The commissioning plan of a substation organizes the work in five phases: document preparation, cold tests, functional tests, energization and handover. Each task has an owner, a duration and a dependency. The critical path, calculated from the dependencies, shows how many days the whole takes and which tasks cannot slip.
Short answer
The commissioning plan of a substation organizes the work in five phases: document preparation, cold tests, functional tests, energization and handover. Each task in the plan has an owner, a duration and a dependency on other tasks. The dependencies give the critical path, which is the chain of tasks that fixes the total duration. To see what the contract should include, read what a substation commissioning includes.
The five phases
1. Preparation. Design documents and factory records are reviewed, and a visual inspection with a tightness check is done. In this phase you confirm that what is installed is what the drawing says. The criteria of the records are in commissioning standards, FAT and SAT.
2. Cold tests. These are tests with the substation de-energized: transformer, breakers, disconnectors, current and voltage transformers. They are done before energizing because they detect faults that, with voltage applied, would be a breakdown. See tests on substation primary equipment and cold and hot commissioning.
3. Functional tests. Relays, logic and signals are tested: each protection with its measuring transformer, the trip all the way to the breaker, and each signal from the field to the control system. See point-to-point signal tests.
4. Energization. Before applying voltage a pre-energization review is done with a checklist, and energization is coordinated with the grid operator when the substation connects to its system. See what is checked before energizing a substation and energization with the grid operator. After energizing come the tests under load.
5. Handover. The dossier is assembled: signed records, reports, as-built drawings and final settings. See commissioning dossier.
Roles
Each task in the plan must have an owner, and it is not the same in all of them. The works contractor delivers the finished installation, the factory records and the drawings, and corrects assembly findings. The testing company runs the cold and functional tests and delivers the records. The owner approves, provides access and decides on findings. The grid operator authorizes energization and coordinates switching at its connection point. One owner per task prevents a test from waiting because «I thought someone else was doing it».
How to build the schedule
- List the tasks with a clear name and a duration in working days.
- For each task note what must be finished before it.
- Calculate the earliest finish of each task: the largest of the finishes of its predecessors plus its own duration.
- Calculate backward the latest finish of each task without delaying the end.
- Float is the difference. Tasks with zero float form the critical path.
- Reserve the energization window agreed with the grid operator and do not move it for convenience.
Worked example: schedule of a one-transformer substation
Example data. A 34.5/13.2 kV substation with one transformer and three bays. Durations in working days, assumed for illustration.
| Task | Phase | Duration | Depends on |
|---|---|---|---|
| A. Review of documents and records | Preparation | 3 | — |
| B. Visual inspection and tightness | Preparation | 4 | A |
| C. Cold tests of the transformer | Cold | 3 | B |
| D. Cold tests of breakers and disconnectors | Cold | 5 | B |
| E. Current and voltage transformer tests | Cold | 2 | B |
| F. Relay and logic tests | Functional | 6 | B |
| G. Point-to-point signal tests | Functional | 4 | E, F |
| H. Relay-to-breaker trip tests | Functional | 3 | D, F |
| I. Pre-energization review | Energization | 1 | C, D, G, H |
| J. Energization with the grid operator | Energization | 1 | I |
| K. Tests under load | Energization | 2 | J |
| L. Dossier and handover | Handover | 3 | K |
Step 1. Earliest finishes. A: 3. B: 3 + 4 = 7. C: 7 + 3 = 10. D: 7 + 5 = 12. E: 7 + 2 = 9. F: 7 + 6 = 13. G: the larger of E (9) and F (13), plus 4 = 17. H: the larger of D (12) and F (13), plus 3 = 16.
Step 2. Closing. I: the largest of C (10), D (12), G (17) and H (16), plus 1 = 18. J: 19. K: 21. L: 24.
Step 3. Total duration. 24 working days.
Step 4. Float. Calculating backward from day 24: C has 7 days of float, D has 2, E has 4 and H has 1. A, B, F, G, I, J, K and L have zero float.
Step 5. Critical path. A, B, F, G, I, J, K and L: 3 + 4 + 6 + 4 + 1 + 1 + 2 + 3 = 24 days, equal to the total duration.
Reading. The relay tests (F) and the signal tests (G) rule the calendar. If the cold tests of the transformer (C) slip four days, nothing happens, because they have seven of float. If F slips two days, the handover slips two days. That is why the settings engineering should be ready before F starts.
Frequent mistakes
- Scheduling energization before the window with the grid operator is approved.
- Leaving the signal tests for the end, when the control system is not yet ready.
- Not assigning an owner to tests that cross two contracts, such as the relay-to-breaker trip.
- Not reserving time to correct findings. Between the cold tests and the pre-energization review, leave float.
Checklist
- The five phases have tasks with name, duration and owner.
- Each task states what it depends on.
- The critical path is calculated and marked.
- Tasks with minimal float have weekly follow-up.
- The energization window is agreed with the grid operator.
- Owner, contractor, testing company and grid operator know and approve the plan.
- There is one day of float before energization.
- The handover dossier has a date and an owner.
Related guides
- What a substation commissioning includes
- Commissioning standards: FAT and SAT
- Cold and hot commissioning
- What is checked before energizing a substation
- Energization with the grid operator: requirements and visit
- Commissioning dossier: records, reports and as-built
When to call us
Do you need this plan? We build it with you from engineering design and studies, with tasks, owners and critical path, for substations in any country. Contact us with your planned energization date.
References
- Criteria of each test and records are listed in commissioning standards: FAT and SAT.
Frequently asked questions
What is the critical path of a commissioning plan?
It is the chain of dependent tasks that fixes the total duration. If a task in that chain slips one day, energization slips one day. Tasks outside the path have float and can move without affecting the date, up to a limit.
Who must approve the plan?
The parties that depend on it: the owner, the works contractor, whoever does the testing and, before energization, the grid operator when the substation connects to its system. A plan known only to whoever wrote it breaks in the first week.
How much time should be reserved for energization?
It depends on the substation and on coordination with the grid operator, which sets the windows. The plan reserves the agreed window and provides one day of float before it, so a last-minute finding does not force rescheduling with the operator.