Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Testing, commissioning and faults

Secondary or Primary Injection: When to Use Each

What secondary and primary injection each prove on a relay and its CT, when one is enough and when both are needed, with a worked example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

injectionprimary52TC 600/5test block51 relaytripinjectionsecondarysecondary: tests the relay, its settings and its logicprimary: plus CT, ratio, polarity and wiringthe CT is short-circuited in the block before isolating the relaySecondary: pickup at 4.02 Aexpected 480 A ÷ 120 = 4.00 A; error 0.5 %Primary: 600 A through the conductorexpected 600 A ÷ 120 = 5.00 A at the relayrelay current (50 px per A)expected 5.00 Ameasured 4.97 Aerror: (4.97 − 5.00) ÷ 5.00 = −0.6 %the relay shows 4.97 × 120 = 596 Aexample limit: 2 %: passesChainPlanInjectionMeasurandRecord© tizagrp.cominjectionprimary52TC 600/5test block51 relaytripinjectionsecondarysecondary: tests the relay, its settings and its logicprimary: plus CT, ratio, polarity and wiringthe CT is short-circuited in the block before isolating the relaySecondary: pickup at 4.02 Aexpected 480 A ÷ 120 = 4.00 A; error 0.5 %Primary: 600 A through the conductorexpected 600 A ÷ 120 = 5.00 A at the relayrelay current (50 px per A)expected 5.00 Ameasured 4.97 Aerror: (4.97 − 5.00) ÷ 5.00 = −0.6 %the relay shows 4.97 × 120 = 596 Aexample limit: 2 %: passesChainPlanInjectionMeasurandRecord© tizagrp.com
Secondary and primary injection on a 51 relay with 600/5 CT: what each tests and the error of the complete chain. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Secondary injection applies current or voltage directly at the relay terminals and tests the relay: pickup, timing, logic and outputs. Primary injection drives current through the power conductor and tests the whole chain: CT, ratio, polarity, wiring and the relay reading. Secondary is the routine test; primary is kept for new installations, replaced CTs, polarity doubts and differential schemes.

Short answer

These are two different tests that answer two different questions. Secondary injection applies current (and voltage, if the relay uses it) at the relay terminals, through the test block, and tests the relay: that it picks up where it should, operates in the expected time, and that its logic and outputs respond. Primary injection passes current through the power conductor, through the CT, and tests the whole chain: the CT ratio, its polarity, the wiring and what the relay finally reads. In commissioning, secondary injection is always done; primary injection is kept for where a wiring or CT error would be costly.

What each one tests

SecondaryPrimary
Injected atRelay terminals, through the test blockPower conductor, through the CT
TestsRelay, settings, logic, outputsAll of that, plus CT, ratio, polarity and wiring
Does not testCT, wiring to the relayFine pickup points (the current is less precise)
EquipmentRelay test setHigh-current source and heavy cables
ConditionRelay out of serviceConductor de-energized and cleared

Secondary injection is precise and repeatable: magnitude, angle and time are controlled to the accuracy of the test set. That is why it is used to verify pickup points, time curves and logic. Primary injection is cruder: the currents are often lower than rated, and the source does not offer the same precision. Its value is not in measuring pickup but in closing the whole loop, from the current source to the relay display.

When secondary is enough

  • Relays already installed, with a CT and wiring verified earlier, where the only change is the settings.
  • Routine or maintenance tests, when the wiring was not touched.
  • Verification of logic, tripping of other equipment and signals: none of these depend on the CT.

In these cases secondary injection tests what changed and does not add unnecessary risk.

When primary is needed

  • New installation or new CTs: the first time the CT, wiring and relay chain is closed.
  • Replaced or rewired CTs, or terminals touched in a terminal block.
  • Polarity or ratio doubts. A reversed polarity in a differential protection can make the relay see a fault where there is none, or miss one where there is.
  • Differential and busbar schemes, where several CTs must add up correctly; the primary test confirms the direction of each.
  • When the contract or the test plan requires it as an acceptance criterion.

Primary injection does not replace the CT’s own tests (ratio, excitation, insulation). See excitation and knee-point tests and CT terminal marking.

Precautions that are not negotiable

  1. A CT secondary is never opened with current in the primary. It is shorted at the test block before the relay is isolated, and restored in reverse order.
  2. Tripping is isolated before injecting: the breaker must not operate by accident. If the real trip is to be checked, it is done as a separate test with the equipment in the intended condition. See breaker trip and close tests.
  3. Conductor de-energized, with working earths, before primary injection. The source cables carry large currents and need good connections.
  4. The initial state is recorded: position of the links and the test block, so everything is returned exactly as found.

Worked example

Example data (assumed): overcurrent relay 51 on a feeder with a 600/5 A CT (ratio 120). The pickup setting is 480 A primary. The example’s criterion for measurement error is 2 % at most. Measured values: secondary pickup 4.02 A; relay current 4.97 A when 600 A is injected through the primary.

  1. CT ratio: 600 / 5 = 120.
  2. Secondary pickup: 480 / 120 = 4.00 A. For the pickup test, 3.90 A is applied (97.5 % of the setting), where it must not operate, and 4.10 A (102.5 %), where it must.
  3. Measured pickup: 4.02 A against 4.00 A expected: error (4.02 − 4.00) / 4.00 = 0.5 %. This injection checked the relay.
  4. Primary injection: with 600 A through the conductor, 600 / 120 = 5.00 A is expected at the relay.
  5. Measurement: 4.97 A. Error: (4.97 − 5.00) / 5.00 = −0.006, or −0.6 %. Within 2 %.
  6. Display reading: 4.97 × 120 = 596.4 A, which the relay shows as 596 A. Against 600 A actual, the error is the same −0.6 %.

If step 5 had given 4.00 A, the reading would be 480 A: a wrongly loaded ratio, a CT connected on another tap, or a turn wired wrongly. That is exactly the kind of error secondary injection cannot see.

What each test lets through

Secondary injection lets through everything upstream of the injection point: a CT ratio different from the one loaded in the relay, a reversed polarity, two phases crossed in the wiring between the CT and the test block, or a CT connected on the wrong winding. The relay responds perfectly to what is injected; what arrives from the CT is another story (see CT saturation).

Primary injection lets through fine differences in pickup and time, because the source and the conductor do not offer the accuracy of a relay test set, and also conditions that are hard to reproduce through the primary: specific angles, harmonics or unbalanced faults. That is why the two tests do not compete: they complement each other, and the plan says what is done with each.

When primary injection is not possible

Sometimes it is not practical: very high currents on busbars or generators, conductors in gas-insulated or enclosed bus ducts that are hard to reach. In those cases the plan replaces primary injection with three checks: the CT’s own tests (ratio, polarity, excitation), the relay’s secondary injection and a verification at energization with the real load current, where magnitudes and angles are read at each relay and compared with what the power flow predicts. The decision and its reason are written in the plan.

What is recorded

For each injection: injected value, expected value, measured value, calculated error, instrument used with its identification, and the initial and final state of the test block. With that, another person can repeat the test and compare. The criteria for each record follow the standards for protection testing and secondary injection.

What not to do

  • Do not consider the CT tested because the relay passed secondary injection.
  • Do not inject through the primary without a cleared, earthed conductor.
  • Do not leave the test block in the test position at the end.
  • Do not use primary injection to verify fine pickup points; that is what secondary is for.
  • Do not approve without recording injected, expected and measured current.

Checklist

  • Approved test plan: what is injected, where, and against what criterion.
  • Relay settings verified against the calculation memo before testing.
  • CT ratio and polarity per nameplate and drawings.
  • CT secondary shorted before the relay is isolated.
  • Tripping isolated during injection.
  • Secondary injection: pickup, time and logic recorded.
  • Primary injection where it applies: injected, expected and measured current.
  • Test block and links returned to the service state and verified.

References

Need these tests?

We define what is injected, where and against what criterion as part of our engineering design and studies service, for projects in any country. Contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Does secondary injection replace primary injection?

No. It tests the relay from its terminals inward, so it says nothing about the CT or the wiring that reaches the relay. If that stretch is new or was modified, you also need a check with current passing through the CT: primary injection or, where that is not possible, a separate CT ratio and polarity test.

Why is the CT shorted before the relay is isolated?

Because a CT with an open secondary and current in the primary develops voltages that are dangerous to people and to insulation. The test block lets you short the CT secondary first and only then isolate the relay, and the order is reversed at the end.

Do you have to inject the CT's rated current in the primary test?

Not necessarily. The aim is a current high enough to read the measurement clearly and calculate the error, within what the injection set and the conductor allow. The injected and expected values are recorded; the procedure and the current are set by each project's test plan.

WhatsApp