Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

Relay Setting Submittals to Utilities: What to Send

Relay settings submittal to a utility: the package a reviewer expects, how to document each setting and how to keep the record straight after energization.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

Settings studycalculation basisSubmittal package10 documents + revision logUtility reviewsettings checked from the fileapproved?noyesCommissioningread settings, compareAs-left filestored with datelater change: new revisiongoes back to the packagefull load 2,500 / (1.732 x 13.2) = 109.3 Ainrush: the instantaneous must stay aboveabove the through-fault, with 25% marginbelow the minimum fault: 4,500 / 2,278 = 1.98secondary 2,278 / 30 = 75.9 A (150:5)A01.0002,0003,0004,000inrush 12 x 109.3 = 1,312 Athrough-fault 109.3 / 0.060 = 1,822 Asetting 1,822 x 1.25 = 2,278 Aminimum fault 4,500 Avalues are illustrativeSubmittal flowSettings studyPackageUtility reviewRead-backAs-left file© tizagrp.comSettings studycalculation basisSubmittal package10 documents + revision logUtility reviewsettings checked from the fileapproved?noyesCommissioningread settings, compareAs-left filestored with datelater change: new revisiongoes back to the packagefull load 2,500 / (1.732 x 13.2) = 109.3 Ainrush: the instantaneous must stay aboveabove the through-fault, with 25% marginbelow the minimum fault: 4,500 / 2,278 = 1.98secondary 2,278 / 30 = 75.9 A (150:5)A01.0002,0003,0004,000inrush 12 x 109.3 = 1,312 Athrough-fault 109.3 / 0.060 = 1,822 Asetting 1,822 x 1.25 = 2,278 Aminimum fault 4,500 Avalues are illustrativeSubmittal flowSettings studyPackageUtility reviewRead-backAs-left file© tizagrp.com
Relay setting submittals: the flow from the settings study through the package and the utility review, with a return on rejection, to commissioning read-back and the as-left file, and the 2,278 A instantaneous setting above the 1,312 A inrush and 1,822 A through-fault and below the 4,500 A minimum fault. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

A relay settings submittal is the package a customer sends to the utility so it can review the protection at the point of delivery. It normally holds the single-line, the protection schematic, the instrument transformer data, the setting sheet and the settings file, the time-current plot with the fault study behind it, and a test plan. A complete package, with a calculation basis for each setting and a revision log, shortens the review and keeps the as-built record straight.

A relay settings submittal is where the plant’s protection design meets the utility’s review. The reviewer has little time and no access to your plant. What they see is the package. Below are what a relay settings submittal to a utility usually contains, how to document each setting for a reviewer and how to keep the record straight after energization.

The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide. The submittal comes after utility relay requirements for industrial customers and coordination with the utility’s protection, because it presents their results.

Short answer

A relay settings submittal to a utility is a package of documents that lets the reviewer check, without a site visit, that the plant protection is correct and coordinated. It contains the single-line diagram, the protection schematic and the CT and VT data. It also holds the setting sheet and file, the time-current plot with its fault study, a calculation basis for every setting and the test plan. Each document has a revision number and a date. Any later change to a reviewed setting goes back through the same channel.

What the package holds

  1. Single-line diagram. The protective devices, instrument transformers, breaker, transformer and source, each with its tag.
  2. Protection and control schematic. The trip circuit, the trip source, the lockout and the inputs to the relay.
  3. Instrument transformer data. Ratios, accuracy class and the burden check. See IEEE C57.13 accuracy classes.
  4. Setting sheet. Each enabled function, with its value and units, in primary and secondary terms.
  5. Settings file. The native file for the relay model. The sheet and the file must say the same thing.
  6. Time-current plot. The plant devices and the utility device, with the curves at the real settings. See coordination with the utility’s protection for how to build it.
  7. Fault study summary. Maximum and minimum fault current, three-phase and ground, at the point of delivery.
  8. Calculation basis. One line per setting: what it protects, what it must avoid and how the value was chosen.
  9. Test plan. What will be tested, with which tools and when, and whether the utility will witness.
  10. Revision log. What changed since the last submittal and why.

How to document a setting so it can be reviewed

A reviewer reads a setting best when it comes with its reason. For each function write:

  • The value in primary and secondary amps, with the CT ratio used.
  • The purpose: the fault it must clear or the condition it must detect.
  • The limit above: the normal condition it must not trip on, such as load, inrush or motor start.
  • The limit below: the fault level it must still see, usually the minimum fault.
  • The source of the limits, for example the transformer nameplate or the utility’s fault data.

This format turns the sheet into an argument. If a number is wrong, the reviewer can see which assumption failed. The guide on protection coordination and setting criteria lists the criteria for the common functions.

After the review

  • Approval: keep the utility’s reply, with its date and the revision it approved.
  • Commissioning: read the settings from the relay and compare them with the approved file. Record who did it and when.
  • Backup: store the as-left file, with its checksum or date, where it can be found. See IED settings backup and recovery.
  • Changes: open a new revision for every change that touches the service entrance. A relay without a record is a problem for the next engineer, as described in relay without documented settings.

Worked example: documenting an instantaneous setting

This example uses illustrative data, not from any project. A 2,500 kVA, 13.2 kV transformer is fed through a 150:5 CT. The impedance is 6.0%. The utility has said that the minimum fault current at the service entrance is 4,500 A. The inrush is assumed to be 12 times full-load current for a short time. The setting sheet explains the 50 element as follows.

  1. Full-load current: 2,500 / (1.732 × 13.2) = 109.3 A.
  2. Inrush: 12 × 109.3 = 1,312 A. The instantaneous must be above this, or the relay will trip on energization.
  3. Through-fault current for a fault on the transformer secondary, treating the source as infinite: 109.3 / 0.060 = 1,822 A. The instantaneous should stay above this, so it does not operate for a fault the downstream devices should clear. With a margin of 25 percent, the value is 1,822 × 1.25 = 2,278 A.
  4. The setting must stay below the minimum fault, 4,500 A. The setting of 2,278 A is below it, with a ratio of 4,500 / 2,278 = 1.98, so the element still sees the faults that matter.
  5. In secondary terms, 2,278 / 30 = 75.9 A.

The sheet then records: 2,278 A primary, 75.9 A secondary, above inrush (1,312 A) and above the transformer through-fault (1,822 A), below the minimum fault (4,500 A). The treatment of the source as infinite overstates the through-fault, which errs on the safe side for selectivity, as the sheet also says. A real source impedance would lower the figure. This shows the format. The final value belongs to the coordination study.

Checklist for the engineer

  • The utility’s list of required documents, in writing.
  • Every document with a revision number and a date.
  • Sheet and file checked against each other.
  • Settings given in primary and secondary terms, with the CT ratio.
  • A reason, an upper limit and a lower limit for every setting.
  • Time-current plot at the real settings, with the utility device.
  • Test plan, with who witnesses.
  • Revision log kept current.
  • After commissioning, as-left file compared with the approved one.

Who signs and seals

Relay settings and the study behind them are engineering work that, in the United States, is normally reviewed and stamped by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Tiza prepares the settings package ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States.

How Tiza can help

If your project needs the settings calculated, documented and loaded into the relay, Tiza provides remote relay configuration in English, working from the settings plan your engineer of record has reviewed. Contact us with the relay model, the study and the utility’s requirements, and we will scope it with you.

References

  • The utility’s own interconnection or service requirements, which define the contents of the package.
  • IEEE 242-2001, Recommended Practice for Protection and Coordination of Industrial and Commercial Power Systems, for the setting criteria.

Figure: the submittal flow from the settings study through the package, the utility review and the approval to the commissioning read-back and the as-left file.

Frequently asked questions

What does a relay settings submittal include?

Usually the single-line diagram, the protection and control schematic, current and voltage transformer ratios, the setting sheet and the native settings file, the time-current plot, a summary of the fault study, the calculation basis for each setting, and the test plan. Check the utility's list, because each utility sets its own.

Why does the utility want the settings file as well as the sheet?

The sheet is the human-readable record and the file is what loads into the relay. A reviewer can compare them and spot a typing error. After commissioning, the file read from the relay is compared with the one approved, so the record and the device match.

Do I resubmit when I change a setting later?

Yes, if the change affects what the utility reviewed, such as a pickup, curve, instantaneous or a function at the service entrance. Treat it like a new submittal with a revision number and a reason. Ask the utility which changes it wants to see, and keep its reply.

WhatsApp