Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

How to Review a Utility System Impact Study Report

How to review a utility interconnection study: check the base case, queue assumptions, plant model, results and cost shares, and write comments by section.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

1 Base case and queue assumptionssize, POI, case date, queue list, dispatch, upgrades2 Your plant modelinverters, step-up data, voltage mode, dynamic model3 Contingencies and criteriaevents studied, limits used, study types included4 Results and plausibilityrecompute the short-circuit contribution5 Network upgrades and cost sharesrecompute each share from the stated methodComments: section, table, expected value, one requestReview flowworked example: 120 MVA plant, 138 kVpass 4: rated 0.502 kA, at 1.2 times 0.602report: 3.2 kA is 6.4 times ratedpass 5: upgrade 9.0 M, 40 MW in total10 MW project: 50 % charged, 25 % duecomment: section, table, expected, askplant contribution at 138 kV, kA0.502 rated0.602 at 1.2 times0123 kAreport: 3.2 kA, 6.4 times ratedupgrade 9.0 M; contributions 18 + 12 + 10 = 40 MW18 MW4.05 M12 MW2.70 M10 MW2.25 Mcharged to the 10 MW project: 4.5 M, 50 %due: 2.25 Millustrative valuesReview passesInputsModelCriteriaResultsCost shares© tizagrp.com1 Base case and queue assumptionssize, POI, case date, queue list, dispatch, upgrades2 Your plant modelinverters, step-up data, voltage mode, dynamic model3 Contingencies and criteriaevents studied, limits used, study types included4 Results and plausibilityrecompute the short-circuit contribution5 Network upgrades and cost sharesrecompute each share from the stated methodComments: section, table, expected value, one requestReview flowworked example: 120 MVA plant, 138 kVpass 4: rated 0.502 kA, at 1.2 times 0.602report: 3.2 kA is 6.4 times ratedpass 5: upgrade 9.0 M, 40 MW in total10 MW project: 50 % charged, 25 % duecomment: section, table, expected, askplant contribution at 138 kV, kA0.502 rated0.602 at 1.2 times0123 kAreport: 3.2 kA, 6.4 times ratedupgrade 9.0 M; contributions 18 + 12 + 10 = 40 MW18 MW4.05 M12 MW2.70 M10 MW2.25 Mcharged to the 10 MW project: 4.5 M, 50 %due: 2.25 Millustrative valuesReview passesInputsModelCriteriaResultsCost shares© tizagrp.com
Review of a utility interconnection study as a flow chart of five passes: base case and queue assumptions, your plant model, contingencies and criteria, results and plausibility with the short-circuit recomputation, and network upgrades with cost shares, ending in comments by section and table, with the worked example of a 120 MVA plant at 138 kV: rated current 0.502 kA, 0.602 kA at 1.2 times rated against 3.2 kA reported, 6.4 times rated, and a 9.0 million dollar upgrade shared 45, 30 and 25 percent against 50 percent charged to the 10 MW project. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

A utility interconnection study report can be checked in five passes: the base case and queue assumptions, the model of your plant, the contingencies and criteria, the results with a plausibility check, and the cost allocation. Each pass has a few numbers to recompute. Comments should cite the section and table, state what you expected and ask for the correction or the input file. The review is done by a qualified engineer and the owner decides what to contest.

Short answer: how to review a utility interconnection study

To review a utility interconnection study, work in five passes: inputs, plant model, contingencies and criteria, results, and cost shares. Start with the inputs, because a wrong base case or a wrong plant model carries into every table that follows. Two of the checks have a numeric example below. The study stages are in interconnection study stages: feasibility, SIS, facilities, within the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide.

Pass 1: base case and queue assumptions

Open the report’s list of assumptions and compare it with your own data:

  • Plant size in MW and MVA, and the point of interconnection by name and voltage.
  • The in-service date and the date of the base case. A case built two years before your date may omit upgrades that are already planned.
  • The list of higher-queued projects included, and whether their status matches the queue as published. Under FERC Order No. 2023 many regions study requests in clusters, so check which requests are in your cluster.
  • The load level and dispatch used: peak, light load, and the output of nearby plants.
  • Whether network upgrades assumed built are the ones in the utility’s own plan.

The study depends on the base case. If you cannot reproduce the main inputs from the report, ask for the case files.

Pass 2: your plant model

The report should show how your plant was modeled. Compare these items with the design:

  • Inverter count, MVA rating and the step-up transformer data, including impedance and tap range.
  • The collector system and the gen-tie, or a note that they were lumped.
  • The voltage control mode at the point of interconnection, the reactive capability and the power factor range.
  • The dynamic model and its settings, including ride-through and protection. The settings should match what the inverter will really be set to, as in NERC PRC-029 and IEEE 2800 model and simulation requirements.
  • Storage: charging and discharging cases, if you have a battery.

A model with default parameters, instead of the manufacturer’s data, can give results that do not apply to the equipment installed.

Pass 3: contingencies and criteria

Check which events were studied and against which limits. A planner works under its own criteria, as in NERC TPL-001 transmission planning studies. Look for the list of single and multiple contingencies, the thermal and voltage limits used, and whether short-circuit, stability and affected-system studies are included. A missing study type is a comment on its own.

Pass 4: results and plausibility

For each overload or violation, find the element, the contingency, the pre-project flow and the project’s contribution. Then recompute a few of them.

Short-circuit contribution. For an inverter-based plant, rated current is close to the plant’s contribution at the point of interconnection. Recompute it from the nameplate and compare it with the report. For power flow, ask whether the distribution factor of your plant on the overloaded element is consistent with the network topology.

Pass 5: network upgrades and cost shares

The report lists the upgrades, their cost and each project’s share. Recompute the shares from the stated method. The method is set by the tariff or the procedures of the transmission provider, so cite it in your comment, not your own view.

Worked example (illustrative)

A report covers a 120 MVA inverter-based plant at 138 kV.

  1. Rated current: 120 MVA / (√3 × 138 kV) = 0.502 kA.
  2. Expected contribution at 1.2 times rated current: 1.2 × 0.502 = 0.602 kA.
  3. The report states a plant contribution of 3.2 kA. The ratio is 3.2 / 0.502 = 6.4 times rated current, far above what an inverter delivers. The plant was probably modeled as a synchronous source. Ask for the model and the corrected breaker duty results.
  4. Cost shares: an upgrade costs 9.0 million dollars, and three projects contribute 18, 12 and 10 MW to the overload, a total of 40 MW. Proportional shares are 45%, 30% and 25%, which is 4.05, 2.70 and 2.25 million dollars. If your 10 MW project is charged 4.5 million dollars, which is 50% of the upgrade, the report does not match its own method. Ask for the calculation.

Both comments cite a table, state what was expected and ask for an input or a correction.

How to write the comments

  • One comment per finding, with section and table number.
  • State the data in the report, the data you expected and the source.
  • Ask for one thing: a correction, a file or an explanation.
  • Keep the tone factual and send comments inside the period the process gives you.
  • Keep a log of the answers, because later stages build on them.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Reproduce the plant inputs from the report.
  • Check the base case date, the queue list and the upgrades assumed.
  • Compare the model with the equipment data sheets.
  • Confirm the studies included: thermal, voltage, short circuit, stability, affected systems.
  • Recompute at least one short-circuit value and one cost share.
  • Ask for the case files when an input cannot be reproduced.
  • File comments within the deadline and keep the responses.

The decision to contest a study, and every filing, belong to the interconnection customer. Tiza prepares engineering and studies ready for your engineer of record, a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project, to review and stamp. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify, and it does not sell a NERC certification.

An independent read of the study

An independent review finds the errors before they become a cost. We review third-party interconnection studies and prepare the engineering and the power-system studies behind your comments, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the report and the plant data.

Figure: five review passes from inputs to cost shares, with the checks of each pass.

References

  • FERC Order No. 2023, Improvements to Generator Interconnection Procedures and Agreements, and the pro forma procedures.
  • The transmission provider’s tariff and interconnection procedures for the project.
  • NERC TPL-001-5.1, Transmission System Planning Performance Requirements.

Frequently asked questions

What should I check first in a system impact study?

The inputs. Confirm the study uses your plant's correct size, point of interconnection, voltage control mode and model, and the right list of higher-queued projects. A wrong input makes every later result wrong.

How can I tell if a short-circuit result is plausible?

Compare the reported plant contribution with the rated current. An inverter-based plant normally contributes close to its rated current, often 1.1 to 1.2 times. A contribution several times larger suggests a model set up as a synchronous source.

Can I contest cost shares in the report?

You can ask for the allocation method and inputs and recompute the shares. The method itself comes from the utility tariff or the transmission provider's procedures, so the comment should cite them.

WhatsApp