ENA Engineering Recommendation P28 Issue 2 (2018) sets how network operators assess voltage fluctuations caused by new connections: flicker and rapid voltage changes. It uses a staged assessment, and the flicker headroom left on a network is allocated to connections as they come. The first check is arithmetic: the voltage step a load causes at the connection point compared with the short-circuit level.
Short answer: what ENA P28 covers
ENA P28 is the UK recommendation for assessing voltage fluctuations from customer equipment connected to the public supply system. Issue 2 was published in 2018 and replaced Issue 1 of 1989. It covers two effects: flicker, which is the visible change in light output from lamps, and rapid voltage changes, which are single steps in the supply voltage. It applies to new connections of disturbing equipment and to changes of existing connections. For the wider framework, see the UK electrical codes and grid connection guide.
What Issue 2 added
Issue 2:
- adds requirements and planning levels for rapid voltage changes, with limits based on an envelope.
- adds an intermediate planning level and the matching flicker severity limits for networks at 3.3 kV, 6.6 kV, 11 kV, 20 kV and 33 kV.
- requires the assessment to be done under worst-case normal operating conditions.
- keeps the three-stage assessment for flicker, and the approach that the remaining flicker headroom is allocated first come, first served.
Issue 2 became applicable on 23 May 2019. The numerical planning levels are in P28 itself.
Flicker, steps and the stages
Flicker is measured with the short-term severity Pst, over ten minutes, and the long-term severity Plt, over two hours. The concepts are explained in the guides on Pst and Plt and when flicker becomes a nuisance. P28 builds on them in a staged assessment.
| Stage | Idea |
|---|---|
| 1 | Screening: if the load change is small compared with the short-circuit level, no more work is needed |
| 2 | A calculation of the step and of the flicker contribution, using equipment data and the network’s strength |
| 3 | A detailed assessment against the headroom left on the network; the connection may be refused or reinforced if there is none |
Because headroom is allocated as connections arrive, a project that comes first uses the margin and the next one inherits less. This is a reason to ask the network operator for the available level early.
Which equipment needs attention
- Large motors started direct on line, or often.
- Arc furnaces and welding plant. The guide on the electric arc furnace transformer shows why they are the textbook case.
- Compressors, crushers and mills with a repeating load cycle.
- Generation with fast output changes, such as wind turbines and solar plants.
The harmonic side of the same assessment is in the G5/5 guide, and the S34 guide covers substation earthing, another ENA document in DNO studies. For solar and storage, the inverter ramp rate and the plant controller settings matter. They are covered alongside PPC testing.
Worked example: the voltage step from a load change
All values are illustrative. An 11 kV bus has a short-circuit level of 200 MVA and an X/R ratio of 10. A plant connects a load that changes by 1.2 MW and 0.9 MVAr in one step.
Step 1. Source impedance. Z = V² ÷ S_sc = 11² ÷ 200 = 0.605 Ω.
Step 2. Resistance and reactance. With X/R = 10: X = Z × 10 ÷ √101 = 0.602 Ω, and R = X ÷ 10 = 0.0602 Ω.
Step 3. Voltage step. ΔV ≈ (R × ΔP + X × ΔQ) ÷ V², with ΔP = 1.2 MW and ΔQ = 0.9 MVAr. ΔV = (0.0602 × 1.2 + 0.602 × 0.9) ÷ 121 = (0.0722 + 0.5418) ÷ 121 = 0.00507, or 0.51 %.
Step 4. Compare with a limit. Assume, for this example only, that the operator gives a step limit of 1 % for this type of change. 0.51 % is half of it, so the step passes with margin. If the same load change were applied where the short-circuit level is 60 MVA, the step would be about 0.51 × 200 ÷ 60 = 1.7 %, above the assumed limit, and the project would need a smaller step, a soft starter or network reinforcement.
Step 5. Repetition. A single step is judged against the step limit. If the same change repeats several times a minute, the flicker severity Pst is what counts. It is calculated with the repetition rate, following the stages of P28. The flicker meter is defined in IEC 61000-4-15.
Ways to reduce the step
When the step is too large, there are four usual options. Start motors with a soft starter or a drive. Split a load into smaller steps with a delay between them. Use a connection point with a higher short-circuit level. Or reinforce the network. Each has a cost, and the study shows which one is cheapest for the project. A static compensator is used for arc furnaces and similar loads where the changes are fast and repeated.
Checklist for the engineer
- Ask the network operator for the short-circuit level and the X/R ratio at the connection point.
- List every load or source that changes quickly, with the size and rate of the change.
- Calculate the voltage step and compare it with the limit the operator gives.
- Calculate the flicker contribution for repeating loads.
- Consider soft starters, drives or a smaller step before asking for reinforcement.
- Ask what flicker headroom is left at the connection point.
- Measure existing flicker with a suitable instrument before the connection, and afterwards.
- Keep the assessment with the connection file.
From the rules to a study your chartered engineer can review
A flicker or voltage step assessment needs the network data, the load profile and the stage the operator applies. We prepare the power-system studies for that assessment, with the calculations laid out so your chartered engineer can review and sign them before they go to the network operator. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify studies in the UK. Contact us with the load data and the DNO’s requirements.
Frequently asked questions
What is ENA P28?
P28 is the ENA Engineering Recommendation for voltage fluctuations on the public electricity supply system caused by customer equipment. Issue 2, published in 2018, covers flicker and rapid voltage changes, and replaced Issue 1 of 1989.
Does P28 apply to existing connections?
It applies to new connections of disturbing equipment and to changes to existing connections that affect voltage fluctuation. It is not intended to be applied retrospectively to existing connections that were assessed under Issue 1 and remain unchanged.
What causes the voltage steps that P28 limits?
Loads that change quickly, such as large motor starts, arc furnaces, welders, and generation whose output changes fast, for example wind turbines or solar plants during rapid cloud cover. The size of the step depends on the load change and on the strength of the network at the connection point.