The test matrix crosses the equipment of a substation with the phases in which it is tested: factory acceptance tests (FAT), cold tests on site, functional tests on site and energization. Each marked cell is a test with its record and its owner. With the matrix the work is counted, testing the same thing twice is avoided and equipment left without a test is found.
Short answer
The test matrix is a table that crosses equipment (rows) with phases (columns): factory acceptance tests (FAT), cold tests on site, functional tests on site and energization. Each marked cell is a test, with its record and its owner. With the matrix the work is counted, testing the same thing twice is avoided and equipment left without a test is found before energizing. For the timing plan that goes with the matrix, see what a substation commissioning includes and the commissioning standards, FAT and SAT.
The four phases of the matrix
FAT (factory acceptance tests). They are run at the equipment’s factory, with its manufacturer, before shipment. They check that the equipment meets its specification and are left in a signed record. An example is the factory tests of transformers.
Cold SAT. These are the tests on site with the substation de-energized. They check that the equipment arrived undamaged, is properly installed and that its characteristics are still those of the factory record. This is the time for tests on primary equipment and for the wiring review.
Functional SAT. These are the on-site tests of whatever depends on other equipment: that the relay receives the current from the transformer, that it trips the right breaker, that each signal reaches the control system. See point-to-point signal tests and protection tests with GOOSE.
Energization. These are the checks during and after applying voltage: the switching, the behavior under voltage and the tests under load. See what is checked before energizing.
How it is built
- List the equipment of the substation by name. Group those that receive the same test: for example, «MV breakers» as one row if they are identical and tested the same way, even though each unit has its own record.
- Define the tests per equipment and per phase from the standards for each piece of equipment, the contract specification and the manufacturer’s records.
- Mark each cell with the test that applies or with «not applicable» and the reason.
- Assign an owner and a record to each marked cell: who runs it, who witnesses it and in what format it is recorded.
- Count. The total of marked cells is the volume of tests, and the effort is estimated per phase.
- Review gaps. A piece of equipment with no marked cell in SAT, or with none in energization, must have a written reason.
The criterion of each test, with its acceptance values, is in the standard for each piece of equipment. The matrix only organizes what is tested, when and by whom.
Worked example: 12 equipment items by 4 phases
Example data. A medium-voltage substation with one transformer. The mark ● means the test applies and – that it does not. The effort per cell is assumed for illustration: FAT 0.5 days per item (witnessing the record), cold SAT 1 day, functional SAT 1.5 days, energization 0.5 days.
| Equipment | FAT | Cold SAT | Functional SAT | Energization |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Power transformer | ● | ● | ● | ● |
| 2. MV breaker | ● | ● | ● | ● |
| 3. Disconnector | ● | ● | ● | – |
| 4. Current transformer | ● | ● | ● | ● |
| 5. Voltage transformer | ● | ● | ● | ● |
| 6. Surge arrester | ● | ● | – | – |
| 7. Protection relay | ● | ● | ● | ● |
| 8. Control panel | ● | ● | ● | – |
| 9. Charger and batteries | ● | ● | ● | – |
| 10. MV cable | – | ● | – | ● |
| 11. MV switchgear panel | ● | ● | ● | ● |
| 12. Grounding | – | ● | – | – |
Step 1. Possible total. 12 items × 4 phases = 48 cells.
Step 2. Marked cells per phase. FAT: 10 (the cable and the grounding do not apply). Cold SAT: 12. Functional SAT: 9 (the arrester, the cable and the grounding do not apply). Energization: 7 (transformer, breaker, current and voltage transformers, relay, cable and panel; for the instrument transformers, the phasing and sequence of the VTs and the on-load test of the CTs, with directionality and differential, are checked).
Step 3. Total tests. 10 + 12 + 9 + 7 = 38 of 48 cells, that is 38 / 48 = 79 %.
Step 4. Effort per phase. FAT: 10 × 0.5 = 5 days. Cold SAT: 12 × 1 = 12 days. Functional SAT: 9 × 1.5 = 13.5 days. Energization: 7 × 0.5 = 3.5 days.
Step 5. Total effort. 5 + 12 + 13.5 + 3.5 = 34 technician-days.
Reading. 79 % of the cells are marked: the matrix does not ask for everything to be tested, it asks for what applies to be tested. The heaviest load is in the SAT tests (12 + 13.5 = 25.5 days out of 34), so that is where the schedule is decided. And the cable and the grounding, which have no witnessed FAT, depend entirely on SAT: if the cable’s factory record is not required, the first time it is tested is on site.
What to review in the matrix before approving it
- Equipment without an owner. Every marked cell has someone who runs it and someone who approves it.
- Tests without a standard or specification. If the acceptance criterion is unknown, the test can be neither approved nor rejected.
- Dependencies between cells. The functional test of a relay requires first the test of the current transformer that feeds it. The matrix must let that order be read.
- Equipment added later. A new item in the design forces its row to be added. The matrix is kept alive until handover.
Checklist
- All the equipment on the one-line diagram is in a row of the matrix.
- The four phases are columns.
- Each cell says «test» or «not applicable», with a reason in the second case.
- Each test has a record and an owner.
- Each test has its acceptance criterion identified.
- The total of marked cells is counted and the effort estimated per phase.
- The dependencies between tests are noted.
- The matrix is in the commissioning dossier.
Related guides
- What a substation commissioning includes
- Commissioning standards: FAT and SAT
- Tests on substation primary equipment
- Point-to-point signal tests: SAS and SCADA
- Factory tests of transformers
- Commissioning dossier: records, reports and as-built
When to call us
Do you need this matrix? We build it with you from engineering design and studies, starting from your one-line diagram and your specification, for substations in any country. Contact us.
References
- Acceptance criteria: the standard for each piece of equipment and the contract specification; see commissioning standards: FAT and SAT.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between FAT and SAT?
FAT is factory acceptance testing, before the equipment ships. SAT is site acceptance testing, with the equipment already installed. Factory tests check that the equipment meets its specification. Site tests check that it arrived well, is properly installed and works with the rest of the substation.
Must everything tested at the factory be repeated on site?
No. On site you repeat what transport and assembly can alter and what can only be tested with the equipment connected to the rest. The matrix helps decide what is repeated, what is accepted on the factory record and who decides.
Is an empty cell a mistake?
Not necessarily. An empty cell may be a test that does not apply to that equipment in that phase, such as energization of a no-load disconnector. What is a mistake is an empty cell nobody decided on: the matrix should show «not applicable» with a reason, or a test with an owner.