Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Protection, control and communications

Industrial Customer Protection at 34.5 kV: Recloser Option

Protection table for industrial customers at 34.5 kV in a utility norm: where a recloser is optional and why settings are agreed with the utility.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

Short answer

A utility design and construction norm (version 00, 2005) lists the protection for industrial customers at 34.5 kV by transformer rating. Between 1,000 and 5,000 kVA a recloser appears as an option next to the load-break switch with trip coil or the relay-driven breaker. The customer's protection systems and operating times must be agreed with the utility during design approval, commissioning and connection.

Short answer

A utility design and construction norm for its medium- and low-voltage levels (version 00, 2005) has a protection table for industrial customers at 34.5 kV. In the 1,000 to 2,000 kVA and 2,500 to 5,000 kVA ranges a recloser is optional.

What the table sets

Transformer ratingSwitching and protection equipmentRecloser
1,000 to 2,000 kVALoad-break switch with trip coil driven by temperature and Buchholz relays; in one column, breaker or switch with that coilOptional
2,500 to 5,000 kVABreaker driven by temperature, Buchholz, phase overcurrent, differential and trip-and-lockout relaysOptional

Agreeing the protection with the utility

The customer’s protection must meet the protection section of the applicable distribution code: reliability, safety, selectivity and fast disconnection, with solid-state, analogue or digital relays. The norm cites IEC 255, now the IEC 60255 series.

The key condition: the customer’s protection systems and operating times are agreed with the utility during design approval, commissioning and connection, and the utility may review them periodically. A customer recloser therefore enters the coordination study with the utility’s network data before the equipment is bought.

Closing the protection of an industrial customer at 34.5 kV
  1. Customer: Design with the table's protection. Transformer rating and installation type
  2. Customer: Coordination study. Equipment curves against the utility network
  3. Utility: Settings and times accepted? Yes: continue; No: back to step 2.
  4. Customer: Commissioning with the agreed settings. Protection tests
  5. Utility: Connection. Periodic review possible

Series reclosers

In chapter 3 the norm notes that, where customers need high reliability and the network is long, reclosers in series can be added on the main feeder with sectionalisers on the branches. It calls this the most expensive scheme and says it is widely used for industrial customers. Coordination between reclosers depends on operating modes, time-current curves and reclose intervals. See recloser and sectionaliser schemes on feeders.

Worked example (assumptions)

A 1,600 kVA transformer at 34.5 kV.

  1. 1,600 kVA falls in the 1,000 to 2,000 kVA range: load-break switch with trip coil, recloser optional.
  2. Rated current: I = 1,600 ÷ (√3 × 34.5) = 1,600 ÷ 59.76 = 26.8 A.
  3. If a recloser is chosen, the selection and settings are agreed with the utility.

Limits of the norm

The protection table dates from 2005 (version 00) and does not say what communications a customer recloser needs; if the utility asks for them, they are fixed at design approval. Confirm the current version before designing.

Checklist

  • Rating and installation type found in the protection table.
  • Recloser option decided with the utility.
  • Protection scheme consistent with the distribution code.
  • Operating times agreed in writing.

How Tiza can help

We carry out the coordination study, calculate the protection settings and configure the recloser control remotely: see remote recloser configuration. Contact us with the study and the utility’s requirements.

Sources

  • IEC 60255 series, measuring relays and protection equipment (formerly IEC 255).

Frequently asked questions

Is a recloser mandatory for an industrial customer?

In the norm's 34.5 kV table it is listed as optional for 1,000 to 2,000 kVA and 2,500 to 5,000 kVA. The switching and protection equipment the table sets for each range is the requirement; the recloser is an alternative agreed with the utility.

Who sets the customer's protection settings?

The customer designs them, but the protection systems and operating times must be agreed with the utility during design approval, commissioning and connection, and the utility may review them periodically.

Is the norm current?

The published copy is dated November 2005, version 00. Confirm with the utility whether a newer version exists before designing.

WhatsApp