Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

Net Metering Engineering: Export Limits and Protection

Net metering and net billing engineering for solar: export limits, metering, curtailment and protection, with a worked export limit example for a US site.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

PV plant=~1000 kWsite loadbreakerCTVTgridReverse / over-powerrelayExport controllerWhmetersetpointPowerMeasure / controlComms1000 kW plant, load 150 kW, limit 300 kW150 + 300 = 450 kW allowed at that moment(1000 - 450) / 1000 = 55 % curtailed300 kW = 13.9 A; 13.9 / 30 = 0.46 Aplant output, nameplateallowed: load 150 + export 300curtailed 550 kW450 kWexport limit 300 kW0.46 A on a 5 A input03004501000 kWillustrative valuesExport limitNet powerMeterExport controllerSetpointBackup trip© tizagrp.comPV plant=~1000 kWsite loadbreakerCTVTgridReverse / over-powerrelayExport controllerWhmetersetpointPowerMeasure / controlComms1000 kW plant, load 150 kW, limit 300 kW150 + 300 = 450 kW allowed at that moment(1000 - 450) / 1000 = 55 % curtailed300 kW = 13.9 A; 13.9 / 30 = 0.46 Aplant output, nameplateallowed: load 150 + export 300curtailed 550 kW450 kWexport limit 300 kW0.46 A on a 5 A input03004501000 kWillustrative valuesExport limitNet powerMeterExport controllerSetpointBackup trip© tizagrp.com
Export limitation at a net metering site: a PV inverter and the site load on the site bus, the breaker and the point of connection to the grid with a current and a voltage transformer feeding the bidirectional meter, an export controller that sends a yellow dashed setpoint to the inverter and a reverse or over power relay that trips the breaker, with the worked example of a 1000 kilowatt plant, 150 kilowatts of minimum load and a 300 kilowatt limit giving 450 kilowatts allowed, 55 percent curtailed and 0.46 amperes on a 150 to 5 current transformer. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Whether a site is under net metering or net billing, the interconnection engineering asks the same questions: how much power can flow back to the grid, how the meter registers it, how export is limited and what protection watches it. The billing rule changes how the owner sizes and operates the plant, and the interconnection study looks at the physical export.

A solar plant on a customer’s site exports when its output is higher than the site’s load. How that export is counted and paid is a matter for tariffs. How much can flow, how it is measured and what protects against too much of it are engineering matters, under either net metering or net billing.

For the process and the documents around it, see the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide and the distribution interconnection process.

Short answer

Net metering and net billing both depend on a meter that registers energy in both directions. For the engineer the difference lies in how much export the owner wants to design for, because it changes the plant size, the use of storage and the controls. The interconnection study then checks the export that the design can produce. The tools to limit it are an export-limiting control, a power control system under NEC 705.13, a reverse or over power relay, and the inverter’s own settings. The utility states what it accepts. The engineer sets the limit, shows how it is enforced and documents the protection.

What the engineering questions are

  • Maximum export. The difference between plant output and site load at the worst moment, which is usually low load with high sun.
  • Metering. A bidirectional meter at the point of connection. The utility specifies the meter, the location of its transformers and any additional meter for the generation. The instrument transformers must meet the metering class the utility requires.
  • Limiting method. Control that curtails the inverter to keep the net flow under a set value, or protection that trips on excess export, or both.
  • Failure behaviour. What happens when the meter or the communication with the controller fails: usually the plant goes to a safe output or zero.
  • Protection. Interface protection continues to apply with a limited export, as covered in PCC relay settings for DER.
  • Island risk. Lower export reduces the chance of a balanced island but does not remove it. See unintentional islanding.

How export limits are applied

An export limit is applied in the controller that reads net power at the point of connection and reduces inverter output when export rises over the limit. The limit holds only if the controller works within a time the utility accepts, and the code treats such systems in NEC 705.13 power control systems. A backup relay that trips the plant on sustained excess export covers a controller failure. The same idea in the UK is explained in ENA G100 export limitation schemes.

Worked example: limit, curtailment and relay setting (illustrative)

Assumptions, all illustrative: a 1000 kW AC plant at a 12.47 kV site. The site’s minimum load during daylight is 150 kW. The utility accepts an export of up to 300 kW. The current transformers are 150:5 (30:1).

  1. Maximum plant output allowed at minimum load = load + export limit = 150 + 300 = 450 kW.
  2. Curtailment needed at that moment = (1000 − 450) / 1000 = 0.55, or 55 % of the nameplate. At higher load the curtailment is smaller.
  3. Export current at the limit = 300 kW / (√3 × 12.47 kV) = 13.9 A primary, assuming unity power factor.
  4. Secondary current = 13.9 / 30 = 0.46 A. That is small for a 5 A relay input, so the relay used must have enough resolution at that level, or a CT with a lower ratio is considered.

The example shows two points: the limit sets how much the plant is curtailed at light load, and the relay must be able to measure the small currents involved. A protection setting is then placed slightly above 300 kW with a delay that rides through the controller’s response.

Common mistakes

The usual errors are sizing the limit on average load instead of the minimum load and placing the meter or its transformers where the utility does not accept them. Others are relying on a controller with no backup trip, and assuming that a limited export removes the islanding review. Each can be avoided by writing the limit, the method and the failure behaviour in one short description that goes with the single-line.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Get the utility’s export limit or the rule that sets it, and its metering requirements.
  • Calculate load and plant output at the worst moment and the resulting curtailment.
  • Choose the limiting method and show how it is enforced.
  • Define the safe state on failure of the meter, the controller or the link.
  • Check the CT ratio and relay resolution for the export current.
  • Confirm that the interface protection stays active with limited export.
  • Document the method and test plan for the utility’s review.

Who signs and seals

Interconnection designs and protection for a US project are normally reviewed and stamped by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Tiza delivers engineering and studies ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify work in the United States.

How Tiza can help

If you need the export control and its protection designed and documented for the utility, Tiza delivers engineering design remotely, in English, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the utility’s requirements and the load data.

References

  • NEC Article 705 and Section 705.13, power control systems. Adoption and edition vary by state.
  • IEEE 1547-2018 and amendment 1547a-2020.
  • The utility’s interconnection procedures and metering requirements.

Figure: single-line of a site with plant, load and the utility meter at the point of connection, the export controller, the reverse-power relay and the control link as a dashed line.

Frequently asked questions

Does the billing rule change the interconnection study?

The study looks at physical effects: export, voltage, fault current and protection. The billing rule affects how much export the owner wants, and so the size and the controls chosen. The study then tests that design. The utility's current tariff and procedures state the details.

How is export limited?

By a control that keeps the net power at the point of connection under a set value, as covered by NEC 705.13 power control systems, or by a relay that trips the plant for sustained export above the limit. The utility states which methods it accepts.

Does a zero-export design avoid the study?

Not by itself. The utility may still review islanding, fault contribution and protection. Many utilities streamline review for limited or non-exporting systems, but each states its own conditions.

WhatsApp