Low-voltage distribution design starts at the transformer: its rated current sets the main breaker and its impedance sets the short-circuit current of the main board. From that current come the breaking capacity of the breakers and the short-time (Icw) and peak (Ipk) withstand of the board. Each outgoing feeder to an MCC or sub-board is chosen with its load current and with the breaking capacity of the point where it sits.
Short answer
The low-voltage distribution of a plant is designed from the top down. The transformer sets the rated current of the main breaker and, with its impedance, the short-circuit current of the main board. That current determines the breaking capacity of the breakers and the withstands the board must have: short-time current (Icw) and peak current (Ipk). Each outgoing feeder to an MCC or a sub-board is chosen with its load current and with the breaking capacity of the point where it sits. The design ends with checking the selectivity between the main breaker and the outgoing feeders. To understand what a board and an MCC are, see low-voltage board and MCC.
What the designer decides and what the manufacturer decides
The project designer sets the conditions: supply, short-circuit level, neutral earthing system (TN, TT or IT), voltage and loads. From them, the board manufacturer adjusts the rated characteristics of the assembly according to IEC 61439-1. Two useful remarks:
- If the short-circuit current at the supply is unknown, the rating and impedance of the transformer, or the generator reactance, are given. Large motors contribute current and must be considered.
- When several supplies operate in parallel, the board withstands must at least equal those of the largest supply or the current let through by the largest protective device on the busbar.
The guide on data to specify a low-voltage board lists what must be delivered.
The structure
- Transformer and, if there is one, a generator set with its transfer.
- Main board (main LV switchboard): receives the supply and distributes. The main breaker is here.
- Outgoing feeders to MCCs, lighting and services boards, each with its breaker.
- MCC (motor control centres), with their starters. See motor control centre.
A board with two sections and a bus tie allows one half to be maintained without shutting down the whole plant. It is justified when a plant shutdown is very costly. Every extra breaker costs and takes space, so the structure is decided by the continuity the process needs.
The four data of each point
- Load current: sum of the loads times their simultaneity factor.
- Short-circuit current available at that point, maximum for the breaking capacity and minimum for the breaker to trip.
- Board withstand: Icw (1 s by default) and Ipk. The peak current is Icw times a factor n that depends on the R/X ratio of the network.
- Selectivity with the breaker above and the one below. See selectivity in low voltage.
For the short-circuit calculation at this level, see short circuit in low voltage, below 1 000 V. The board must also withstand that current in its busbars; it is explained in Icw, Ipk and Icc.
Worked example: a 1 000 kVA transformer and three outgoing feeders
Example data (assumed): a 1 000 kVA, 13.2 kV / 480 V transformer, impedance 6 %. An infinite grid at the primary is assumed, which gives the maximum short circuit without the motors. Factor n = 2.1 (example datum). Three feeders: MCC 1 of 380 kVA, MCC 2 of 220 kVA and services of 90 kVA. Simultaneity factor of 0.75.
- Transformer rated current: In = 1 000 / (√3 × 0.48) = 1 202.8 A.
- Main breaker (Q1): it must carry at least 1 202.8 A. The next commercial value above is chosen, 1 250 A. The margin is only 3.9 %: if growth or overload is foreseen, go to the next value.
- Short circuit at the main board: Isc = 1 202.8 / 0.06 = 20 047 A.
- Breaking capacity of Q1: it must be higher than 20.0 kA. The next value above in the manufacturer’s range is chosen, and the motors’ contribution is added according to the short-circuit study.
- Board: if the breaker clears in less than 1 s, the 1 s Icw must be at least 20.0 kA. The peak current is Ipk = 2.1 × 20 047 = 42 099 A.
- Feeder to MCC 1: 380 / (√3 × 0.48) = 457.1 A. The commercial value above is chosen, 500 A. The other two: 264.6 A (MCC 2) and 108.3 A (services).
- Demand of the whole: 690 kVA connected × 0.75 = 517.5 kVA, which is 622.5 A and 51.7 % of the transformer capacity. There is room to grow.
Each feeder must also have a breaking capacity higher than the 20.0 kA and a selectivity checked with Q1. That is read from the manufacturer’s tables for each pair of breakers.
What the selection of each breaker must check
| Characteristic | What is checked |
|---|---|
| Rated current | Higher than the load current and lower than the cable capacity |
| Breaking capacity | Higher than the maximum short-circuit current of the point |
| Magnetic trip | Trips with the minimum short-circuit current at the end of the cable |
| Selectivity | With the breaker above, up to the short-circuit current of the point |
| Motor starting | The protection does not trip on the starting current; see type 1 and type 2 coordination |
Low-voltage breakers have different values per pole and in series; see low-voltage breakers: series and per-pole values.
What a good design delivers
- Single-line diagram of the distribution, with voltages, rated currents and breaking capacity of each breaker.
- Short-circuit report for each board, with its input data.
- Breaker list with its trip setting, for the coordination study.
- Selectivity table between main and feeders.
- Board data for the manufacturer: Icw, Ipk, neutral system, forms of separation and spares.
- Load schedule with simultaneity factors and reserve.
What changes the design
- Generator set in parallel or on transfer: changes the minimum and maximum short circuit.
- Large motors: contribute current in the fault and raise the required breaking capacity.
- Drives: change the shape of the current and require reviewing the earthing.
- Arc flash: with long clearing times due to selectivity, higher incident energy appears. See arc flash study.
Frequent mistakes
- Choosing the main breaker equal to the rated current with no margin.
- Forgetting the motors’ contribution to the board’s short circuit.
- Selecting the breaking capacity with the short circuit of another point.
- Asking for total selectivity without checking it in the tables.
- Leaving no reserve in the feeders or space for extension.
Checklist
- Rated current of the transformer and of the main breaker.
- Short circuit at each board, with the motors’ contribution.
- Icw and Ipk of the board requested from the manufacturer.
- Breaking capacity of each breaker higher than the short circuit of its point.
- Selectivity between main and feeders checked.
- Simultaneity factors documented.
- Reserve for extensions.
- Neutral system (TN, TT or IT) indicated.
Related guides
- Low-voltage board and MCC
- Data to specify a low-voltage board
- Selectivity in low voltage
- Short circuit in low voltage, below 1 000 V
- Icw, Ipk and Icc: board short-circuit withstand
- Type 1 and type 2 coordination
References
- IEC 61439-1: low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies, general rules (rated characteristics: short-time withstand current Icw and peak withstand current Ipk).
- ZVEI, Bemessungsdaten einer Niederspannungs-Schaltgerätekombination: Anschluss an das elektrische Netz, Fachkreis Niederspannungs-Schaltanlagen (supply data given to the manufacturer).
Need this study?
The low-voltage distribution design of your plant, with the short circuits, breaker selection and selectivity, is part of our engineering design and studies service. We do it for projects in any country. Write to us.
Frequently asked questions
What short-circuit data does the board manufacturer need?
The short-circuit current at the board's supply. If it is not available, the transformer rating and impedance (or the generator reactance) will do. Large motors raise that current and must be included. From that the manufacturer derives the board's short-circuit withstand (Icw) and peak withstand (Ipk), according to IEC 61439-1.
What is Icw and why does time matter?
It is the short-time current the board withstands without damage, rated for 1 s by default. If the protective breaker clears the fault earlier, the board is covered; if it takes longer, compare with the recalculated value. With constant energy, a 25 kA board for 1 s withstands 25 × √(1/3) = 14.4 kA for 3 s.
How is the breaker of each MCC feeder chosen?
With the projected load current (with its simultaneity factor), the next commercial value above, a breaking capacity higher than the board's short-circuit current and a verified selectivity with the main breaker. Motors add the coordination between protection and starter.