Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Testing, commissioning and faults

Substation Commissioning Schedule: An 8-Week Example

How to build the schedule and resources of a substation commissioning: phases, crews and man-hours, with an 8-week worked example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

115 / 13.8 kV substationP1SCADAAdrawings and settingsBBCDEFA documents B primary C protectionD control E integrated F energizationweeks and man-hours per phase12345678A 80 hB 240 hC 240 hD 120 hE 120 hF 160 htotal: 960 h in 8 weekswith 15 % contingency: 1,104 hone week of waiting for 3 people: 120 henergization moves to week 9ChainDocumentsPrimary equipmentProtection and controlEnergization© tizagrp.com115 / 13.8 kV substationP1SCADAAdrawings and settingsBBCDEFA documents B primary C protectionD control E integrated F energizationweeks and man-hours per phase12345678A 80 hB 240 hC 240 hD 120 hE 120 hF 160 htotal: 960 h in 8 weekswith 15 % contingency: 1,104 hone week of waiting for 3 people: 120 henergization moves to week 9ChainDocumentsPrimary equipmentProtection and controlEnergization© tizagrp.com
Substation commissioning: where each of the six phases acts and the 8-week schedule with its man-hours. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

A commissioning schedule is built from phases in a fixed order (documents, primary equipment, protection, control, integrated tests, energization) and converted into man-hours by multiplying crew by weeks. A worked example with assumed figures adds up to 960 h over 8 weeks, 1,104 h with 15 % contingency, and shows that one week of the full crew waiting costs 120 h.

Short answer

The schedule of a commissioning is built in three steps: fix the phases in their logical order, give each one a crew and a number of weeks, and multiply by the weekly hours to get man-hours. That total is what gets priced and scheduled. In the worked example below, a substation with a crew of 2 to 4 people needs 8 weeks and 960 man-hours, which with an assumed 15 % contingency become 1,104.

The six phases and why they go in this order

  1. Documents and review. Drawings, signal lists, settings, factory protocols. If something is missing it shows up here and not in front of the breaker.
  2. Primary equipment. Breakers, disconnectors, instrument transformers, the power transformer. See what is checked before energizing.
  3. Protection. Current and voltage circuits, loaded and verified settings, functional and trip tests. The measuring circuits must be proven before this phase.
  4. Control and communications. Commands, status, alarms, the link to the control center. It depends on the protection already tripping and signaling correctly.
  5. Integrated tests. Complete substation sequences: interlocks, transfers, reclosing, with the real logic.
  6. Energization and close-out. Staged energization, measurements under load, open items and handover of the dossier. The grid-operator procedures are scheduled here; see energization with the grid operator.

The order avoids repeating tests: a protection tested before its measuring circuits are verified has to be tested again. The test matrix by equipment and phase helps make sure none is forgotten.

From phases to man-hours

For each phase three things are estimated: the number of points or devices to test, the time per unit and the crew available. Duration comes from dividing the work by the crew, and man-hours are the crew times the working hours of each week. Two practical rules:

  • A bigger crew does not shorten a phase that depends on a single test set or on one person holding the access credentials. Some tasks cannot be split.
  • Waiting counts. If the whole crew waits for equipment to arrive, or for the client to approve a setting, the hours are paid all the same.

Worked example: 8 weeks and 960 man-hours

Assumptions. A medium-sized medium- or high-voltage substation. A 40-hour week per person. The phases, with their crew and weeks, are:

PhaseCrewWeeksMan-hours
A. Documents and review21 (week 1)2 × 1 × 40 = 80
B. Primary equipment32 (weeks 2 and 3)3 × 2 × 40 = 240
C. Protection32 (weeks 4 and 5)3 × 2 × 40 = 240
D. Control and communications31 (week 6)3 × 1 × 40 = 120
E. Integrated tests31 (week 7)3 × 1 × 40 = 120
F. Energization and close-out41 (week 8)4 × 1 × 40 = 160
  1. Total duration: 1 + 2 + 2 + 1 + 1 + 1 = 8 weeks.
  2. Man-hours: 80 + 240 + 240 + 120 + 120 + 160 = 960 h.
  3. Assumed 15 % contingency: 960 × 0.15 = 144 h, for a total of 960 + 144 = 1,104 h.
  4. Cost in relative units: if H is the cost of one man-hour, the work is worth 960 H and, with contingency, 1,104 H.
  5. One week of the three-person crew waiting (for example, a setting the client approves late in phase C): 3 × 40 = 120 h, which is 12.5 % of the 960 h, with no test done. 120 / 960 = 0.125.
  6. Energization date: week 8 holds only if the earlier phases finish on time; with that wait, energization moves to week 9.

The practical conclusion is that cutting waiting time pays more than adding people: the best way to protect the schedule is to have drawings, approved settings and permits complete before starting.

How the crew is divided

A three-person crew performs better if each has a clear front: one on the test equipment and injection, another on wiring and circuit verification, and another on documentation, settings and recording results. In the energization phase a fourth person is added to coordinate with the grid operator and the control center. When a phase depends on a single test set, running two crews at once does not shorten it; what does help is bringing preparation work forward, such as loading and reviewing settings, while another phase finishes.

What the client must approve, and when

The schedule has decision points that do not depend on the crew: approval of the signal list and the settings (before phase C), authorization of energization (phase F) and acceptance of the open items. It is worth fixing in the schedule the deadline of each approval and what happens if it slips: how much waiting is tolerated before rescheduling. That way the wait stops being a surprise and becomes an agreed condition.

What usually stretches the schedule

  • Factory or site documents that are incomplete or do not match what was installed.
  • Wiring corrections found during protection testing.
  • Settings that change when the coordination study is updated halfway through testing.
  • Test equipment or accessories arriving late.
  • Grid-operator dates that do not match the finish of the phases.
  • A punch list left open.

Using it to price and to control

For pricing, the phase table is the base: each row is discussed with the client, who sees where every hour comes from. For control, hours spent are compared week by week with those planned per phase; a deviation in phase B warns that C will slip. The result of each phase is recorded in the dossier and the close-out includes a commissioning report.

Checklist

  • Phases in logical order, each with its crew and weeks.
  • Man-hours per phase and in total, with contingency shown separately.
  • Documentation and approved settings in hand before phase C.
  • Test equipment availability confirmed per phase.
  • Energization date agreed with the grid operator.
  • Possible waits identified and who resolves them.
  • Weekly review of hours spent against planned.
  • Punch list opened from phase A.
  • Dossier handover included in phase F.

References

  • The standards that govern each test are cited in the guides for each piece of equipment and function linked above.

Need these tests?

We prepare the commissioning schedule and resources, with phases, crews and hours per phase, as part of our engineering design and studies service, for projects in any country. Contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Why do commissioning phases follow a fixed order?

Because each phase depends on the one before: protection of a piece of equipment is not tested until its wiring and measuring circuits are verified, and integrated tests are not run with unverified protection. Changing the order forces tests to be repeated.

How much contingency should be allowed?

There is no single percentage. It depends on the quality of the documentation received, the number of open items and the availability of the grid operator for energization. The example assumes 15 %, and the real figure should come from experience with similar installations.

What makes a schedule run long?

Incomplete or outdated documentation, late equipment, wiring corrections, settings that change halfway through testing, and an energization that depends on a date set by the grid operator. Every wait of the crew is paid in hours, even when no test is carried out.

WhatsApp