Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

S5.2.5.2 Quality of Electricity Generated: NER Guide

S5.2.5.2 quality of electricity generated: how the NER limit flicker, harmonics and voltage unbalance from a generator, and how the limits are allocated.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

NSP busbreakerCT50/51relayCTVTPQPQ meterplanttransformerLV bus=~DC=~DCPQ recordinverters,harmonic sourcesPowerMeasure / tripData8 / 400 = 0.02: a 2.0% step0.8% allocated needs 8 / 0.008 = 1,000 MVA1.44 + 0.81 + 0.49 = 2.74square root = 1.66% total distortion%012voltage step at 400 MVA2.00.8 allocatedharmonic voltages1.20.90.7total of the three orders1.66against the NSP allocation; illustrativeLimitsFluctuationHarmonicsUnbalanceMonitoringCompare© tizagrp.comNSP busbreakerCT50/51relayCTVTPQPQ meterplanttransformerLV bus=~DC=~DCPQ recordinverters,harmonic sourcesPowerMeasure / tripData8 / 400 = 0.02: a 2.0% step0.8% allocated needs 8 / 0.008 = 1,000 MVA1.44 + 0.81 + 0.49 = 2.74square root = 1.66% total distortion%012voltage step at 400 MVA2.00.8 allocatedharmonic voltages1.20.90.7total of the three orders1.66against the NSP allocation; illustrativeLimitsFluctuationHarmonicsUnbalanceMonitoringCompare© tizagrp.com
Quality of electricity generated S5.2.5.2: inverters as harmonic sources, the plant transformer, the connection point breaker with CT, PT and relay, and the power quality measurement point with its data record, with a voltage step of 2.0 percent from 8 Mvar at a fault level of 400 MVA against 0.8 percent allocated, and harmonic voltages of 1.2, 0.9 and 0.7 percent summing to 1.66 percent. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Clause S5.2.5.2 of the National Electricity Rules limits the disturbance a generating plant may inject at its connection point: voltage fluctuation (flicker), harmonic voltage distortion and voltage unbalance. The limits are not fixed numbers in the clause. The network service provider allocates them under clauses S5.1.5, S5.1.6 and S5.1.7, and the plant must stay within them at all times when connected.

S5.2.5.2 quality of electricity generated is the clause in Schedule 5.2 of the National Electricity Rules (NER) that controls what a generating plant puts back onto the network. A solar farm with many inverters, a wind farm or a synchronous machine can each distort the voltage waveform or make it flicker. The clause limits three effects at the connection point: voltage fluctuation, harmonic voltage distortion and voltage unbalance. For the framework around it, see the Australia electrical codes and grid connection guide and the guide to generator performance standards.

Short answer

  1. What it limits: voltage fluctuation, harmonic voltage distortion and voltage unbalance at the connection point, at all times when the plant is connected.
  2. Where the numbers come from: the network service provider (NSP) allocates the limits for each connection point under clauses S5.1.5 (fluctuation), S5.1.6 (harmonics) and S5.1.7 (unbalance).
  3. Synchronous machines: the standard IEC 60034-1 is named as the plant standard for harmonic voltage distortion.
  4. Automatic and minimum standards: both require the plant to stay within limits. They differ in whose limit applies.

The two levels

Under the automatic access standard, the plant must not produce, at its connection point:

  • voltage fluctuation above the limits allocated by the NSP under clause S5.1.5(a);
  • harmonic voltage distortion above the emission limits in a plant standard or allocated by the NSP under clause S5.1.6(a); and
  • voltage unbalance above the limits allocated under clause S5.1.7(c).

Under the minimum access standard, the same three effects are limited, but the reference limits are those the NSP determines under S5.1.5(b), S5.1.6(b) and S5.1.7(c). For harmonics, the lesser of the NSP’s limit and the plant-standard limit applies.

There is no negotiated level in the usual sense for this clause. The practical work is in getting a realistic allocation and then showing that the plant meets it.

How the limits are used

The NSP allocates a share of the disturbance the network can absorb to each connecting plant, based on the plant’s size and the strength of the network at the connection point. A weak connection with a low fault level leaves less room, and the plant must do more to stay inside its share.

Two quantities carry most of the engineering:

  • Fault level at the connection point. A voltage step caused by a change in reactive power is roughly the change in reactive power divided by the fault level.
  • Harmonic emission. Inverter-based plants emit at switching-related frequencies. The emission seen at the connection point also depends on the network impedance, which may bring resonance. See harmonics and resonance in solar power plants.

Unbalance depends on the symmetry of the plant. Single-phase auxiliary loads, uneven inverter loading and an open phase on a collector circuit can all raise it, so the study should include these conditions.

The evidence usually comes in three stages. The design study predicts the emission. Factory test reports confirm the equipment’s own emission. Measurements at the connection point during commissioning show the real result, with the plant running at several output levels.

A related clause, S5.2.5.6, covers the opposite direction. The plant must stay connected when voltage quality at the connection point is within the levels in clauses S5.1a.5, S5.1a.6 and S5.1a.7. Design the plant for both directions.

Worked example: a voltage step and a harmonic sum

The numbers are illustrative.

Voltage step. A plant switches a reactive power change of 8 Mvar at a connection point with a fault level of 400 MVA. Assume the network is mainly inductive, so the step is about ΔQ / S(fault).

  1. Voltage step = 8 / 400 = 0.02, or 2.0%.
  2. Assume the NSP allocates a maximum step of 0.8%. Then the fault level needed for the same 8 Mvar step is 8 / 0.008 = 1,000 MVA.
  3. The connection point has 400 MVA, so the step is too large. The options are to reduce the step, for example by staging the switching, or to move to a stronger connection point.

Harmonic sum. Individual harmonic voltages measured at the connection point from the plant are 1.2%, 0.9% and 0.7% of nominal.

  1. Square each value: 1.44, 0.81, 0.49.
  2. Add the squares: 2.74.
  3. Square root: about 1.66%. This is the total harmonic voltage distortion from these three orders. It is compared with the allocated limit, which the NSP provides.

Figure: single-line diagram of the plant with its harmonic emission sources at the inverters, the plant transformer, the connection point and the power quality measurement point.

Checklist for the engineer

Related guides in this series: reactive power capability and response to voltage disturbances. Technical background: power quality in industry.

Who reviews and certifies

Engineer registration is a state matter. In Queensland, professional engineering services must be provided by or under the direct supervision of an RPEQ.

How Tiza can help

Tiza prepares power-system studies, including harmonic and voltage fluctuation assessments, remotely and in English. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify anything in Australia. The results are ready for review and certification by your RPEQ in Queensland, or by the registered engineer your state requires. Contact us with the connection point data and the NSP’s allocated limits.

Frequently asked questions

Does S5.2.5.2 give numeric limits for harmonics and flicker?

No. The clause points to limits allocated by the network service provider under clauses S5.1.5 for voltage fluctuation, S5.1.6 for harmonics and S5.1.7 for unbalance. The figures come from the NSP for each connection point and are then recorded in the performance standard.

What is the difference between the automatic and minimum standards here?

Under the automatic standard the plant must stay within the limits the NSP has allocated. Under the minimum standard the limits are the ones the NSP determines under the minimum-level clauses, and for harmonics the lesser of that limit and the limit in a plant standard applies.

Does the plant also have to keep running when voltage quality is poor?

Yes, within limits. Clause S5.2.5.6 sets a minimum standard that the plant must not disconnect because of voltage fluctuation, harmonic distortion or unbalance within the levels in clauses S5.1a.5, S5.1a.6 and S5.1a.7.

WhatsApp