Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Studies and design

GIS vs AIS: Technical and Life-Cycle Comparison

Technical comparison of GIS and AIS substations: land, environment, maintenance, SF6 gas and life-cycle cost, with a break-even calculation.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

115 kV yard at the same scaleAIS: 6 300 m²GIS: 1,800 m²building, accessand transformer yardUSD, present value at 8 % over 30 yearsGIS equipment extra cost900 000land and civil works savings675 000maintenance savings (PV)101 320AIS wins by123 680break-even: 177.5 USD/m² of land andcivil works; above that value GIS winsChainGroundAmbientMaintenanceSF6Total cost© tizagrp.com115 kV yard at the same scaleAIS: 6 300 m²GIS: 1,800 m²building, accessand transformer yardUSD, present value at 8 % over 30 yearsGIS equipment extra cost900 000land and civil works savings675 000maintenance savings (PV)101 320AIS wins by123 680break-even: 177.5 USD/m² of land andcivil works; above that value GIS winsChainGroundAmbientMaintenanceSF6Total cost© tizagrp.com
GIS or AIS: footprint to scale and life-cycle cost balance of the example. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Gas-insulated switchgear (GIS) takes a fraction of the land of air-insulated switchgear (AIS), is shielded from the environment and needs less maintenance, but costs more to buy and requires managing SF6 gas. The decision is made with life-cycle cost: the saving in land and operation against the equipment premium, discounted over time, and with the fluorinated-gas restrictions that apply where the project is.

Short answer

AIS (air-insulated) and GIS (gas-insulated) do the same electrical job. The difference lies in the land they take, how the environment affects them, maintenance and cost over their life. GIS takes a fraction of the area and is shielded from the weather; AIS costs less to buy and is easier to extend. Between the two there is no absolute winner: there is a break-even point that depends on land price, the saving in operation, the discount rate and the environmental rules of the place. For the initial decision tree see AIS or GIS: how to decide the substation type.

Technical comparison

  • Land. GIS compacts busbars, breakers and disconnectors into closed compartments housed in a building. AIS spreads everything over a yard with air clearances. The difference in area is large and becomes decisive in urban areas or on high-cost land.
  • Environment. The external insulation of AIS suffers pollution, salt fog and rain, and at higher altitude it needs more clearance. GIS has its live parts inside the enclosure, so the surroundings hardly affect it.
  • Maintenance. The live parts of GIS are sealed and inspected with gas density monitoring. AIS allows visual access and on-site repair with standard equipment. In return, GIS requires personnel and tools to open compartments safely, as described in SF6 by-products.
  • Assembly and lead times. GIS arrives in factory-tested modules, and on-site assembly is shorter. AIS requires more civil work and structure erection.
  • Extensions. AIS grows by adding bays if there is land. GIS grows if the extension module and its connection were planned; that is why the initial design reserves the positions.
  • Repair. An internal GIS fault can put a section or compartment out of service while the gas is recovered and repaired. A fault in AIS is usually isolated and repaired in the yard.

SF6 gas in the balance

GIS contains SF6, a greenhouse gas whose warming potential is tens of thousands of times that of CO₂. IEC 62271-203 limits leakage from each compartment to 0.5% per year at most. The gas inventory and its estimated leakage are converted to tonnes of CO₂ equivalent for environmental reporting; the procedure is in SF6 and the environment and handling in SF6 handling per IEC 62271-4.

In the European Union, Regulation (EU) 2024/573 bans putting new switchgear with fluorinated gases into service at medium voltage up to 24 kV from 1 January 2026, and from 24 to 52 kV from 1 January 2030. For higher voltages it sets later dates. This pushes towards considering SF6-free alternatives at medium voltage and anticipating the cost of the gas and its management at high voltage.

Life-cycle cost

Total cost adds up: equipment purchase, land and civil works, assembly, operation and maintenance over the service life, gas management and end-of-life cost. Since those flows occur in different years, they are brought to present value with a discount rate. Comparing only purchase cost always favours AIS; comparing by adding annual savings without discounting favours GIS more than is warranted.

Worked example

Example data (assumed): 115 kV substation with 4 bays. AIS area: 6,300 m². GIS area (building, access and transformer yard): 1,800 m². Land and civil works cost: 150 USD/m². GIS equipment premium: 900,000 USD. Annual maintenance: AIS 18,000 USD, GIS 9,000 USD. Service life 30 years, discount rate 8%. SF6 inventory: 1,800 kg; GWP in the example: 25,000.

  1. Area difference: 6,300 − 1,800 = 4,500 m².
  2. Land and civil saving of the GIS: 4,500 × 150 = 675,000 USD.
  3. Investment difference: 900,000 − 675,000 = 225,000 USD in favour of AIS.
  4. Annual maintenance saving of GIS: 18,000 − 9,000 = 9,000 USD. Undiscounted, over 30 years it would be 270,000 USD, which would make GIS win by 45,000 USD.
  5. With 8% discounting, the 30-year present-value factor is (1 − 1.08⁻³⁰) / 0.08 = 11.258. The maintenance saving is worth 9,000 × 11.258 = 101,320 USD today.
  6. Result: AIS still wins by 225,000 − 101,320 = 123,680 USD.
  7. Break-even land price: (900,000 − 101,320) / 4,500 = 177.5 USD/m². With land and civil works above that value, GIS is cheaper.
  8. Gas: with the maximum leakage of 0.5% per year, 1,800 kg × 0.005 = 9 kg/year, equivalent to 9 × 25,000 / 1,000 = 225 t of CO₂ equivalent per year. It is a ceiling; the real leakage of a well-assembled installation is lower.

The lesson of the example: with the given data, discounting changes the result compared with the simple sum, and land price is the variable that weighs most. Replace each datum with your project’s before concluding.

Common mistakes

  • Comparing only purchase price.
  • Adding future savings without discounting them.
  • Forgetting reserve land to extend the AIS.
  • Ignoring the cost of gas management and personnel training.
  • Not checking the environmental rules of the country where it is installed.

Checklist

  • Land area of each alternative and its cost with civil works.
  • GIS equipment premium quoted.
  • Annual maintenance of each alternative.
  • Service life, discount rate and present value calculated.
  • SF6 inventory and maximum leakage in CO₂ equivalent.
  • Fluorinated-gas restrictions of the project’s country.
  • Extension positions planned.
  • Site pollution and altitude conditions documented.

Need this study?

We compare AIS and GIS alternatives with your land, your environment and your costs, and deliver the comparison with the life-cycle calculation and the summary for the decision. Engineering work can be done for projects in any country. See the engineering design and studies service and contact us.

References

  • IEC 62271-203, gas-insulated metal-enclosed switchgear for rated voltages above 52 kV (leakage limit per compartment).
  • IEC 62271-1, common specifications for high-voltage switchgear.
  • Regulation (EU) 2024/573 on fluorinated greenhouse gases.

Frequently asked questions

When is a GIS worthwhile?

When land is expensive or scarce, when the environment (salt or industrial pollution, altitude, humidity) punishes external insulation, or when the substation goes inside a building or an urban area. On cheap land and in a clean environment, AIS is usually cheaper.

What SF6 leakage does a GIS allow?

IEC 62271-203 limits gas leakage from each compartment to a maximum of 0.5% per year. Well-built installations lose less. Even so, the gas inventory is accounted for and converted to CO₂ equivalent for environmental reporting.

Do SF6 restrictions affect the design?

They depend on the country. In the European Union, Regulation (EU) 2024/573 already bans putting new switchgear with fluorinated gases into service at medium voltage up to 24 kV from 2026 and from 24 to 52 kV from 2030, and sets later dates for higher voltages. A project that is exported or whose parent company is there must review those dates from the concept stage.

WhatsApp