Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

Protection Coordination with the Utility: US Guide

Protection coordination with the utility, step by step: what data to request, where the plant curve must sit against the utility device and how to show it.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

utility sourceutilityfeeder relay0.60 sservice entrancerelay0.33-0.35 splant feederrelay0.08 s6,000 A faultPowerMeasure / tripat 6,000 A the utility relay takes 0.60 supper limit 0.60 - 0.25 = 0.35 splant device 0.08 s: lower 0.08 + 0.25 = 0.33 swindow 0.33 to 0.35 s, width 0.02 srepeat at the minimum fault: it can closet (s)I (A)1.0006,00010,0000.050.10.51utility 0.60 splant 0.08 swindow 0.02 sillustrative curves, not a real feederChecksUtility curveUpper limitLower limitWindowMinimum fault© tizagrp.comutility sourceutilityfeeder relay0.60 sservice entrancerelay0.33-0.35 splant feederrelay0.08 s6,000 A faultPowerMeasure / tripat 6,000 A the utility relay takes 0.60 supper limit 0.60 - 0.25 = 0.35 splant device 0.08 s: lower 0.08 + 0.25 = 0.33 swindow 0.33 to 0.35 s, width 0.02 srepeat at the minimum fault: it can closet (s)I (A)1.0006,00010,0000.050.10.51utility 0.60 splant 0.08 swindow 0.02 sillustrative curves, not a real feederChecksUtility curveUpper limitLower limitWindowMinimum fault© tizagrp.com
Coordination with the utility: three breakers in series, each with its own CT, relay and trip, a 6,000 A fault clearing at the plant feeder first, and the time-current window of 0.33 to 0.35 s for the service entrance relay between the 0.08 s plant device and the 0.60 s utility relay. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Coordinating with the utility means placing the plant's service entrance curve below the curve of the utility device upstream, with enough time between them, and above the plant's own downstream devices. The utility supplies the upstream device, its settings, its reclosing sequence and the fault levels. The customer's engineer builds the time-current plot and shows the margin at the highest and lowest faults. If the window is closed, the plant and the utility have to negotiate before energization.

Protection coordination with the utility is the part of a plant’s protection study that someone else has to agree with. The plant’s service entrance relay must clear plant faults before the utility’s device upstream reacts. It must not trip when the utility device is the right one to open. Below are the data to request, the shape of the plot, and the check that decides whether the two can coexist.

The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide. The service entrance requirements are in utility relay requirements for industrial customers. The paper trail is in relay setting submittals to utilities.

Short answer

To coordinate with the utility, get the upstream device and its settings in writing. Plot them with the plant’s service entrance device and the plant’s own downstream devices. Then check that the plant curve sits below the utility curve by the coordination interval, at every fault current from minimum to maximum. The plant device must also stay above the downstream plant devices by their own interval. Where both constraints cannot be met, the utility and the customer have to agree on a change before energization.

What to request from the utility

Ask for the following, in writing, and keep the reply with its date:

  • The upstream device: a feeder breaker with a relay, a recloser or a fuse, with make and model.
  • Its settings: pickup, curve and time dial or fuse size, plus any instantaneous element.
  • Its reclosing sequence, with the number of shots and the open intervals. A plant must stay safe through those operations. The guide on recloser settings explains the sequence.
  • Fault levels at the point of delivery: maximum and minimum, three-phase and ground, with X/R.
  • The utility transformer connection upstream, because it decides how ground faults look from the plant side.

If the utility only gives a fuse size or a recloser curve name, ask for the curve data too. A plot built on a guessed curve is not a coordination.

What to place on the plot

A time-current plot has current on the horizontal axis and time on the vertical one, both logarithmic. Draw, from the plant side outward:

  1. The largest downstream plant device that must stay selective.
  2. The service entrance relay or breaker curve, at the plant’s real settings.
  3. The utility’s upstream device, including its fast and delayed curves if a recloser.
  4. The plant’s transformer inrush point and the damage curves of the transformer and the main cable, so the setting protects what it should.

Mark the maximum and minimum fault current at the service entrance, because coordination holds at one end and fails at the other if the margin is thin. Plot on the same base current, which for a plant and a utility at the same voltage is the primary side. The method is in protection coordination step by step and its basis in the IEEE 242 guide.

The two constraints

Every device in the chain obeys two inequalities:

  • Upper limit: the plant’s service entrance device must operate faster than the utility device by the coordination interval.
  • Lower limit: the plant’s service entrance device must operate slower than the plant’s downstream device by the same kind of interval.

The coordination interval covers the relay tolerance, the breaker opening time and a safety margin. It is explained in coordination time interval (CTI). If the lower limit is higher than the upper limit, there is no setting that coordinates, and the choice moves to the next section.

When the window is closed

The options, in order of how much they involve the utility:

  • Speed up the downstream plant device so the lower limit drops.
  • Use a faster scheme between plant relays, such as blocking or interlocking, so the service entrance can be faster without losing selectivity.
  • Move a plant instantaneous element, if the minimum fault allows.
  • Ask the utility whether its setting can change. The decision is the utility’s.
  • Accept a documented loss of selectivity at a defined range of faults, with the utility’s written agreement.

The decision is documented in the review. A verbal agreement does not survive a change of staff.

Worked example: the window at a given fault

This example uses illustrative data. The utility curves and the plant curves are assumptions, not from a real feeder. The fault is 6,000 A at the service entrance. The coordination interval used is 0.25 s for both pairs.

  1. Utility feeder relay: its curve gives 0.60 s at 6,000 A.
  2. Upper limit for the plant service entrance device: 0.60 − 0.25 = 0.35 s.
  3. Largest plant downstream device: its curve gives 0.08 s at 6,000 A.
  4. Lower limit for the service entrance device: 0.08 + 0.25 = 0.33 s.
  5. Window: from 0.33 s to 0.35 s. The width is 0.35 − 0.33 = 0.02 s.

A setting exists, and the plant relay has to operate between 0.33 s and 0.35 s at 6,000 A. The margin of 0.02 s is small. If the relay tolerance alone is larger than that, the plot is not enough. The next steps would be a lower plant downstream time, a larger interval agreed with the utility or one of the options above. The point of the example is to run the two inequalities at the maximum fault, then repeat them at the minimum, where the utility device is usually slower. At the minimum fault, the window can close.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Written confirmation of the upstream device, settings, curve data and reclosing sequence.
  • Maximum and minimum fault current and X/R at the service entrance.
  • Plot with downstream plant devices, the service entrance, the utility device, inrush and damage curves.
  • Coordination interval stated, and where it came from.
  • Check at the maximum and at the minimum fault.
  • Check of the reclosing sequence against the plant’s motors and sensitive loads.
  • Ground fault coordination checked separately, with the transformer connections in view.
  • Decision log for any case where the window is closed, with the utility’s reply.

Who signs and seals

A coordination study for a US service entrance is normally reviewed and stamped by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Tiza delivers the study ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States.

How Tiza can help

If you need the coordination plot and the settings study prepared for the utility review, Tiza runs power-system studies remotely and delivers them in English, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the single-line diagram and the utility data you have, and we will scope the study with you.

References

  • IEEE 242-2001, Recommended Practice for Protection and Coordination of Industrial and Commercial Power Systems (the Buff Book).
  • The utility’s own interconnection or service requirements, which set the interval and the data it will supply.

Figure: time-current plot with the downstream plant device, the service entrance relay and the utility relay, showing the margin between each pair at the maximum fault.

Frequently asked questions

Who is responsible for coordinating the plant with the utility?

The customer's engineer designs the plant protection and shows how it coordinates with the utility device upstream. The utility supplies the upstream device data and reviews the result. If the two cannot coordinate, the utility may adjust its setting or ask the customer to change the plant's. The agreement is normally recorded in the review.

What data do I need from the utility to coordinate?

The upstream device type and its settings or fuse size, its curve family, its reclosing sequence, the maximum and minimum fault current and the X/R at the point of delivery, and the transformer connection on the utility side. Ask in writing and keep the date of the reply.

How much time should separate the plant device from the utility device?

It depends on the device types and the margin the utility accepts. The time interval is a design choice that covers relay tolerance, breaker time and a safety margin. Use the utility's stated value if it gives one, and see our guide on the coordination time interval for the components.

WhatsApp