Many utilities step the protection at a customer's connection point by installed capacity: a plain cutout for small loads, a cutout with an arc-extinguishing chamber for medium loads, and a device chosen by a coordination study above a set limit. The design adds up every transformer and shows why the chosen device is enough.
Short answer
The protection at a customer’s connection point is often chosen by installed capacity, adding up every transformer. A common scheme has three bands: a plain cutout for the smallest loads, a cutout with an arc-extinguishing chamber for medium loads, and, above a limit set by the utility, a device defined by a coordination study. The recloser belongs to that last band, together with the breaker and relay option.
The coordination study is described in what a coordination study needs; recloser settings, in recloser settings.
The three bands
| Installed capacity | Protection logic |
|---|---|
| Small | Cutout, with surge arresters |
| Medium | Cutout with an arc-extinguishing chamber, with surge arresters |
| Above the utility limit | Device defined by the coordination study |
The limits are set by the utility; the example below uses assumed values of 75 kVA and 500 kVA.
In the upper band the study must show:
- Selectivity with the upstream device, at the fault current of the point.
- The device chosen, with its settings.
- If a breaker is used, the justification of the burden and accuracy of the current and voltage transformers and of the secondary wiring.
- Is the installed capacity above 500 kVA?
- No: Is it above 75 kVA?
- No: Cutout and surge arresters
- Yes: Cutout with arc-extinguishing chamber and surge arresters
- Yes: Coordination study that defines the device
- Recloser: control settings coordinated with the upstream device
- Breaker: secondary relays, with the transformer burden justified
- No: Is it above 75 kVA?
What the design also covers
- Arresters next to the high-voltage bushings of the transformer, bonded to its ground.
- Overcurrent protection in every substation; if fuses are used, their maximum size comes from the study.
- Large transformers: above a few MVA, protection against internal arc pressure waves is considered.
- Bypass of a recloser: a design decision, made with the utility.
Example with numbers (assumptions)
A plant at 13.2 kV with transformers of 400 kVA and 300 kVA.
- Installed capacity: 400 + 300 = 700 kVA, above the assumed 500 kVA limit: a study is needed.
- Load current: I = 700 ÷ (1.732 × 13.2) = 700 ÷ 22.86 = 30.6 A.
- If the study picks a recloser: the settings are defined against the upstream device.
- With a single 400 kVA transformer: the connection would sit in the middle band.
The fault current at the point comes from the utility.
Design checklist
- Installed capacity added up, with expansions.
- Band identified against the utility’s limits.
- Coordination study if above the limit.
- Device chosen, with settings.
- Arresters next to the transformer bushings.
- Bypass decision recorded.
We design the protection coordination for the recloser your project requires and configure its control remotely, whatever its make. See remote relay configuration.
Related guides
References
- IEC 62271-111:2019 / IEEE C37.60-2018, automatic circuit reclosers for alternating current systems up to 38 kV.
- IEEE C57.12.00-2021, general requirements for liquid-immersed distribution, power and regulating transformers.
Frequently asked questions
What counts as installed capacity for choosing the protection?
The sum of all the transformers the customer owns, including those to be added in an expansion. A second transformer can move the connection to the next protection band.
Why does a coordination study decide the device above a set limit?
Because above that load the choices (recloser, breaker with relay, fuses) depend on the fault level, the upstream devices and the selectivity needed. The study shows which one coordinates.
What does a breaker with secondary relays need in the design?
A justification of the burden and accuracy of the current and voltage transformers that feed the protection, and of the secondary wiring and the ratio chosen.