Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Testing, commissioning and faults

Staged Energization of a Substation: the Sequence

The sequence to energize a substation one breaker at a time, with the condition checked at each step and a 115/13.8 kV example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

115 kV network52L115 kV busbarTP52T40 MVA115 / 13.8 kV52M13.8 kV busbar52Floadeach step closes a single breakerand measured before continuing1 115 kV busbar energized117.3 kV = 102 %; VT: 117.3 V phase to phase2 Transformer no-loadexample starting current: 8 × 200.8 = 1,606 A3 13.8 kV busbar14.08 kV at nominal tap4 First step: 20 % load8 MVA = 334.7 A at 13.8 kV5 Second step: 50 % load20 MVA = 836.7 A at 13.8 kVrated current on the 115 kV side: 200.8 AChainLine115 kV busbarTransformer13.8 kV busbar© tizagrp.com115 kV network52L115 kV busbarTP52T40 MVA115 / 13.8 kV52M13.8 kV busbar52Floadeach step closes a single breakerand measured before continuing1 115 kV busbar energized117.3 kV = 102 %; VT: 117.3 V phase to phase2 Transformer no-loadexample starting current: 8 × 200.8 = 1,606 A3 13.8 kV busbar14.08 kV at nominal tap4 First step: 20 % load8 MVA = 334.7 A at 13.8 kV5 Second step: 50 % load20 MVA = 836.7 A at 13.8 kVrated current on the 115 kV side: 200.8 AChainLine115 kV busbarTransformer13.8 kV busbar© tizagrp.com
Staged energization of a 115/13.8 kV substation: line, busbar, no-load transformer, medium-voltage busbar and load steps with their measurement. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Staged energization means closing one breaker at a time, from the source toward the load, and not closing the next until the previous step has produced what it should: voltage at the bus, phase sequence, transformer no-load current, voltage at the medium-voltage bus and current at each load step. Each step has its entry condition, its measurement and its criterion to continue or go back.

Short answer

Staged energization means closing one breaker at a time, from the source toward the load, and not closing the next one until the measurement of the previous step confirms what was expected. In a 115/13.8 kV substation there are five steps: the line and the 115 kV bus, the transformer at no load, the 13.8 kV bus, the first load step and the second. Each step has its entry condition, its measurement and its criterion to continue or go back. Here is the switching sequence; what is checked before switching is in what is checked before energizing a substation.

Why in stages

Closing everything at once mixes the problems: if something trips, nobody knows which part failed. By energizing one section at a time, each measurement belongs to a single element, and if there is a problem the last closed breaker is opened and the rest stays as it was. It is also a way to limit damage: a wiring or setting error is found with the least equipment energized.

The order follows the flow of energy: first the bus is energized from the grid, and a breaker closes before what is downstream receives voltage. It is assumed that the previous tests, the review and the grid operator’s authorization are already closed; for that procedure see energization and commissioning with the grid operator.

Conditions before the first closing

Before closing the first breaker, the following is confirmed in writing:

  • The equipment is reviewed and the test records are closed.
  • The protections are in service with the final settings, not the test ones.
  • Earthing switches are open and lockout locks and tags have been removed by whoever placed them.
  • Communication with the control center and with the operator is tested.
  • Personnel are outside the zones about to be energized, at the procedure’s safety distances.

The five steps

Energization sequence
  1. Step 1: line and 115 kV bus. Close 52L; voltage and phase sequence are measured at the VT
  2. Step 2: transformer at no load. Close 52T; the inrush current and the behavior of the protections are observed
  3. Step 3: 13.8 kV bus. Close 52M; the voltage on the medium-voltage bus is measured
  4. Step 4: first load step. Close 52F; 20 % load; currents and temperature are read
  5. Step 5: second step. Raise to 50 %; the readings are repeated

Step 1: line and 115 kV bus. With 52L closed, the 115 kV bus receives voltage from the grid. The voltage is read at the secondary of the voltage transformer: it must correspond to the grid voltage divided by the ratio. The phase sequence is verified and must be that of the system. If two sources were to be paralleled, synchronism across the open breaker would be checked here before closing; with a single source, only the sequence.

Step 2: transformer at no load. Closing 52T produces the transformer inrush current, which lasts a few cycles and can be several times the rated current. Check that the differential protection does not trip on it and that, once the transient has passed, the no-load current is small and steady. Listen to and look at the equipment: noises, temperature, gas or level indicators. The transformer stays at no load for the time the procedure defines. For the phenomenon see transformer inrush current and, if it trips, transformer trip at energization.

Step 3: 13.8 kV bus. With 52M closed, the voltage on the medium-voltage bus is measured. It must correspond to the high-side voltage multiplied by the transformer ratio at the tap it is on. If it does not match, suspect the tap or the voltage transformer before the transformer.

Steps 4 and 5: load in steps. The feeder breaker is closed with a first load step and the currents on both sides, the temperature and the protections are read. Each step raises the load, and the readings are repeated. Check that the current measured by each protection is consistent with the load and with the current transformer ratio, which is the final verification of the loaded ratios.

What to do if something does not comply

The last closed breaker is opened, left in a safe state and the cause is investigated before trying again. Do not close again onto a protection that tripped without understanding the cause: the trip may be telling you there is a real fault. The relay’s oscillographic record is the first evidence to review.

Worked example

Example data (assumed): a 40 MVA transformer, 115/13.8 kV, nominal tap. Measured grid voltage: 117.3 kV. Voltage transformer of 115 kV/√3 to 115 V/√3. Example inrush current: 8 times the rated current. Load steps: 20 % and 50 % of 40 MVA.

  1. Rated current at 115 kV: 40 000 kVA / (√3 × 115 kV) = 200.8 A.
  2. Rated current at 13.8 kV: 40 000 / (√3 × 13.8) = 1 673.5 A.
  3. Step 1: the voltage is 117.3 / 115 = 1.02, that is 102 % of nominal. The VT ratio is 1 000, so between phases you must read 117.3 kV / 1 000 = 117.3 V. Phase to earth, 117.3 / √3 = 67.7 kV on the primary and 67.7 V on the secondary.
  4. Step 2: the example inrush current is 8 × 200.8 = 1 606 A. It is the figure used to check that the protection does not mistake the transient for a fault.
  5. Step 3: the medium-voltage bus voltage is 13.8 × 117.3 / 115 = 14.08 kV, equal to 102 % of nominal. If 13.8 kV were read with the grid at 117.3 kV, the transformer would be on a different tap.
  6. Step 4: 20 % of 40 MVA is 8 MVA, which at 13.8 kV is 8 000 / (√3 × 13.8) = 334.7 A.
  7. Step 5: 50 % is 20 MVA, that is 20 000 / (√3 × 13.8) = 836.7 A.

Record of each step

For each step, note the closing time, who ordered it and who carried it out, the readings with their units, the exit condition and who authorized the next. That record goes into the commissioning dossier. If the equipment fails later, it is the proof of how it was energized.

Checklist

  • Previous tests and review closed; grid operator authorization received.
  • Protections in service with final settings.
  • Earthing switches open and lockouts removed by whoever placed them.
  • Step 1: voltage and phase sequence verified at the VT.
  • Step 2: transformer at no load without a trip; no-load current steady.
  • Step 3: medium-voltage bus voltage consistent with the tap.
  • Steps 4 and 5: current at each step consistent with the load and the CT ratio.
  • Transformer temperature and condition reviewed at each step.
  • Record of each switching operation with time, owner and readings.

References

  • Energization procedure: set by the substation owner and, where it applies, the grid operator; the sequence described here is general and does not replace the project’s procedure.
  • Calculations and data: our own, with assumed data for the example.

Need this study?

We prepare the energization sequence, with the conditions and criteria of each step, as part of our studies for commissioning, for projects in any country. Write to us.

Frequently asked questions

Why is the transformer energized at no load before loading it?

Because that isolates what is being verified. At no load you see the inrush current, the excitation current and the behavior of the protection without the load getting mixed in. If something fails, you know it was the transformer or its protection and not the feeder. Load is added afterward, in steps.

What do the protections do during energization?

They stay in service with their final settings, not the test ones. The transformer inrush current can be several times the rated current and the protection must tell it apart from a fault. If it trips, do not close again without understanding why; the guide on transformer trips at energization explains it.

How long do you wait between one step and the next?

As long as the substation's procedure sets and, where it applies, the grid operator. It must be enough to read the measurements, inspect the equipment and confirm the condition of the step. The times belong to the assumed example, not to a recommendation.

WhatsApp