Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Equipment, switchboards and substations

SF6 Handling to IEC 62271-4: From Filling to End of Life

What IEC 62271-4 requires when handling SF6: evacuation and filling, re-filling, gas quality checks, recovery before opening, used-gas grades, end of life.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

compartmentSF6ρrecoveryunitcylinderevacuate the airfill with SF6in servicealarm: re-fillrecover before openingdry air, then openSF6 absolute pressuretimerated fillingalarm< 2 kPaatmosphericvacuum ≥ 30 minStageEvacuationFillingRe-fillingRecoveryOpening© tizagrp.comcompartmentSF6ρrecoveryunitcylinderevacuate the airfill with SF6in servicealarm: re-fillrecover before openingdry air, then openSF6 absolute pressuretimerated fillingalarm< 2 kPaatmosphericvacuum ≥ 30 minStageEvacuationFillingRe-fillingRecoveryOpening© tizagrp.com
Life of an SF6 compartment to IEC 62271-4: evacuation and filling, re-filling at the alarm and recovery below 2 kPa before opening. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

IEC 62271-4 sets the minimum procedures for handling the SF6 of high-voltage switchgear over its whole life cycle: filling at commissioning, re-filling and gas quality checks in service, recovery during maintenance and dismantling at end of life. It has two goals: protecting personnel and reducing SF6 emissions.

Short answer

IEC 62271-4 is the standard that says how the SF6 of high-voltage switchgear is handled from the moment it arrives on site until it is dismantled. It covers filling at commissioning, re-filling and gas quality checks in service, recovery of the gas before a compartment is opened, and the end of life of the equipment. The standard presents these procedures as minimum requirements for personnel safety and for reducing emissions (clause 1.1). Where the manufacturer’s manual asks for something different, the manual prevails.

Edition of the standard. This guide is based on IEC 62271-4:2013 (first edition). The current edition is IEC 62271-4:2022 (second edition), which adds procedures for gases that replace SF6, makes the main clauses independent of the gas type and moves the information on each gas to its own annex.

What counts as SF6 handling

For the standard, handling SF6 is any process that may involve moving the gas from one vessel to another (definition 2.2). That includes operations that are sometimes confused:

OperationWhat movesWith what
EvacuationAir or nitrogen, which may be releasedVacuum pump
RecoverySF6, from the compartment to a reclaimer or a cylinderRecovery compressor
Re-fillingSF6, to bring the compartment back to its filling pressureCylinder and filling equipment
ReclaimRecovered SF6, filtered of dust, by-products, moisture and oilRecovery unit with filters

Definitions 2.3 to 2.7 of IEC 62271-4:2013; wording and layout by Tiza Group.

The standard always uses absolute pressure. A common error is to read a gauge-pressure instrument and compare it with a figure from the standard without adding the atmospheric pressure.

At installation and commissioning

A compartment that arrives with air or nitrogen is evacuated before it is filled with SF6. The standard asks for a pressure below 2 kPa and for the pump to keep running for at least 30 minutes before checking that the vacuum holds (clause 3.2). The compartment is then filled to the rated pressure, the density sensor is checked, the joints made on site are checked for tightness and the gas quality is measured.

Many GIS arrive with compartments pre-filled at the factory, at 0.12 MPa to 0.15 MPa (note to definition 2.5). In that case there is no evacuation: the compartment is topped up to the rated pressure (clause 3.3). That shortens commissioning.

Example. A busbar compartment of a 115 kV GIS arrives pre-filled at 0.13 MPa absolute. The nameplate gives 0.50 MPa absolute filling pressure at 20 °C. The technician tops it up to 0.50 MPa, with the temperature correction given by the manufacturer. There is no vacuum step, because the factory gas is already SF6. At the end, the assembly joints are checked and moisture and purity are measured. The figures in this example are illustrative: those of your equipment are on its nameplate and in its manual.

The dew point required at filling is covered in installation of switchgear.

During service life

In a closed pressure system, re-filling usually starts with the first alarm of the density monitor (clause 4.1). Before re-filling, the date of the last re-filling is checked to see whether the leak is abnormal. If it is, the standard requires the leak to be located and eliminated at once: re-filling again and again does not solve the problem. How pressure systems are classified and which leakage is accepted is in controlled, closed and sealed gas systems, and how the alarms are generated in the SF6 density monitor.

Gas quality is normally measured on site with portable instruments (clause 4.2). The typical measurements are three:

  • Moisture.
  • SF6 percentage.
  • Reactive gaseous by-products, which produce acidity.

If the history of the compartment is unknown, the reactive by-products are measured first, so as not to damage the other instruments. When an on-site result is not satisfactory, a sample is taken in a cylinder and sent to a chemical laboratory. What each measurement detects is explained in SF6 gas analysis.

During maintenance: recover before opening

Before a compartment is opened, the SF6 is recovered. The standard sets the same limit for every case: the SF6 partial pressure must be below 2 kPa before dry air is let in and the compartment opened (clauses 5.2 and 5.3). If recovery cannot reach that value, because of a leak in the equipment or small pumping openings, other methods are accepted, such as dilution.

The procedure changes with how much arcing the gas has seen. The standard defines three conditions of used SF6 by the amount of gaseous by-products (definitions 2.18 to 2.20):

Gas conditionGaseous by-productsWhere it is expected
Non-arcedBelow 1 ml/l (0.1 %)Insulation compartments, freshly filled gas
Normally arcedBetween 1 ml/l and 10 ml/l (0.1 % to 1 %)Circuit breakers and switches after normal operations
Heavily arcedAbove 10 ml/l (1 %)After an internal arc or an interruption failure

Values from definitions 2.18 to 2.20 of IEC 62271-4:2013; wording and layout by Tiza Group.

Heavily arced gas also comes with a dust of metal fluorides, which calls for more protection when the compartment is opened and cleaned. We cover it in SF6 by-products and safety when opening a compartment.

What happens to the recovered gas

Gas taken out of equipment is treated as used gas (definition 2.14). Depending on its quality, the standard sorts it into three groups (definitions 2.15 to 2.17):

  1. Fit for re-use on site: it meets the impurity limits of IEC 60480. It can go back into the same equipment or into another one.
  2. Fit for re-use by the gas manufacturer: it exceeds those limits, but the gas manufacturer can process it.
  3. Not fit for re-use: it is disposed of as waste under local or international regulations.

SF6 is stored as a gas below 2 MPa or as a liquid up to 5 MPa (Annex A). An “empty” cylinder still holds gas and is treated as if it were full. Cylinders of new gas or gas fit for re-use on site are kept apart from those holding gas for the manufacturer or gas not fit for re-use.

At the end of the equipment’s life

Dismantling is the owner’s responsibility, with the manufacturer’s support (clause 6.1). The path depends on the pressure system:

  • Controlled or closed systems: the gas is analysed, or its history is known, and it is recovered on site with the procedure that matches its condition (clause 6.2).
  • Sealed systems: they are usually shipped complete to the dismantling site. There, the gas is recovered through the equipment’s connection or, if it has none, with a gas-tight drilling system (clauses 6.3 and 6.4). Resin enclosures must be protected from impacts during transport.

A typical piece of equipment is 75 % to 90 % metal by weight, and the SF6 is a very small part of that weight (clause 6.5). Parts with dust are neutralised and cleaned before they are recycled or disposed of.

Who may handle the gas

The standard asks for certified personnel, or work under their supervision, with training in modules by task: awareness, maintenance without gas recovery, installation and commissioning, maintenance with gas recovery, and dismantling at end of life (Annex C). Training is given for a specific design: a GIS is not the same as medium-voltage switchgear.

Typical errors

  • Opening a compartment without confirming an SF6 partial pressure below 2 kPa.
  • Re-filling at every alarm without locating the leak.
  • Storing cylinders of fit and unfit gas together without labels.
  • Treating a circuit-breaker compartment as if it held non-arced gas.
  • Venting the gas of an “empty” cylinder in the belief that it no longer contains SF6.

When to call us

At Tiza Group we analyse SF6 quality and test circuit breakers and switchgear at commissioning and during maintenance. For your case, our quote recommends the tests and the test equipment you need, without paying for tests you do not need. See our circuit breaker testing and write to us for a quote.

References

  • IEC 62271-4, High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Part 4: Handling procedures for sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) and its mixtures, edition 1.0 (2013), clauses 1.1, 2.2 to 2.7, 2.14 to 2.20, 3.2, 3.3, 3.4, 4.1, 4.2, 5.2, 5.3, 6.1 to 6.5 and Annexes A and C.
  • IEC 62271-4:2022, High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Part 4: Handling procedures for gases for insulation and/or switching, edition 2.0 (current edition).
  • IEC 60480:2019, Specifications for the re-use of sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) and its mixtures in electrical equipment, edition 3.0.

Frequently asked questions

What SF6 pressure must remain in a compartment before it is opened?

The SF6 partial pressure must be below 2 kPa before the compartment is flooded with dry air and opened (IEC 62271-4:2013, clauses 5.2, 5.3 and 6.4). If the recovery equipment cannot reach that value, because of leaks in the equipment or small pumping openings, the standard accepts other methods, such as dilution.

Can SF6 taken out of equipment be used again?

Yes, depending on its quality. The standard sets three groups (definitions 2.15 to 2.17). Gas fit for re-use on site meets the impurity limits of IEC 60480. Gas fit for re-use by the gas manufacturer exceeds those limits, but the manufacturer can process it. Gas not fit for re-use is disposed of as waste under the applicable regulations.

Does sealed medium-voltage switchgear need SF6 handling on site?

Normally not. Most medium-voltage switchgear uses sealed pressure systems, which are filled at the factory and need no gas handling during their expected life. If one is damaged and must be refilled on site, the manufacturer is consulted (clause 3.4). At end of life it is usually shipped complete to the dismantling site (clause 6.3).

WhatsApp