In a conventional substation every copper wire between the yard equipment and the relay is tested. In a digital one those wires are replaced by fiber and IEC 61850 messages: there is less wiring to test, but new tests appear for configuration, time synchronization and messages. A worked example with assumed figures, for the signal testing only, goes from 9 h per bay to 4.3 h, and from 108 h to 51.6 h over 12 bays; the new tests come on top of that.
Short answer
In a conventional substation, commissioning tests wire by wire the copper that runs from the yard to the relay and from the relay to the breaker. In a digital substation, much of that copper is replaced by optical fiber and network messages. Wiring tests shrink, but tests that did not exist before appear: configuration, time synchronization, messages between devices, and the reaction when the network fails. Tests of the primary equipment (breakers, transformers, instrument transformers) stay the same, except where low-power instrument transformers are used, whose ratio is verified in a different way.
Where the copper was and where it remains
In the conventional bay, every signal has its own pair of wires: currents and voltages from the instrument transformer to the relay, breaker and disconnector status to the relay, the relay trip to the coil, interlocks between bays. The test checks each wire: that it lands on the right terminal and that the relay sees it.
In the digital bay, the process bus replaces part of this. A merging unit digitizes currents and voltages near the yard and sends them over fiber as sampled values; a breaker interface unit receives the trip as a message. The station bus carries the other exchanges between devices as GOOSE messages. The copper does not vanish entirely: it remains between the primary equipment and the merging unit or interface unit, and in any signals the design keeps hardwired.
What changes in each test
- Current and voltage wiring. Conventional: inject and measure at the relay. Digital: check the short copper run to the merging unit (polarity and ratio), then verify that the sampled values reach the relay with the right scale, direction and phase.
- Status and trip signals. Conventional: point-to-point test with a contact simulator. Digital: simulate the message and observe the reaction; also measure how long the message takes to arrive.
- Interlocks between bays. Before, wires between panels. Now, GOOSE messages: test that the message is published, that the relay subscribes to it and that, if it stops arriving, the interlock falls to the safe state defined.
- Configuration. Before, hardly a test at all. Now the SCL files (describing the system and each device) are part of the design and the deliverables; what is loaded in each device is checked against the approved file. See how to verify the settings loaded in relays.
- Time. Sampled values depend on a common time reference. Test that each device is synchronized and how it behaves if the reference is lost.
- Network. Tests of the communications network appear: redundant paths, switchover when a link drops, and traffic load.
New tests a conventional substation does not have
- Configuration conformity. Each device publishes and subscribes exactly what the design file says.
- Message simulation. Publish test messages carrying the simulation flag, which the relay accepts only if its simulation mode is enabled; so that it does not act on the yard, the relay is put in test mode with outputs blocked. This is the great advantage of the method: whole logic schemes are tested without touching primary equipment.
- Signal quality. Review the quality information a message carries, and check that the relay handles bad quality correctly.
- Communication failure. Pull a fiber, switch off a merging unit, lose synchronization: each function must go to the safe state and raise an alarm.
- End-to-end test. Once per function, the full chain with real signals: from the instrument transformer to the breaker trip. This is the test that settles whether scale and polarity are right from the source.
The test equipment for this environment injects or simulates the messages and records them. The guide on MMS messages covers the other channel of the standard.
Worked example: test hours for one bay
Assumptions. A line bay with 36 copper points in the conventional version. Average test time per point is 15 minutes. In the digital version, 8 of those points stay in copper (between the primary equipment and the merging unit or interface unit) the 36 signal exchanges become messages; in addition, 8 copper runs remain between the primary equipment and the merging unit or interface unit, at 3 minutes each by simulation. Another 0.5 h covers verifying the merging unit’s sampled values. These figures illustrate the method; they are not reference times.
- Conventional: 36 × 15 min = 540 min = 9.0 h per bay.
- Digital, messages: 36 × 3 min = 108 min = 1.8 h.
- Digital, remaining copper: 8 × 15 min = 120 min = 2.0 h.
- Digital, sampled values: 0.5 h.
- Digital, total: 1.8 + 2.0 + 0.5 = 4.3 h per bay.
- A 12-bay substation: conventional 12 × 9.0 = 108 h; digital 12 × 4.3 = 51.6 h.
- Difference: 108 − 51.6 = 56.4 h, that is, 56.4 / 108 = 52.2 % fewer signal-test hours.
This saving covers signals only. Configuration verification, synchronization, communication-failure tests and the end-to-end test of each function sit outside it, and a conventional substation has none of them. A correct schedule adds them before comparing the two options.
What does not change
With or without a digital substation, primary equipment is tested the same way: transformation ratio, contact resistance, breaker timing, insulation and earthing. Nor does the need change to verify the settings of each function against the coordination study, or to leave evidence: signed protocols, records and a complete dossier. Digitalization moves the test from the cable to the configuration and the network, but it does not remove the duty to show that each function acts at the right time and under the right condition.
How the test is ordered in a digital substation
The practical order is bottom-up. First, the primary equipment and the short copper run to the merging unit and the interface unit. Second, the network: links, time synchronization and redundancy, because everything else depends on it. Third, the configuration of each device against the approved file. Fourth, the functions: sampled values at each relay, trip messages and interlocks. Fifth, the end-to-end test with real signals and the communication-failure tests. Changing this order forces repetition, because a network or configuration error found at the end contaminates everything tested before.
Common mistakes
- Treating the relay as tested because message simulation worked, with no end-to-end test using real signals.
- Loading a configuration file that is not the latest approved one.
- Testing only with a healthy network and never with a failed link.
- Not recording the SCL file version in the test report.
- Forgetting the test flag and leaving simulated messages active at energization.
- Assuming the fiber is “already tested” because the manufacturer delivered factory-tested equipment.
Checklist
- Approved configuration file version and the one loaded in each device match.
- Polarity and ratio of the copper between primary equipment and merging unit verified.
- Sampled values with correct scale, direction and phase at each relay.
- Status and trip messages simulated and reaction checked.
- Message-based interlocks fall to a safe behavior if the message is lost.
- Time synchronization verified and response to its loss tested.
- Network redundancy tested with one link down.
- One end-to-end test per function with real signals.
- Simulated messages disabled before energization.
- Protocols record the file version and the test equipment used.
Related guides
- Digital substation IEC 61850: process bus, GOOSE and SV
- Digital interface of switchgear (IEC 62271-3)
- IEC 61850 MMS: reports, SBO commands and files
- Commissioning dossier: protocols, reports and as-built
- What is checked before energizing a substation
References
- IEC 61850, communication networks and systems for power utility automation (part 6, configuration description language; part 8-1, GOOSE messages; part 9-2, sampled values; part 10, conformance testing).
Need these tests?
We define the test scope, protocols and acceptance criteria for digital substations, and the verification of their configuration, as part of our engineering design and studies service, for projects in any country. Contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Does a digital substation need fewer tests than a conventional one?
It needs fewer copper-wiring tests, but not fewer tests overall. The nature of the work changes: configuration files, GOOSE messages, sampled values, time synchronization and behavior on loss of communication all have to be verified. Tests on the primary equipment do not change, except where low-power instrument transformers are used, whose ratio is verified in a different way.
Can a relay be tested without the real yard signals?
Yes. In a digital substation, status, trip or current and voltage messages can be simulated with a test set connected to the network, and the relay's reaction observed. That simulation replaces much of the wired injection, but the real chain, from the instrument transformer to the breaker, must still be proven at least once.
What is tested when communication fails?
Each function must move to a safe state and report it: block or trip as defined in the design, plus an alarm to the operator. Testing only normal operation leaves the most important part of a message-based network unverified.