Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

ENA G5/5: Harmonic Voltage Distortion in the UK

ENA EREC G5/5 sets how UK network operators assess harmonic voltage distortion from new connections: three stages, resonant plant and a worked THD check.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

150 MVA grid source11 kV bus (PCC)bank 4 MVArbank 6 MVAr~==~Mdriveharmonic currentparallel resonance with the sourceh = √(source MVA / bank MVAr)4 MVAr: h = √(150 / 4) = 6.1 (5th to 7th)6 MVAr: h = √(150 / 6) = 5.0, on the 5thTHD = √(0.9² + 0.7² + 0.5² + 0.3²) = 1.28 %Z against source aloneharmonic order h13579111316.15.00.9 %0.7 %0.5 %0.3 %% of fundamentalillustrative: 1.5 % allocation, margin 0.22AssessmentSourceBankResonanceHarmonicsTHD© tizagrp.com150 MVA grid source11 kV bus (PCC)bank 4 MVArbank 6 MVAr~==~Mdriveharmonic currentparallel resonance with the sourceh = √(source MVA / bank MVAr)4 MVAr: h = √(150 / 4) = 6.1 (5th to 7th)6 MVAr: h = √(150 / 6) = 5.0, on the 5thTHD = √(0.9² + 0.7² + 0.5² + 0.3²) = 1.28 %Z against source aloneharmonic order h13579111316.15.00.9 %0.7 %0.5 %0.3 %% of fundamentalillustrative: 1.5 % allocation, margin 0.22AssessmentSourceBankResonanceHarmonicsTHD© tizagrp.com
G5/5 harmonic resonance: an 11 kV bus fed by a 150 MVA source with a capacitor bank and a drive injecting harmonic current, the impedance against harmonic order with the parallel resonance at order 6.1 for a 4 MVAr bank and at order 5.0 for 6 MVAr, and the harmonic voltages of 0.9, 0.7, 0.5 and 0.3 percent giving 1.28 percent distortion. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

ENA Engineering Recommendation G5/5 is the UK document network operators use to assess harmonic voltage distortion when a new load or generator connects. It works in three stages, from a simple screening to a detailed study with a harmonic specification from the operator, and it also covers resonant plant such as capacitor banks and long cables. The limits are on voltage at the connection point, not on the current of one machine.

Short answer: what ENA G5/5 sets

ENA G5/5 is the UK recommendation for assessing harmonic voltage distortion from new connections. The network operator uses it to decide whether a load, a generator or a resonant plant can connect without pushing the voltage distortion on the network past its planning levels. G5/5 is the fifth revision of G5 and replaced G5/4 in 2020. It applies to transmission and distribution networks, and to the users that connect to them: demand, generation and storage. The wider framework is in the UK electrical codes and grid connection guide.

What G5/5 changed from G5/4

Compared with the previous revision, G5/5:

  • extends planning and compatibility levels from harmonic order 50 (2.5 kHz) to order 100 (5 kHz), and defines interharmonic limits more clearly;
  • uses voltage ranges that match typical UK voltages instead of single voltage levels;
  • raises some planning levels and lowers none;
  • revises the limits for voltage notches;
  • adds a section on resonant plant, such as power factor correction capacitors and long cables;
  • rewrites the third stage so that limits are allocated from available headroom, with a harmonic specification from the network operator and a standard compliance report.

The numerical levels are in G5/5 itself.

The three stages

G5/5 keeps a three-stage assessment. The idea is that a small, simple connection should not need a full study.

StageWhat it isTypical outcome
1Simple screening of the connection against criteria in the documentMany small connections end here
2A more detailed check using the equipment’s harmonic data and the network’s strengthPass, or continue to stage 3
3Detailed assessment at the network operator, with a harmonic specification and a compliance reportRequired at 33 kV and above, and for anything that fails stage 2

For resonant plant below 33 kV a simple assessment process applies. Equipment connected at 33 kV and above goes straight to stage 3. Tell the operator early about a large rectifier, drive or converter plant, so the harmonic data can be gathered in time.

Harmonics from generation and inverters

Inverters produce harmonics too, and a solar or battery plant is assessed in the same way as a large load. The plant’s own transformer and cables can shift a resonance into the range where the inverter emits. The guide on IEEE 519 with inverters and generation explains the same problem under the US rule. The assessment needs the harmonic emission data of the inverters, which manufacturers provide in their test reports.

Worked example: resonance and distortion

All values are illustrative.

Part 1: where a capacitor bank resonates. An 11 kV bus has a short-circuit level of 150 MVA. A power factor correction bank of 4 MVAr is planned. The parallel resonance order is approximately h = √(short-circuit MVA ÷ bank MVAr).

  • With 4 MVAr: h = √(150 ÷ 4) = 6.1. This sits between the 5th and 7th harmonics, which are common in drives, so the bank is close to a harmonic that is present in the network.
  • With 6 MVAr: h = √(150 ÷ 6) = 5.0. This is exactly the 5th harmonic, and a 6 MVAr bank would be a poor choice without a detuning reactor.

A resonance near an emitted harmonic multiplies the voltage at that frequency. This is why G5/5 includes resonant plant: the bank may not emit anything, and still cause the problem.

Part 2: total harmonic voltage distortion. Suppose a measurement or study gives these harmonic voltages as a percentage of the fundamental: 5th = 0.9 %, 7th = 0.7 %, 11th = 0.5 %, 13th = 0.3 %. Total harmonic distortion (THD) = √(0.9² + 0.7² + 0.5² + 0.3²) = √(0.81 + 0.49 + 0.25 + 0.09) = √1.64 = 1.28 %.

Part 3: compare with a level. Assume, for this example only, an allocation of 1.5 % total for the connection. 1.28 % is below it, so the result passes, with a margin of 0.22 percentage points. If the bank in Part 1 were the 6 MVAr size, the 5th harmonic voltage could grow and the sum would be recalculated. The planning levels used in a real case come from G5/5 and from the harmonic specification given by the operator.

Where it overlaps with other methods

The sister document on voltage steps and flicker is ENA P28, and the connection route is in G98 versus G99. The guide on IEEE 519 harmonic studies uses the same arithmetic of summing harmonic voltages. The compatibility levels for low-voltage networks are in IEC 61000-2-2 levels. The point of common coupling concept is the same idea as the connection point in G5/5. For filters that fix a resonance problem, see harmonic filters. Measurements with the right class of instrument are described in the power quality analyzer guide.

Why resonance is the usual surprise

A capacitor bank and the network inductance form a parallel circuit. At its resonant frequency the impedance seen by a harmonic source becomes large, so a small harmonic current produces a large voltage. Cables add capacitance as well, which is why long cables sit in the same group as capacitor banks. Detuning reactors move the resonance below the lowest harmonic that is present, and filters absorb the harmonic current directly. The choice is made in the study, with the actual network data.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Identify the connection voltage and which stage applies.
  • Collect harmonic emission data for every drive, rectifier or inverter.
  • Calculate the resonance order of every capacitor bank and long cable.
  • Ask the network operator for the short-circuit level and for its harmonic specification.
  • Compare the sum of harmonic voltages with the levels the operator gives.
  • Decide on detuning reactors or filters before ordering a capacitor bank.
  • Measure the existing distortion before the connection, with a suitable instrument.
  • Keep the assessment and the compliance report with the connection file.

From the rules to a study your chartered engineer can review

A harmonic assessment needs a model of the network, the emission data and the resonance checks. We prepare the power-system studies, harmonic and resonance included, ready for your chartered engineer to review and sign before they go to the network operator. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify studies in the UK. Contact us with the single-line diagram and the equipment data.

Frequently asked questions

What is ENA G5/5?

G5/5 is the fifth revision of ENA Engineering Recommendation G5, the UK recommendation for assessing harmonic voltage distortion on transmission and distribution networks and for connecting harmonic sources and resonant plant. It came into use in 2020 and replaced G5/4.

How does G5/5 differ from IEEE 519?

Both address harmonics, but G5/5 sets planning and compatibility levels for voltage and a staged assessment run with the network operator. IEEE 519 puts voltage limits on the network owner and current limits on the user at the point of common coupling. Neither replaces the other in its country.

Does a capacitor bank need a G5/5 assessment?

Plant that can resonate, such as power factor correction capacitors and long cables, is covered by G5/5. A simple assessment process applies to resonant plant below 33 kV, and the network operator says what it needs for a given site.

WhatsApp