Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Equipment, switchboards and substations

SF6 and the Environment: Global Warming and Emissions

Why SF6 is such a potent greenhouse gas, how a leak is turned into CO₂ equivalent, and what IEC 62271-4 and IEC 62271-1 ask for in this respect.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

GIS1,800 kgof SF6ρleak 0.5 % peryear 9 kg of SF69 kg × GWP 23,500211.5 t of CO₂ere-fillingrecorddesign leakage of closed equipmentmass lost times the GWPthe record shows the real leakageSF6 lost, cumulative (kg)yearsdesign: 0.5 % per yearreal, from the re-fillingsover 3 times: leak to locateEmissionsInventoryLeak (kg/year)× GWPt CO₂eRecord© tizagrp.comGIS1,800 kgof SF6ρleak 0.5 % peryear 9 kg of SF69 kg × GWP 23,500211.5 t of CO₂ere-fillingrecorddesign leakage of closed equipmentmass lost times the GWPthe record shows the real leakageSF6 lost, cumulative (kg)yearsdesign: 0.5 % per yearreal, from the re-fillingsover 3 times: leak to locateEmissionsInventoryLeak (kg/year)× GWPt CO₂eRecord© tizagrp.com
From an SF6 leak to CO₂ equivalent: mass lost times the global warming potential, and design leakage against the real leakage in the record. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

SF6 is not toxic, does not harm the ozone layer and does not build up in living things, but it is a very potent greenhouse gas with a very long life in the atmosphere. That is why IEC 62271-4 asks for it to be handled in a closed cycle, without releasing it, and IEC 62271-1 limits equipment leakage. A leak is turned into CO₂ equivalent by multiplying the mass lost by the global warming potential.

Short answer

SF6 is an excellent insulant and is not toxic, but it is one of the most potent greenhouse gases known. One kilogram released warms the atmosphere, over a 100-year horizon, some twenty thousand times more than one kilogram of CO2, and it stays there for a long time. That is why the electrical industry handles it in a closed cycle: IEC 62271-4 asks for it to be recovered and re-used instead of released, and IEC 62271-1 limits how much each piece of equipment may lose per year.

Edition of the standard. This guide is based on IEC 62271-4:2013 (first edition), whose Annex F covers the environmental effects of SF6. The current edition is IEC 62271-4:2022 (second edition), which adds procedures for gases that replace SF6. In it, the environmental information on SF6 moved to IEC 60376:2018.

What harm it does and what harm it does not

IEC 62271-4:2013 reviews three possible environmental effects in its Annex F:

EffectWhat the standard says about SF6
Toxicity to the ecosystemIt is not toxic, does not build up in the food chain and hardly dissolves in water
Ozone depletionIt does not contribute, because it contains neither chlorine nor bromine
Greenhouse effectYes: it strongly absorbs infrared radiation and has a very long life in the atmosphere

Our own summary of Annex F of IEC 62271-4:2013; wording and layout by Tiza Group.

SF6 is on the list of gases controlled by the Kyoto Protocol, together with CO2, methane, nitrous oxide, hydrofluorocarbons and perfluorocarbons. Hydrofluorocarbons, perfluorocarbons and SF6 are known as fluorinated gases.

What the global warming potential is

The global warming potential, GWP, compares the warming that 1 kg of a gas produces over 100 years with the warming of 1 kg of CO2. The GWP of CO2 is 1 by definition.

The standard gives SF6 a GWP of 22,200, the value of the Third Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Later reports updated it: 22,800 in the Fourth Report and 23,500 in the Fifth, according to the table the Government of Canada publishes for emissions reporting. The value you apply depends on the reporting system you submit your figures to.

According to the same standard, SF6 from all applications contributes about 0.2 % of the total greenhouse effect. The standard also states that the GWP alone is not enough to judge a piece of equipment: the environmental impact of an application is assessed and compared with a life cycle assessment to ISO 14040.

How much the electrical industry emits

The electrical industry uses SF6 in a closed cycle: the gas is kept inside GIS, circuit breakers, gas-insulated lines and gas-insulated voltage transformers. According to the standard, it is reported as the largest user of SF6 in the world, but its emissions are low compared with applications that release the gas as they use it.

Average emission rates vary widely between regions: from well below 1 % to more than 10 % of the installed gas, depending on handling, equipment tightness and the amount of gas in service. According to the standard, those rates have fallen sharply since 1995, and industry actions reduced emissions by 50 % to 90 % in Europe, Asia and North America. Those actions were two: equipment with less gas and higher tightness, and better handling procedures and equipment at every stage of the equipment’s life.

Major failures that release gas are very rare, according to the experience the standard records. In addition, switchgear is divided into compartments, and a failure releases only the gas of the affected compartment.

From a leak to CO₂ equivalent

The design leakage is set by IEC 62271-1:2017. In a closed pressure system, the maximum relative leakage rate is 0.5 % per year for SF6 and its mixtures, at 20 °C (clause 6.16.3). The standard notes that some regulations require less, for example 0.1 % per year. Sealed equipment is considered to lose less than 0.1 % per year during its life (clause 6.16.4). How each system is classified is in controlled, closed and sealed gas systems.

The emissions calculation is direct:

CO2 equivalent (t) = SF6 mass lost (kg) × GWP / 1000

Example. A 230 kV GIS substation holds 1,800 kg of SF6 in its compartments. If all of them lost exactly the maximum rate of 0.5 % per year, the loss would be 9 kg per year. With the GWP of the IPCC Fifth Report, 9 × 23,500 / 1000 = 211.5 t of CO2 equivalent per year. If the re-filling record shows that 30 kg were added in one year, the real leakage is more than three times the design value: there is a leak to locate.

A low-density alarm that keeps coming back is, besides a service problem, a source of emissions. How it is diagnosed is in SF6 low-pressure alarm.

What the standard asks for to emit less

What IEC 62271-4:2013 asks for to reduce emissions comes down to four ideas:

  1. Closed cycle: no deliberate release of the gas. Recovery and re-use have the highest priority (Annex F).
  2. Handling by procedure: recover before opening, down to an SF6 partial pressure below 2 kPa, and send the recovered gas where its quality allows. We explain it in SF6 handling to IEC 62271-4.
  3. Trained personnel: the first training module of Annex C includes climate change, the Kyoto Protocol and the GWP.
  4. Records: some countries already require by law that SF6 emissions be recorded and reported (Annex F).

Mixtures and alternative gases

In very cold climates, below about −40 °C, mixtures of SF6 with nitrogen or with CF4 are used (IEC 62271-4:2013, Annex J). The SF6 percentage is set by the equipment manufacturer; usual values range from 10 % to 75 % by volume. A mixture still contains SF6 and is handled under the rules of the standard, plus the particulars of Annex J.

The 2022 edition of IEC 62271-4 adds handling procedures for gases that replace SF6, with one annex per gas. The requirements for each alternative come from that edition and from the equipment manufacturer’s manual.

Typical errors

  • Calculating CO2 equivalent with a GWP other than the one the report requires.
  • Comparing the leakage of a piece of equipment with 0.5 % per year without knowing whether it is a closed or a sealed system.
  • Recording re-fillings without the mass added, only with the pressure.
  • Venting the gas of a compartment “because it was only a little”.
  • Judging equipment only by the GWP of the gas, without looking at its life cycle.

When to call us

At Tiza Group we analyse SF6 quality, test density monitors and test circuit breakers and switchgear at commissioning and during maintenance. For your case, our quote recommends the tests you need. See our circuit breaker testing and write to us for a quote.

References

  • IEC 62271-4, High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Part 4: Handling procedures for sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) and its mixtures, edition 1.0 (2013), Annexes C, F and J.
  • IEC 62271-4:2022, High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Part 4: Handling procedures for gases for insulation and/or switching, edition 2.0 (current edition).
  • IEC TR 62271-303:2008, High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Part 303: Use and handling of sulphur hexafluoride (SF6), replaced by IEC 62271-4:2013.
  • IEC 62271-1, High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Part 1: Common specifications for alternating current switchgear and controlgear, edition 2.0 (2017), clauses 6.16.3 and 6.16.4.
  • Government of Canada, Global warming potentials (100-year GWP values from the IPCC Fourth and Fifth Assessment Reports).

Frequently asked questions

What is the global warming potential of SF6?

IEC 62271-4:2013 quotes 22,200 times that of CO2 over 100 years, the value of the IPCC Third Assessment Report (Annex F). Later IPCC reports give 22,800 (Fourth Report) and 23,500 (Fifth Report), according to the Government of Canada table for emissions reporting. Use the value required by the report you submit your figures to.

Does SF6 damage the ozone layer?

No. SF6 and its by-products in switchgear do not contribute to destroying stratospheric ozone, because they contain neither chlorine nor bromine (IEC 62271-4:2013, Annex F). Its environmental problem is the greenhouse effect.

What annual leakage is accepted in SF6 equipment?

For closed pressure systems, IEC 62271-1:2017 sets a maximum relative leakage rate of 0.5 % per year for SF6 and its mixtures, at 20 °C (clause 6.16.3). Sealed systems are specified by their operating life, and the standard considers their losses to be below 0.1 % per year (clause 6.16.4).

WhatsApp