ENA Engineering Recommendation G99 replaced G59 for new generation connections in Great Britain (GB) from 27 April 2019. The interface protection that separates a generator from the network when the network is lost is still there, now set out by generator type. Neutral voltage displacement (NVD) is one of its functions: it detects earth faults on the network side that a generator with an unearthed winding might otherwise keep energised.
Short answer: G59 was replaced by G99
G59 was replaced by ENA Engineering Recommendation G99. G99 came into effect on 27 April 2019 and applies to new generation connections that need an application to the network operator. The job that G59 did for interface protection continues: when the network supply is lost or goes out of limits, the generator must disconnect from the network. G99 now describes that duty by generator type, from Type A to Type D, and adds the dynamic requirements of the European network codes for larger plants.
Neutral voltage displacement (NVD) is one of the functions a network operator can add to it. The wider rules are in the UK electrical codes and grid connection guide.
What interface protection does
The interface between a generating site and the network is a circuit breaker or contactor that the protection can open. Interface protection watches the network side and opens that device when the network is no longer in a healthy state. There are three reasons.
- A generator that keeps feeding a dead part of the network is dangerous to people working on it, because they expect the line to be dead.
- If the network reconnects while the generator is out of phase, the closing can damage equipment.
- A generator that carries on during a fault can keep an earth fault alive.
The G99 functions are under-voltage, over-voltage, under-frequency, over-frequency and loss of mains (LoM). For LoM, G99 uses rate of change of frequency (ROCOF) at 1 Hz/s with a 500 ms delay. Vector shift is not acceptable as LoM protection (clause 10.4.11). The guide on ROCOF 81R protection shows how that function works. NVD is an extra function that the DNO can require after its connection study (clause 10.5). It looks for the earth fault itself.
What changed from G59 to G99
Three changes matter to a designer:
- The document is organised by generator type. G99 sorts each power generating module into Type A, B, C or D by registered capacity and connection voltage, and the requirements grow with the type.
- Larger plants carry more than protection. For modules of 1 MW and above, G99 adds frequency response, fault ride through and reactive power capability, and it changes the application and commissioning steps. See which rules apply to a project.
- Settings come from the network operator. The values are set out in G99 and confirmed by the operator for the actual site. A relay left at factory defaults, or at old G59 settings, is not enough evidence.
Equipment that was approved only to G59 can no longer be connected as new from the date G99 took effect. Small generation up to 16 A per phase follows a different document, covered in the G98 guide.
Where NVD is used
NVD protection measures the residual voltage. On a healthy three-phase system the three phase voltages add up to almost zero. An earth fault on the network side moves the neutral point and the sum rises. The measurement comes from a voltage transformer (VT) with an earthed-star primary and a broken-delta (open-delta) winding. A relay can also calculate the residual from three phase voltages of an earthed-star VT.
NVD matters when the generator side has no earth path that would show the fault. A typical case is a transformer whose network-side winding is a delta or an unearthed star. After the network breaker at the far end opens on an earth fault, the generator can keep the island alive. The fault then stays energised. NVD sees the residual voltage and trips the interface breaker. Whether a site needs NVD, and with which setting and delay, is stated in the DNO’s connection offer, since it depends on how the DNO earths its network.
Worked example: an NVD setting
All values are illustrative.
Data. An 11 kV connection. The voltage transformer has an earthed-star primary, a star secondary rated 110/√3 V and a broken-delta winding rated 110/3 V per winding.
Step 1. Phase voltage on the primary side. 11,000 V ÷ √3 = 6,351 V.
Step 2. Residual voltage with the neutral fully displaced. In a solid earth fault on an unearthed network side, the two healthy phases rise by √3. The broken-delta output is then 3 × (110/3) = 110 V.
Step 3. Choose a setting. Assume the DNO asks for a pick-up at 10 % of the full-fault residual voltage. Setting = 0.10 × 110 V = 11 V.
Step 4. What the setting means on the primary side. 11 V is 10 % of the 110 V full-fault value, so it corresponds to a neutral displacement of 10 % × 6,351 V = 635 V on the 11 kV system. A fault with some resistance still trips the relay as long as it moves the neutral by 635 V or more.
Step 5. Check against healthy-system unbalance. Suppose the residual voltage measured on the healthy system is 2 V. The setting of 11 V is 5.5 times that value, which leaves room for normal unbalance without nuisance trips. If the measured value were 8 V, the margin would be too thin and the setting would be discussed with the operator.
The figures are an example of the method, not a setting to copy. The pick-up and the time delay of a real site come from the connection offer.
Checklist for the engineer
- State which document the connection falls under (G98 or G99) and the issue the DNO applies.
- List the interface protection functions that the connection offer asks for, with settings and time delays.
- Confirm where the interface breaker is and which protection trips it, including its auxiliary supply.
- Decide whether NVD is required and check the voltage transformer winding that feeds it.
- Measure the residual voltage under normal conditions before fixing the pick-up.
- Keep the setting file and the commissioning test results together for the DNO.
- Check that no old G59 setting sheet is still in the relay.
- Test the trip path from the relay to the breaker, not only the relay.
Related guides
The principles of the function are explained in interconnection relays. For the inverter standards behind type-tested equipment, see PV inverter standards. Export limits at the same connection are in the G100 guide.
From the rules to a settings plan your chartered engineer can review
An interface protection plan is only accepted when the settings, the single-line diagram and the test plan agree with the connection offer. We provide remote relay configuration, with the settings plan behind it, ready for your chartered engineer to review and sign before it goes to the network operator. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify designs in the UK. Contact us with the relay model and the DNO’s requirements.
Frequently asked questions
Was G59 replaced by G99?
Yes. ENA Engineering Recommendation G99 replaced G59 for new generation connections, and it came into effect on 27 April 2019. A generator connected under G59 keeps its original approval, but a new application, or a change to an existing installation, is assessed against G99.
What does NVD protection detect?
Neutral voltage displacement detects an earth fault on the network side by measuring the residual voltage, which is the sum of the three phase voltages. On a healthy system this sum is close to zero. During an earth fault it rises, and the relay trips the interface circuit breaker.
Who decides the interface protection settings?
The distribution network operator (DNO) states the required functions and settings in the connection offer, based on G99 and on the local network. The designer takes them from the offer and proves them at commissioning.