Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Testing, commissioning and faults

Substation SAT Protocol: Levels 0, 1 and 2 and SCADA

How to organize a substation site test by levels, from the yard to the SCADA, with its signal list and the end-to-end time.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

SCADA525252Level 2Level 1Level 0each signal is traced from the yard to the screenLevel 0: yard and wiring144 signals from 6 bays (6 × 24)Level 1: baysinterlocking and trips between baysLevel 2: station174 signals (144 + 30 from the station)SCADA174 signals seen on the screenyard-to-screen time (120 px per s)limit 2 s0.63 s0.02 + 0.01 + 0.20 + 0.30 + 0.10 = 0.63 s3 signals in error out of 174: 1.72 %ChainLevel 0Level 1Level 2SCADA© tizagrp.comSCADA525252Level 2Level 1Level 0each signal is traced from the yard to the screenLevel 0: yard and wiring144 signals from 6 bays (6 × 24)Level 1: baysinterlocking and trips between baysLevel 2: station174 signals (144 + 30 from the station)SCADA174 signals seen on the screenyard-to-screen time (120 px per s)limit 2 s0.63 s0.02 + 0.01 + 0.20 + 0.30 + 0.10 = 0.63 s3 signals in error out of 174: 1.72 %ChainLevel 0Level 1Level 2SCADA© tizagrp.com
Site test by levels: yard signals, bays, station and SCADA, with end-to-end time against its limit. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

The SAT of a substation is organized by levels: first the yard toward each bay (level 0), then the bays among themselves (level 1), the station (level 2) and finally the integration to the SCADA. Each level is tested with the signal list in hand and the next one starts only when the previous one is closed; at the end the end-to-end time is measured, from the yard contact to the screen.

Short answer

The SAT (site acceptance test) of a substation is organized by levels. At level 0 the yard signals are checked up to each bay’s IED. At level 1 the bays are tested: logic, interlocks and messages among them. At level 2 the station is tested: HMI, gateway and network. Then it is integrated to the SCADA, with every point of the list seen on screen and the end-to-end time measured. The next level starts only when the previous one is closed. For what is tested at the factory beforehand, see the FAT guides and the standards for commissioning.

Why by levels

IEC 61850-4 defines the site acceptance test. The process, bay and station levels are those of IEC 61850; the 0, 1 and 2 numbering is the usual one in industry:

LevelWhat it isWhat is checked
0Yard and field wiringPositions, measurements and commands between the primary equipment and the IED
1BaysEach bay’s logic, interlocks, trips and messages between bays
2StationHMI, gateway, clock and station network
SCADAControl centerPoint list, names, states, commands and time

The reason is practical: locating faults. If a state does not appear in the SCADA, the level where the test fails says where the error is. If everything is tested together, the symptom is the same for four different causes. For how missing signals are diagnosed, there is a case in signals that do not reach the SCADA.

Level 0: from the yard to the bay

Here the wiring between the primary equipment and each bay’s IED is verified. The state of each signal is changed at the equipment, or simulated at the terminal if the equipment cannot be moved, and it is checked that the IED records it with the right state. With commands it works the other way around: the IED sends the order and it is verified that the equipment moves and that the feedback positions change. Nothing is energized that the substation’s procedure does not allow.

Level 1: the bays

With the wiring closed, what the IED does with the signals is tested. Bay logic, interlocks, trips and messages between bays, where GOOSE is used, are verified. Protection functions are set from the study and tested by injection. This level is where you confirm that a rejected command is rejected for a design reason and not because of a configuration error.

Level 2: the station

The common equipment is tested here: the HMI with its screens and alarms, the gateway with its point list toward the control center, the clock with its synchronization and the network with its redundancy. Verify that every data point from every IED reaches the HMI and the gateway, with its name and state. A network cable is cut and it is checked that service is not lost. There is a specific guide on tests of the substation communications network.

SCADA: integration

With the station ready, the link to the control center is tested. For each point of the list, the control center must see the agreed name, type, state and data quality. Each command is tested from the center, with the bay in the mode that allows it. The timestamps are checked, because a record with a wrong time is useless for analyzing an event. For the plant side, see integrating the substation into the plant SCADA and command rejected from the SCADA.

End-to-end time

Besides the signal arriving, how long it takes is measured. A real change of state is provoked in the yard and timed until the screen shows it. The total is broken into its parts: bay, station network, gateway, link and SCADA. If the total exceeds the agreed limit, the breakdown says which part to fix.

Worked example

Example data (assumed): a substation with 6 bays, 24 signals per bay (states, alarms and measurements) and 30 signals of the station itself (clock, auxiliary supply, network state). Times measured with a real change of state: bay 0.02 s, station network 0.01 s, gateway 0.20 s, link to the center 0.30 s, SCADA 0.10 s. Limit agreed in the example: 2 s. Test result: 3 signals with errors.

  1. Level 0: 6 × 24 = 144 field signals to test.
  2. Level 2 and SCADA: 144 + 30 = 174 signals the SCADA must show.
  3. Total time: 0.02 + 0.01 + 0.20 + 0.30 + 0.10 = 0.63 s. That is less than 2 s: it passes, with 1.37 s of margin (2 − 0.63).
  4. Largest part: the link at 0.30 s is 0.30 / 0.63 = 48 % of the total. If the time were over the limit, that is where to look first.
  5. Signals with errors: 3 of 174 = 0.0172, that is 1.72 %. To accept, each one is corrected and the test of that point and of its level is repeated.

The 1.72 % figure is not an acceptance criterion: the normal criterion is that all points end up correct and signed. It serves to see how much is being corrected and at which level.

Common mistakes

  • Jumping to the SCADA without closing the bay: the symptom shows on screen but the cause is in the wiring.
  • Testing with the signal list of an older drawing: what is checked no longer exists.
  • Accepting a signal because it changes on screen, without looking at its name, quality and time.
  • Not repeating the affected level after correcting a point: the correction may move other signals.
  • Measuring time with a change simulated in the SCADA and not with a real change in the yard.

What to hand over at closing

A closed SAT leaves a signed record per level: the signal list with the result of each point, the nonconformities with their closing, the measured time and the version of the configuration files used. With that, whoever operates the substation can reproduce the test and whoever audits can follow it. The commissioning dossier gathers those records.

Checklist

  • Signal list approved, with one column per level.
  • Level 0: every yard signal reaches the IED with the right state.
  • Level 0: every command moves the equipment and the positions return.
  • Level 1: logic and interlocks of each bay tested.
  • Level 1: messages between bays verified.
  • Level 2: HMI, gateway, clock and network tested, including the failure of one network.
  • SCADA: all points with correct name, type, state and quality.
  • Commands from the control center tested.
  • End-to-end time measured and compared with the agreed limit.
  • Signed record with the versions of the configuration files.

References

  • IEC 61850-4, Communication networks and systems for power utility automation, Part 4: System and project management.
  • Calculations and data: our own, with assumed data for the example.

Need this study?

We design the SAT protocol, the signal list per level and the acceptance criteria as part of our studies for commissioning, for projects in any country. Write to us.

Frequently asked questions

Why test by levels and not everything at once?

Because when a signal does not reach the SCADA, the level where it fails points to the cause: yard wiring, bay configuration, the station network or the link to the control center. Testing from the bottom up, each error is found where it starts and not three levels higher.

What does IEC 61850-4 say about the SAT?

IEC 61850-4 defines the site acceptance test. The process, bay and station levels are those of IEC 61850; the 0, 1 and 2 numbering is the usual one in industry.

What time is accepted between the yard and the SCADA?

There is no single value: the contract or the control center operator sets it. As an example, 2 s. What matters is to measure the end-to-end time with a real change of state and compare it with the agreed value.

WhatsApp