Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Protection, control and communications

Fuse or Recloser at a Customer's Medium-Voltage Tap

How a load-current threshold decides between fused cutouts and a recloser at a customer's medium-voltage tap, and who supplies the recloser settings.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

Short answer

Some utilities decide the protection of a customer's overhead medium-voltage tap by load current: fused cutouts up to a threshold, and above it fused disconnect switches or a recloser with fault indicators. The utility then supplies the recloser settings, and only one switching device is allowed at the connection point.

Short answer

A utility can decide the protection of a customer’s overhead tap by a load-current threshold: fused cutouts below it, and above it fused disconnect switches or a recloser with fault indicators on each phase. The recloser is then not an open choice: the utility specifies it in the basic design data and supplies the setting conditions, so the customer’s internal protection is coordinated against them. A rule of one switching device per connection point keeps the arrangement simple.

Margins and curves are covered in recloser-fuse and recloser-relay coordination.

Which protection at the tap?
  • Does the load current exceed the utility's threshold?
    • No: Fused cutouts
    • Yes: What do the basic design data specify?
      • Fused disconnect switches: Install as specified
      • Recloser with fault indicators on each phase: Request the setting conditions

Threshold in kVA

A current threshold converts to apparent power with S = 1.732 × V × I. For an assumed threshold of 200 A:

VoltageEquivalent power
13.2 kVAbout 4.6 MVA
34.5 kVAbout 12 MVA

Order of design work

  1. Obtain the utility’s setting conditions and the fault level at the tap.
  2. Calculate the plant’s internal protection against those values.
  3. Plot the curves together and check the margins.
  4. Close the single-line diagram so the protections in it equal the study.

Example (assumptions)

A plant of 6 MVA at 13.2 kV draws about 262 A, above a 200 A threshold. If the basic design data specify a recloser, the plant waits for the utility’s setting conditions before fixing its own main protection.

Design checklist

  • Load current calculated and compared with the threshold.
  • Protection specified by the utility confirmed in writing.
  • Setting conditions and fault level obtained.
  • One switching device at the connection point.
  • Curves overlaid and margins checked.
  • Recloser grounding done per the manufacturer’s manual.

We provide the design engineering and the remote configuration of the recloser control, from the coordination study to the settings file and the test plan: contact us with your network data and we will propose a scope. See remote relay configuration.

References

  • IEC 62271-111:2019 / IEEE C37.60-2018, automatic circuit reclosers for alternating current systems up to 38 kV.

Frequently asked questions

What decides between a fuse and a recloser at a customer tap?

In a threshold-based rule, the load current. Below the threshold, fused cutouts; above it, fused disconnect switches or a recloser with fault indicators on each phase, as the utility's basic design data specifies.

Who provides the recloser settings?

Where the utility requires a recloser on its network, it usually supplies the setting conditions so that designer and contractor can coordinate the customer's protection with them.

Can two switching devices be placed at the same connection point?

A single-device rule avoids it: one protection or switching element per connection point, sized to the project's power, instead of stacking a disconnect switch and a recloser.

WhatsApp