Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Protection, control and communications

Recloser and Sectionaliser Schemes on Feeders

Feeder protection schemes with reclosers, sectionalisers and fuses in a utility norm: sectionalising rules, counts, operation limits and 34.5 kV lockout.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

Short answer

A utility design and construction norm (version 00, 2005) describes feeder protection schemes with reclosers, sectionalisers and fuses and normalises rural substations with 34.5 kV reclosers. Its own rules: at least two sectionalising points on the main circuit, at most four recloser operations before lockout with sectionalisers in series, and closing blocked and fast curve disabled on a 34.5 kV recloser while a transformer is energised.

Short answer

A utility design and construction norm (version 00, 2005) sets three things for reclosers on feeders: the sectionalising rules of the 13.2 kV circuit (chapter 1), the protection schemes with reclosers, sectionalisers and fuses (chapter 3), and the rural substation with 34.5 kV reclosers (chapter 7).

Sectionalising of the 13.2 kV circuit

  • At least two normally closed sectionalising elements on the main circuit, giving three sections of about 1,000 kVA each.
  • Design load up to 3,000 kVA normal and 4,000 kVA emergency; each section must give or receive up to 1,200 kVA from another circuit.
  • A branch above 1,000 kVA counts as main circuit: no fuses at the tap, 400 A single-pole switches.

Schemes with a recloser

SchemeEffectLimitation noted by the norm
Fused branches, recloser or breaker at the headTemporary faults cleared by the fast trip before the fuse is damaged; permanent ones by the fuseFusing short branches is not recommended: the fuse may operate together with the first fast trip
Recloser at the head, sectionalisers on branchesA temporary fault on a branch does not take out the whole systemA permanent fault on the main feeder causes total loss
Reclosers in series on the main feeder, sectionalisers on branchesFor customers needing high reliability on long systemsMost expensive; a permanent fault between two reclosers leaves the downstream section without service

A fourth scheme places sectionalisers in series on the main feeder under one head recloser.

Permanent fault on a branch with a sectionaliser
  1. Recloser: Fault on the branch. Detected by the recloser
  2. Recloser: Trip and reclose. Each opening is counted
  3. Sectionaliser: Counts the openings. While the recloser is open
  4. Sectionaliser: Set count reached? Yes: continue; No: back to step 2.
  5. Sectionaliser: Opens and isolates the branch. De-energised, during the dead time
  6. Recloser: Recloses. The rest of the feeder stays in service

Counts

With series sectionalisers the norm sets one count less each time. In its example the farthest sectionaliser has one count, the next two, the next three, and the recloser at most four operations before lockout. Two cautions: the sum of the recloser’s trip and reclose times must not exceed the sectionaliser’s memory time, and a single-count sectionaliser may read transformer inrush as a fault. Coordination between recloser, sectionaliser and fuse must also be studied so that the sectionaliser does not lock open before the fuse.

34.5 kV rural substation

For 0.5 to 2.0 MVA, the 34.5 kV module has 600 A, 38 kV single-pole switches, a 400 A recloser with built-in current transformers and a 27 kV surge arrester. The norm sets three rules for the 34.5 kV recloser:

  1. Closing is blocked, because operating onto a fault can damage the power transformer.
  2. Its maximum-time curve stays below the transformer thermal capability (ANSI C57.92).
  3. When energising the transformer, the fast curve is blocked until inrush disappears; the slow curve applies and the control locks out on permanent faults.

Worked example (assumptions)

A 13.2 kV circuit with 2,700 kVA normal load.

  1. Three sections: 2,700 ÷ 3 = 900 kVA each, within the norm’s guide of about 1,000 kVA.
  2. Load current: I = 2,700 ÷ (√3 × 13.2) = 2,700 ÷ 22.86 = 118 A.
  3. Three series sectionalisers get counts of one, two and three, with at most four recloser operations.

Limits of the norm

It is a 2005 text, version 00, with no telecontrol or communications requirements for reclosers. Confirm the current version with the utility.

Checklist

  • Two or more normally closed sectionalising points on the main circuit.
  • Descending sectionaliser counts and at most four recloser operations.
  • Trip and reclose times within sectionaliser memory time.
  • 34.5 kV recloser: closing blocked, curve under transformer capability, fast curve blocked on energisation.

How Tiza can help

We carry out the coordination study, calculate the recloser and sectionaliser settings and configure the recloser control remotely: see remote recloser configuration. Contact us with the study and the utility’s requirements.

Sources

  • ANSI C57.92, loading guide for mineral-oil-immersed power transformers, cited by the norm.

Frequently asked questions

How many operations may a recloser have with series sectionalisers?

At most four operations in total before lockout. Series sectionalisers are set one count lower each time: in the norm's example, three, two and one from the source toward the load.

What does the norm do with the 34.5 kV recloser when energising a transformer?

The fast curve is blocked until inrush current has disappeared. Meanwhile the slow curve applies and the control locks out on permanent faults, with no reclosing. Closing is also blocked, and the maximum-time curve must stay below the transformer thermal capability (ANSI C57.92).

How many sectionalising elements does a 13.2 kV circuit need?

At least two normally closed elements on the main circuit, splitting it into three sections of about 1,000 kVA each. A branch above 1,000 kVA is treated as main circuit: no fuses at the tap, 400 A single-pole switches.

WhatsApp