drops or rises. Generation that trips during a frequency event makes the event worse. The clause sets how long each plant must ride through, and which rates of change of frequency are allowed to trip it. For the surrounding framework see the Australia electrical codes and grid connection guide and the guide to generator performance standards. The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) assesses the agreed level with the network service provider.

Short answer

The clause refers to the frequency operating standards for the plant’s region. They define the normal operating band, the operational frequency tolerance band and the extreme excursion limits, with the times the system may spend outside them.

  1. Automatic access standard: the plant, each production unit and any synchronous condenser stay in continuous uninterrupted operation across the whole range from the lower to the upper extreme excursion limits. The times are the stabilisation time and the recovery time from the frequency operating standard, and indefinite inside the normal band.
  2. Minimum access standard: the same, with a shorter requirement at the extremes and a transient frequency limit of 47.5 Hz for 9 seconds.
  3. Rate of change of frequency (ROCOF): a trip is allowed only when ROCOF exceeds set values for set times.
  4. Negotiated standard: accepted if AEMO and the network service provider (NSP) judge that tripping would not push system frequency outside the operational tolerance band.

Reading the ranges

The standard works in ranges, each with a time:

  • the lower extreme limit to the lower edge of the operational tolerance band, for at least the stabilisation time;
  • the lower edge of the operational band to the lower edge of the normal band, for at least the recovery time, including any time already spent in the range below it;
  • the normal band, indefinitely;
  • the same two steps on the upper side.

The stabilisation time and the recovery time are the longest times the frequency operating standard allows the system to remain outside the operational tolerance band and the normal band. The clause takes the widest values specified for any condition, including an island condition.

Where the minimum standard differs

The minimum access standard adds a transient frequency limit of 47.5 Hz and a transient frequency time of 9 seconds, unless the Reliability Panel sets other values. The plant must ride through from the lower extreme limit to 47.5 Hz for at least 9 seconds. It must then ride through up to the lower edge of the operational band for the stabilisation time.

Some trips are allowed under the minimum standard:

  • an integrated resource system, such as a battery, may trip consumption of a bidirectional unit below a frequency level agreed with AEMO;
  • a production system may trip generation above a frequency level agreed with AEMO;
  • the ride-through above the operational band, up to the extreme limit for the transient time, applies to production systems at or above a size threshold. The threshold is the lower of 30 MW (or 30 MVA) and 5% of the maximum credible contingency size in the region’s frequency operating standard.

ROCOF limits

Both standards exempt the plant from ride-through when the rate of change of frequency is outside certain ranges. In plain terms:

  • Automatic standard: ride through unless ROCOF is beyond 4 Hz per second for more than 0.25 seconds, or beyond 3 Hz per second for more than 1 second.
  • Minimum standard: ride through unless ROCOF is beyond 2 Hz per second for more than 0.25 seconds, or beyond 1 Hz per second for more than 1 second.

The Reliability Panel may set other ranges. ROCOF protection settings in an inverter or a plant controller must sit outside these envelopes, or the plant fails the standard.

Worked example: checking two settings

The numbers are illustrative.

ROCOF relay. A plant controller trips on 2.5 Hz per second sustained for 0.5 seconds. During a disturbance, ROCOF is 3.2 Hz per second for 0.8 seconds.

  1. Under the automatic standard, ride-through is required unless ROCOF exceeds 3 Hz per second for more than 1 second. Here ROCOF is above 3 Hz per second, but only for 0.8 seconds, so the plant must ride through.
  2. The relay trips after 0.5 seconds, before the ride-through requirement ends. The setting does not meet the automatic standard.
  3. The frequency moved 3.2 × 0.8 = 2.56 Hz in that time. A relay that trips here removes generation during exactly the event the standard is meant to cover.

Size threshold. A region has a maximum credible contingency of 500 MW (illustrative). Five percent is 25 MW. The lower of 30 MW and 25 MW is 25 MW. A plant of 4 units at 9 MVA each is 36 MVA, which is above the 25 MW (or MVA) threshold. The upper-side ride-through to the extreme limit therefore applies, unless the plant has an agreed frequency trip.

Figure: frequency against time, with the ride-through envelope of the automatic and minimum access standards drawn around the normal, operational and extreme bands.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Get the frequency operating standard for the region and note the bands and times.
  • List every frequency and ROCOF trip in the inverter, turbine and plant controller, with settings and delays.
  • Compare each setting with the agreed performance standard, not only with the automatic standard.
  • Confirm the size threshold for the upper-range ride-through, using the region’s maximum credible contingency size.
  • Check auxiliary systems, such as pumps and fans, that may trip on frequency or ROCOF before the main unit.
  • Plan model validation and a commissioning test for frequency response. See frequency variation in the grid and the 81 operating and reset characteristic.

Related guides in this series: response to voltage disturbances and disturbance ride-through. Technical background: harmonics and interharmonics in frequency protection, 81 blocking by undervoltage and fault analysis from oscillography.

Who reviews and certifies

Engineer registration is a state matter. In Queensland, professional engineering services must be provided by or under the direct supervision of an RPEQ.

How Tiza can help

Tiza provides remote relay configuration in English: the frequency and ROCOF protection settings plan, checked against the agreed performance standard. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify anything in Australia. The deliverables are ready for review and certification by your RPEQ in Queensland, or by the registered engineer your state requires. Contact us with the agreed standard and the plant protection data.

Frequently asked questions

What rate of change of frequency can trip a plant under S5.2.5.3?

Under the automatic standard, ride-through is required unless the rate of change of frequency is outside minus 4 to plus 4 Hz per second for more than 0.25 seconds, or outside minus 3 to plus 3 Hz per second for more than one second. Under the minimum standard the figures are 2 Hz per second for 0.25 seconds and 1 Hz per second for one second.

Where do the frequency band values come from?

From the frequency operating standards that apply to the region where the plant is. Clause S5.2.5.3 refers to the normal operating frequency band, the operational frequency tolerance band and the extreme excursion limits as defined there. Read the current standard for your region.

Can an under-frequency relay be set at 47.8 Hz on a NEM plant?

Only if the plant's agreed performance standard allows it. The minimum access standard requires the plant to stay in operation between 47.5 Hz and the lower edge of the operational band for at least the stabilisation time. A trip at 47.8 Hz that acts sooner than that needs a negotiated standard.

WhatsApp