Reviewing a coordination study made by another firm does not require redoing it. Four groups of five points are checked: the input data, the short circuit, the curves and margins, and the settings with their delivery. An independent calculation of one or two critical points is enough to detect whether the settings table and the report curves say the same thing.
Short answer
Reviewing a coordination study made by another firm does not require redoing it. Four groups of five points are checked: the input data, the short circuit, the curves and margins, and the settings with their delivery. In addition, one or two critical points are recalculated independently, for example the relay trip time for the maximum fault, and compared with what the report says. If the report and your calculation agree, the study is consistent. If not, a written clarification is requested before a single setting is loaded.
If you need to know what a well-made study should contain, start with what a protection coordination study needs and the coordination method step by step.
When a review is advisable
There are four typical moments. When you hired the study from a provider and must approve it before paying the last milestone. When the study was delivered by the works contractor together with the equipment. When the grid operator made comments and you need to know whether they are valid. And when you inherited a plant with an old study and wonder whether it is still good. In the last case, the first point of the list (is the study’s one-line diagram the plant as it is today?) usually yields the most.
Group 1: input data (points 1 to 5)
- The study’s one-line diagram matches the installation and carries a date.
- Transformers list power, voltages, impedance, connection and grounding.
- Cables list size, material, length and number of conductors per phase.
- The devices in the study are the ones installed: make, model and curve version.
- Current transformer ratios and the settings in force at the start are recorded.
The most common error is here. A perfect study on an outdated one-line diagram gives settings that are no good. To see what data each piece of equipment needs, see equipment data for a short-circuit study.
Group 2: short circuit (points 6 to 10)
- The grid operator’s network is represented by an equivalent with a date and an origin.
- Maximum and minimum currents were calculated at each bus.
- The fault types used correspond to the system grounding.
- The operating scenarios are listed and justified.
- The contribution of motors and own generation is included where it applies.
The minimum current is the one most often forgotten, and it decides whether a relay sees the fault at the end of a feeder. See short-circuit currents for setting protections.
Group 3: curves and margins (points 11 to 15)
- The damage curves of the main cables are there.
- The damage curve of each transformer and its inrush point are there.
- The starting of large motors is there.
- The coordination interval between devices is declared and respected.
- Each pair of devices, upstream and downstream, was checked in every scenario.
To understand what each curve protects, see damage curves of cables, motors and transformers.
Group 4: settings and delivery (points 16 to 20)
- The settings table states the unit: current transformer secondary and primary.
- The settings fit the functions and ranges of the installed relay.
- There is a calculation record and a model file so the study can be repeated.
- Where selectivity was not achieved, the report says so and explains why.
- There is a settings loading plan, with prior backup and version record.
Point 17 is the one that exposes studies made «on paper»: a setting of 1.63 A in a relay whose setting step were 0.05 A could not be loaded as written.
Worked example: a medium-voltage relay
Example data. Assumed data for illustration. A 1000 kVA transformer, 13.2 kV / 0.48 kV, impedance 5.75 %. The 51 relay on the 13.2 kV side uses the IEC 60255-151 normal inverse curve, whose time is t = TMS × 0.14 / ((I / Is)^0.02 − 1). The report sets the pickup at 1.5 times the rated current and TMS = 0.30, and says that at maximum fault the relay trips in 0.45 s. The low-voltage breaker is assumed to clear in 0.05 s and the required margin is 0.3 s.
Step 1. Rated current at 13.2 kV. In = 1000 / (√3 × 13.2) = 1000 / 22.863 = 43.74 A.
Step 2. Pickup. Is = 1.5 × 43.74 = 65.61 A.
Step 3. Maximum fault seen from 13.2 kV, with an infinite source. I = In / Z = 43.74 / 0.0575 = 760.7 A. This equals 760.7 × 13.2 / 0.48 = 20 918 A on the low-voltage side.
Step 4. Relay time with TMS = 0.30. I / Is = 760.7 / 65.61 = 11.594. Raised to 0.02 it gives 1.0502, and minus 1 gives 0.0502. The time with TMS = 1 is 0.14 / 0.0502 = 2.787 s, and with TMS = 0.30 it is 0.836 s.
Step 5. Comparison with the report. The report says 0.45 s; the calculation gives 0.84 s. They do not match. To give 0.45 s the TMS would have to be 0.45 / 2.787 = 0.16.
Step 6. Margin. With the calculation: 0.836 − 0.05 = 0.786 s, which exceeds 0.3 s. With the report’s value: 0.45 − 0.05 = 0.40 s, which also exceeds it. The margin is met in both cases, but the table and the curves are not consistent.
Step 7. Energization. The inrush point is taken as 12 times In = 524.9 A for 0.1 s. I / Is = 8.0. With TMS = 0.30 the relay takes 0.989 s and does not trip on energization. With TMS = 0.16 it takes 0.527 s and does not trip either.
Remark for the review report: the study does not state which TMS is the right one (0.30 or 0.16). They are asked to clarify it and to correct the table or the curve before the setting is loaded into the relay.
What to deliver when the review is done
A short report in three parts: the checklist points that pass, those that fail with the evidence, and the questions the study’s author must answer. Each remark cites the checklist point and the specific figure, as in the example. That way the author can answer without arguing.
Checklist
- I received the study with its model and calculation record.
- I checked the 5 input data points.
- I checked the 5 short-circuit points.
- I checked the 5 curves and margins points.
- I checked the 5 settings and delivery points.
- I independently recalculated at least one critical point.
- I compared my calculation with the report’s table and curves.
- I wrote the remarks with the checklist point and the figure.
- I got a written answer before loading the settings.
Related guides
- What a protection coordination study needs
- Protection coordination step by step (IEEE 242)
- Damage curves of cables, motors and transformers
- Time and current selectivity in MV
- Lack of selectivity: several feeders trip
- Short-circuit currents for setting protections
When to call us
Do you need this study? We review coordination studies made by other firms and, if needed, redo them, from engineering design and studies, for plants and substations in any country. We give you a review report with the 20-point list and substantiated remarks. Contact us.
References
- IEC 60255-151, Measuring relays and protection equipment, Part 151: Functional requirements for over/under current protection (normal inverse curve formula).
- IEEE Std 242-2001, IEEE Recommended Practice for Protection and Coordination of Industrial and Commercial Power Systems (Buff Book), clauses 15.6 and 15.7.
Frequently asked questions
Is reviewing a study the same as redoing it?
No. The review checks that the data, the criteria and the results are consistent with each other. One or two critical points are recalculated by hand, such as a relay's trip for the maximum fault, and checked against the curves and the settings table. If they do not match, a clarification is requested before the settings are loaded.
What difference between the report and my calculation is acceptable?
Small differences from rounding or from the version of the formula are normal. A large difference, such as 0.45 s against 0.84 s for the same current and the same settings, points to an error in the data, the setting or the table, and must be clarified in writing.
Can I load the study's settings once it passes review?
Only with a settings commissioning plan: backup of the previous settings, loading per device, testing of each function and a record of the final state. Reviewing the study does not replace testing the relay.