US utilities publish their own protection requirements for distributed solar, so there is no single national list. The documents usually ask for a way to isolate the plant from the grid, interface protection at the point of common coupling, a defined fault contribution, telemetry for larger plants, and a witnessed commissioning test. Reading the utility's document before the design starts avoids rework at review.
A solar plant that connects to a US distribution system answers to two audiences: the code inspector for the installation and the utility for the connection. The second one is where designs get delayed, so it pays to know what the utility’s protection requirements usually contain.
The legal and technical layers are mapped in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide. The industrial customer’s side is in utility relay requirements for industrial customers.
Short answer
US utilities set the protection requirements for solar in their own interconnection handbooks or technical manuals. They usually ask for four things: a way to separate the plant from the grid, interface protection at the point of common coupling, a statement of the fault current the plant adds, and a commissioning test the utility can witness. Larger plants add telemetry, a transfer trip or a utility-controlled recloser. IEEE 1547-2018 and UL 1741 listing are the usual technical base. Treat the utility’s document as an input to the design, not a checklist at the end.
What the documents usually cover
- Isolation. A lockable disconnect the utility can reach, sometimes with a visible blade. Where it sits and who can operate it is the utility’s rule.
- Interface protection. Voltage and frequency functions at the point of common coupling, plus anti-islanding. Some utilities accept the inverter’s built-in functions for small plants and ask for a separate relay for larger ones. The settings are covered in PCC relay settings for DER.
- Transformer connection and grounding. The utility states which winding connections it accepts, because they decide how the plant behaves in a ground fault. See ground fault overvoltage and grounding transformers.
- Fault contribution. Inverters add little fault current, and rotating machines add much more. The utility needs the figure to check its own devices.
- Transfer trip. For plants large compared with the feeder’s minimum load. See transfer trip requirements.
- Telemetry and control. For larger plants, a data link for status, power and sometimes remote curtailment. Protocols are covered in IEEE 1547 interoperability.
- Testing. A commissioning test, often witnessed, and a record of settings, as in relay setting submittals to utilities.
What the utility reviews
In short, the review is a comparison.
The reviewer normally checks the single-line diagram, the protection description, the settings and the test plan against the utility’s document and against the study result. Questions come back when the single-line does not show the instrument transformers, when settings are given in per unit without the base, or when the trip path is not clear. Coordination with the utility’s own device is part of it, as in coordination with utility protection.
Worked example: what the utility asks about fault current (illustrative)
Assumptions, all illustrative: a 1.2 MW plant at 12.47 kV, with 8 kA available at the point of connection. The utility asks for the plant’s maximum contribution.
- Rated current = 1.2 MW / (√3 × 12.47 kV) = 55.6 A.
- For an inverter plant, assume a limit of 1.1 per unit: 55.6 × 1.1 = 61 A. That is 61 / 8000 = 0.76 % of the available fault current.
- For a synchronous machine of the same rating with a subtransient reactance of 0.15 per unit: 55.6 / 0.15 = 370 A, or 4.6 % of the available fault current.
Both are small compared with the utility’s fault level, so a breaker rating check is not the issue here. For the inverter, the question that matters is the shortage of fault current, which can make an overcurrent relay slow or blind. The utility reviews both and the design must show which one applies.
Common mistakes
The most frequent problems are a single-line that omits the instrument transformers, settings given without their base, a disconnect placed where the utility cannot reach it, and a protection description that does not say how the breaker trips when the grid is absent. Another is to reuse the document of a different utility, because the same item can be asked for in a different form. Each of these returns as a review comment.
Checklist for the engineer
- Obtain the utility’s current handbook and the state rules, and record their dates.
- Confirm whether the utility wants its own device at the connection or accepts the customer’s breaker.
- Confirm the isolation point, its location and who may operate it.
- Calculate and document the fault contribution, with the machine type and assumptions.
- Confirm the transformer connection the utility accepts.
- Confirm telemetry points and protocol for the plant’s size.
- Draw the single-line with instrument transformers, relay and trip path.
- Prepare the test plan and the settings record.
Who signs and seals
Protection design for a US interconnection is normally reviewed and stamped by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project, and the utility reviews it on top of that. Tiza delivers engineering and studies ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify work in the United States.
How Tiza can help
If you have the utility’s requirements and need the interface protection designed and its settings prepared, Tiza delivers engineering design remotely, in English, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the utility’s document and the single-line.
Related guides
- Distribution interconnection process in the US
- Unintentional islanding in IEEE 1547
- NEC 705.13 power control systems
References
- IEEE 1547-2018 and amendment 1547a-2020.
- UL 1741, listing of inverters and grid-support equipment.
- The interconnection handbook or technical manual of the utility that owns the circuit.
Figure: single-line of a solar plant connecting to a feeder, with the utility disconnect, the breaker, the interface relay on current and voltage transformers and the telemetry link as a dashed line.
Frequently asked questions
Where do the utility's protection requirements for solar come from?
From the utility's interconnection handbook, tariff or technical manual, and from the state rules behind them. IEEE 1547-2018 is the technical base, but each utility adds its own items. The document that applies is the one named in the interconnection agreement.
Does a solar plant need a recloser at the connection point?
Not always. Some utilities want a utility-controlled interrupting device at the connection, others accept the customer's breaker with interface protection. The utility states which one in its requirements for the size of the plant.
Are the requirements the same for storage?
The same documents normally apply to inverter-based storage, and the utility may add items if the system can export from the battery or operate islanded. Ask the utility how it classifies the system.