Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

Utility Relay Requirements for Industrial Customers

Utility interconnection requirements for an industrial customer: what the service entrance relay must do, what the utility reviews and how to prepare.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

utility 13.2 kVservice breakerCT150:5VTtestswitch50/51relayDC trip sourceutilitytelemetry2,500 kVA13.2 kVPowerMeasure / tripCommsfull load 2,500 / (1.732 x 13.2) = 109.3 Alimit 109.3 x 1.50 = 164.0 Apickup 109.3 x 1.25 = 136.7 Amargin 164.0 - 136.7 = 27.3 Arelay: 3.64 A full load, 4.56 A at pickupfull load is 73% of the CT ratingA050100150full load109.3 Apickup 125%136.7 Autility limit 150%27.3 ACT 150 Athe 150% utility rule is assumed for the exampleOrderLimitFull loadPickupCT ratioDocumented© tizagrp.comutility 13.2 kVservice breakerCT150:5VTtestswitch50/51relayDC trip sourceutilitytelemetry2,500 kVA13.2 kVPowerMeasure / tripCommsfull load 2,500 / (1.732 x 13.2) = 109.3 Alimit 109.3 x 1.50 = 164.0 Apickup 109.3 x 1.25 = 136.7 Amargin 164.0 - 136.7 = 27.3 Arelay: 3.64 A full load, 4.56 A at pickupfull load is 73% of the CT ratingA050100150full load109.3 Apickup 125%136.7 Autility limit 150%27.3 ACT 150 Athe 150% utility rule is assumed for the exampleOrderLimitFull loadPickupCT ratioDocumented© tizagrp.com
Utility relay requirements: a 13.2 kV service entrance with breaker, 150:5 CT and VT through a test switch to the relay, its DC trip source, trip to the breaker and telemetry to the utility, and a 136.7 A pickup between the 109.3 A full load and the 164.0 A utility limit. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

A US utility does not publish one national rule for the relay at an industrial customer's service entrance. Each utility, and each transmission owner, issues its own requirements. They usually cover the protective functions needed, how the trip is powered, what the instrument transformers must meet, what telemetry is exchanged, how settings are approved and how the scheme is tested. The customer's engineer reads that document first and designs to it.

An industrial customer who is about to connect, or to change the service, learns quickly that the service entrance relay is not only the plant’s business. The utility wants to know that a fault inside the plant will not take down its feeder and that the plant will not keep a de-energized line alive. Below are what US utility interconnection requirements for an industrial customer usually cover, what the utility reviews, and how to prepare so the review does not stall.

The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide. Two related guides cover coordination with the utility’s protection and the relay setting submittal.

Short answer

Utility relay requirements for an industrial customer are set by the utility and, at transmission level, by the transmission owner. There is no single national list. The documents usually name the protective functions the service entrance needs and how the trip is powered. They also cover the instrument transformers, metering and telemetry, how settings are approved and how the scheme is tested. Read the utility’s document before the design starts, and treat it as a design input, not a checklist at the end.

Where the requirements come from

  • The utility’s service or interconnection requirements. A document that applies to all customers of that utility. It sets the technical minimums at the point of delivery.
  • The tariff and the interconnection agreement. The legal side: who owns what, who operates what and who pays.
  • Facility interconnection requirements of the transmission owner. For a customer connected at transmission level, FAC-001, a standard of the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC), asks the transmission owner to document them. The owner publishes its own version.
  • State rules. A state commission may add rules, especially when the customer has generation.

The NEC does not set these. It governs the installation on the customer side. The utility’s document governs the interface. The plant-utility interface guide shows where each begins.

What these requirements usually cover

The list below is typical. Each utility decides its own, so confirm every item in the document that applies to you.

TopicWhat the utility typically wants to see
FunctionsPhase and ground overcurrent at the service entrance, and for a plant with generation, voltage, frequency and directional functions
Relay typeA microprocessor relay with event records and a setting file the utility can review
Trip sourceA battery and charger that keep the relay and the breaker able to trip when the AC supply is lost
Instrument transformersCurrent and voltage transformers whose accuracy suits protection, with the ratios on the drawing
RedundancySometimes a second relay or a second trip coil, depending on voltage level and the effect of a failure on the utility
Test provisionsTest switches or equivalent so the relay can be tested without opening the service
TelemetryStatus and measurements sent to the utility’s control center, over a path the utility accepts
ApprovalReview of drawings and settings before energization, and often a witnessed test

The functions of the incomer relay are described in medium-voltage incomer protection relay. The choice of current transformer is described in the CT and VT selection guide, and the series continues in IEEE C57.13 accuracy classes.

When the plant also generates

Solar, storage, cogeneration and standby generators that can run in parallel change the requirements. The utility will normally ask about the point of common coupling and the voltage and frequency functions. It will also ask how the plant separates from the grid and whether a transfer trip is needed. The IEEE 1547 family is the usual reference for inverter-based sources. The framework guide linked at the top shows how it sits next to the NEC and the utility process. Keep the protection that serves the plant and the protection that serves the utility on separate drawings, so each reviewer finds what they check.

What the utility reviews

The review normally covers:

  1. The single-line diagram, with protective devices and instrument transformers marked.
  2. The protection and control schematic, including the trip circuit and its power source.
  3. The relay settings and the coordination with the utility’s own devices.
  4. The test plan and the commissioning schedule.

A reviewer who cannot find the trip source or the CT ratio sends the package back, and the clock starts again.

Worked example: a pickup the utility will accept

This example uses illustrative data, and the utility rule is assumed for the example. A plant has a 2,500 kVA, 13.2 kV transformer at its service entrance. Assume the utility’s document says the phase overcurrent pickup at the service entrance must not exceed 150% of the transformer full-load current.

  1. Full-load current: 2,500 / (1.732 × 13.2) = 109.3 A.
  2. Utility limit: 109.3 × 1.50 = 164.0 A.
  3. The plant picks 125%: 109.3 × 1.25 = 136.7 A, which is below the limit and clears the normal load and the short overload allowed in operation.
  4. Current transformer ratio chosen: 150:5, a factor of 30. The relay sees 109.3 / 30 = 3.64 A at full load and 136.7 / 30 = 4.56 A at pickup.

The pickup passes the limit with 27.3 A of margin (164.0 − 136.7). The ratio keeps full load at 73% of the CT rating (109.3 / 150), which leaves room for overload within the CT’s continuous rating. Whether the relay also needs an instantaneous element, and at what level, belongs to the coordination step in the next guides. The point of the example is the order: read the limit, compute the load, choose the pickup and the ratio, then document both.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Obtain the utility’s current service or interconnection requirements, in writing, and note the date.
  • Ask whether the customer’s point of delivery is on the distribution or the transmission system.
  • List every protective function the document requires, and mark the ones that apply.
  • Confirm the trip source and its autonomy.
  • Confirm the current and voltage transformer ratios and the accuracy the utility expects.
  • Confirm telemetry points, protocol and path with the utility’s control center.
  • Confirm whether a witnessed test is required and when.
  • Prepare single-line, schematic and settings as separate documents.
  • Agree who at the utility reviews each document and the expected turnaround.

Who signs and seals

Protection design for a US service entrance is normally reviewed and stamped by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project, and the utility reviews it on top of that. Tiza delivers the engineering ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States.

How Tiza can help

If you have the utility’s requirements and need the service entrance protection designed, Tiza delivers engineering design remotely, in English, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the utility document and the single-line diagram, and we will scope the package with you.

References

  • NERC FAC-001, Facility Interconnection Requirements, for transmission owners’ published requirements.
  • The utility’s own service or interconnection requirements document, which governs each project.

Figure: single-line view of the service entrance, with the utility source, the breaker, the relay fed from current and voltage transformers, the trip source, the test switch and the telemetry link to the utility.

Frequently asked questions

Where do I find the utility's relay requirements?

In the utility's interconnection or electric service requirements document, often published on its website or given during the application. Utilities and transmission owners each issue their own. For a transmission-level customer, a facility interconnection requirements document is normally part of it. If you cannot find it, ask the utility's engineering contact and keep the reply in writing.

Does the utility design my service entrance protection?

No. The customer's engineer designs the protection on the customer side. The utility reviews it against its requirements and may ask for changes to functions, settings or testing. The design responsibility stays with the customer's engineer of record.

Is a utility-grade relay required for a plant with its own generation?

Often the requirements are stricter when a customer can export power or keep a feeder energized. Typical items are directional and voltage functions, a transfer trip and a witnessed test. The exact list is set by the utility and by the size and type of the generation.

WhatsApp