Pure SF6 is not toxic, but arcing breaks it down and leaves gaseous by-products and a dust of metal fluorides that irritate the skin, eyes and airways. IEC 62271-4 grades the gas by its by-product content and, by grade, asks for ventilation, oxygen measurement and protective equipment before a compartment is opened and cleaned.
Short answer
Pure SF6 is not toxic, but an electric arc breaks it down. What remains inside the compartment are gaseous by-products, mainly SOF2, and a fine dust of metal fluorides. Both irritate the skin, eyes and airways. IEC 62271-4 grades used gas by its amount of by-products (non-arced, normally arced and heavily arced). With that grade it sets how the gas is recovered, how the compartment is opened and what protection the personnel wear.
Edition of the standard. This guide is based on IEC 62271-4:2013 (first edition). The current edition is IEC 62271-4:2022 (second edition). In it, the information on SF6 by-products and on their health effects moved to IEC 60480:2019.
How the by-products form
The arc heats the gas to thousands of degrees. According to Annex G of IEC 62271-4:2013, SF6 starts to decompose from about 500 °C and dissociates into sulphur and fluorine atoms at around 3000 °C. As it cools below about 1000 °C, most of those atoms form SF6 again. Another part reacts with whatever is nearby:
- Vaporised contact metal and the compartment walls: they form solid metal fluorides, such as CuF2 and AlF3, and tungsten oxyfluorides.
- Oxygen left over from evacuation or released by the electrodes: it forms SOF2, the main by-product, and SOF4.
- Moisture: SOF2 hydrolyses and forms SO2 and HF, which is hydrofluoric acid.
S2F10 can also form, but under arcing its quantity is very low, according to the standard. Low-current discharges (corona, sparking, partial discharges) also break down the gas, although the concentrations they produce are generally very low.
Without arcing there is no decomposition in normal service. The materials used withstand SF6 without reacting up to about 150 °C, and metals only start to decompose it noticeably between 400 °C and 600 °C, far above service temperatures.
How much arcing the gas has seen
The standard grades used SF6 by its gaseous by-product content (definitions 2.18 to 2.20). The procedure is chosen by that grade:
| Grade | Gaseous by-products | Dust | Typical cases |
|---|---|---|---|
| Non-arced | Below 0.1 % by volume | No | Busbars, cable boxes, insulation compartments |
| Normally arced | 0.1 % to 1 % | Little | Circuit breakers and switches after load or fault operations |
| Heavily arced | Above 1 % | Much | After an internal arc, an interruption failure or several high short circuits |
Values from definitions 2.18 to 2.20 and clause 6.6 of IEC 62271-4:2013; wording and layout by Tiza Group.
The quantity depends on the arc energy accumulated over the equipment’s life, on the mass of SF6 and on the adsorbers installed (clause 6.6). A load-break switch builds up far fewer by-products than a circuit breaker with a high breaking capacity that has often cleared faults. Adsorbers, such as alumina or molecular sieves, retain almost all the reactive gaseous by-products and keep the dew point low. That is why, in most cases, decomposition is low even in circuit breakers.
Example. In a GIS substation, a busbar compartment that never saw an arc is opened, and in another bay the chamber of a circuit breaker that cleared a close-in, high-current fault. The first is treated as non-arced gas. The second is treated at least as normally arced gas. If the history is unknown, the gas is analysed first: the analysis overrides the assumption. What that analysis measures is explained in SF6 gas analysis.
Two different risks: irritation and lack of oxygen
Irritation. The by-products irritate the skin, eyes and mucous membranes. At high concentrations and with enough exposure time they can cause pulmonary oedema (Annex G). Gas with by-products has a sharp, unpleasant smell. According to the standard, the odour thresholds of SOF2, SO2 and HF are of the same order as their exposure limits. That is why even small quantities give a clear warning within seconds.
The metal fluoride dust is the other risk: some fluorides react with water and form hydrofluoric acid. That is why the dust is kept away from moisture and neutralised.
Lack of oxygen. SF6 is much heavier than air and, without good mixing, it collects in low areas: pits, cable trenches, basements and drains (Annex E). The standard treats an SF6 concentration in air above 19 % by volume as an asphyxiation hazard, because it leaves oxygen at 16 % (Annex B). This risk exists even if the gas has never seen an arc.
What measures the standard asks for when opening
Before any work, the usual electrical rules apply: disconnect, secure against reclosing, verify absence of voltage, earth and short-circuit, and isolate nearby live parts (Annex B). The work permit is signed by the owner and by the service provider. Then come the measures specific to the gas:
- Recover the gas down to an SF6 partial pressure below 2 kPa before letting dry air in and opening (clauses 5.2 and 5.3). With heavily arced gas, the standard also allows time for the dust to settle before opening.
- Ventilate and measure oxygen before entering the compartment. In confined spaces, also monitor the oxygen of the room.
- Remove dust and adsorbers with a high-efficiency vacuum cleaner able to retain particles of around 1 µm.
- Wear protection when the gas has seen arcing: disposable overalls, acid-resistant gloves, goggles and, preferably, a full-face mask with a filter. Outdoors, a shelter that stops the wind from spreading the dust.
- Neutralise tools, parts and the compartment with an alkaline solution, such as the 10 % by weight soda solution the standard mentions, and rinse with clean water.
- Bag and label disposable clothing, filters and waste, and dispose of them under local regulations.
Nobody eats, drinks or smokes in the work area. While SF6 is being handled, a notice is displayed that forbids open flames, welding without precautions and heating above 200 °C, together with first-aid instructions. Anyone entering an area that may be short of oxygen does so with a second person in constant visual and audible contact.
After an internal arc
An internal arc or an external fire can release heavily arced gas into the room. In that case, the standard reserves entry and cleaning for personnel trained in the modules for maintenance with gas recovery or for dismantling (Annexes B and C). The same measures apply to areas below the point of release and to rooms without ventilation. How switchgear is tested against internal arcing is in internal fault in a GIS and arc test.
For skin or eye irritation, the person is removed from the area, washed with running water and medical care is requested. For breathing difficulty, the person is taken to fresh air and emergency services are called without delay (Annex B).
Typical errors
- Opening a circuit-breaker chamber with the same protection as a busbar compartment.
- Sweeping or blowing the dust with compressed air instead of vacuuming it.
- Entering a pit or a cable trench after a leak without measuring oxygen.
- Leaving the dust exposed to rain or moisture.
- Assuming the gas is clean because the equipment “never failed”, without knowing its fault-clearing history.
The full recovery procedure and what happens to the gas are explained in SF6 handling to IEC 62271-4.
When to call us
At Tiza Group we analyse SF6 quality and test circuit breakers and switchgear at commissioning and during maintenance. For your case, our quote recommends the tests and the test equipment you need. See our circuit breaker testing and write to us for a quote.
Related guides
- SF6 handling to IEC 62271-4: from filling to end of life
- SF6 gas analysis: moisture, purity and decomposition
- Internal fault in a GIS and arc test
- Circuit breaker interrupting chamber: vacuum, SF6 and air
- GIS switchgear: pressures and compartments
- SF6 and the environment: global warming and emissions
References
- IEC 62271-4, High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Part 4: Handling procedures for sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) and its mixtures, edition 1.0 (2013), definitions 2.18 to 2.20, clauses 5.2, 5.3 and 6.6, and Annexes B, C, E, G and H.
- IEC 62271-4:2022, High-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Part 4: Handling procedures for gases for insulation and/or switching, edition 2.0 (current edition).
- IEC 60480:2019, Specifications for the re-use of sulphur hexafluoride (SF6) and its mixtures in electrical equipment, edition 3.0.
Frequently asked questions
Is SF6 toxic?
Pure SF6 is not toxic and is biologically inert (IEC 62271-4:2013, Annex E). The risks come from two things: the by-products left by arcing, which are irritants, and the displacement of oxygen, because SF6 is much heavier than air and collects in low areas such as pits, cable trenches and basements.
What is the main by-product of arced SF6?
SOF2 (thionyl fluoride) is the main arcing by-product when oxygen is present (Annex G). With moisture it hydrolyses and forms SO2 and HF. Since no occupational exposure limit is defined for SOF2, the standard assesses the health risk with the limits of SO2 and HF (Annex H).
What concentration of SF6 in air is an asphyxiation hazard?
More than 19 % SF6 by volume in air is treated as an asphyxiation hazard, because it lowers oxygen to 16 %, which is usually taken as the asphyxiation threshold (Annex B). That is why oxygen is measured before entering a compartment and monitored in confined spaces.