The voltage used to distribute power inside a plant is not chosen by habit but by comparing current, voltage drop, losses, copper and short-circuit level. With a 2.7 MW load at 300 m, 480 V needs 27.5 times more current and copper than 13.2 kV, and a drop of 3.6% against 0.13%. In return, medium voltage needs switchgear, a transformer close to the load and qualified staff.
Short answer
The internal distribution voltage of a plant is decided by comparing, for the same load, the current, voltage drop, losses, amount of copper and short-circuit level of each option. At equal power the current is inversely proportional to voltage: at 13.2 kV the current is 27.5 times lower than at 480 V. That is why low voltage suits small loads and short distances, and medium voltage suits larger power or longer runs. The price of medium voltage is switchgear, a transformer close to the load and qualified staff. It is a decision of the plant’s primary design.
What is decided and what is not
There are two different voltages. The supply voltage is set by the network operator according to its system and the power you request; it is an input. The internal distribution voltage is the one you choose: how far you carry energy at medium voltage and where you step it down to 480 V, 440 V or the utilization voltage of the equipment.
IEEE 141-1993 is the classic reference for power distribution in industrial plants. Choosing the voltage is a compromise between initial cost, losses, regulation and safety, and it is settled by calculation, as in the example. The standard voltages of each country (in Colombia, for instance, 13.2 kV and 34.5 kV on distribution networks) limit the real options: you do not pick a voltage the operator or the manufacturer does not handle.
The criteria that are compared
- Current. For an apparent power S, the line current is I = S / (√3 × V). It sets the size of breakers, busbars and cables.
- Voltage drop and losses. With the same copper per ampere, the volts lost do not depend on the voltage; the percentages do. Also review the AC voltage drop in cables and the busway when distribution is at low voltage.
- Copper and raceways. A very high current forces several conductors per phase in parallel, with more trays, more lugs and more space.
- Short-circuit level. At low voltage, a large transformer gives high fault currents; the switchboards must withstand them (see Icw, Ipk and Icc of a switchboard).
- Special loads. Very large motors and their starting current weigh on the busbar voltage; see starting large motors and voltage drop.
- Equipment, safety and operation. Medium voltage adds switchgear, insulation, clearances and procedures; low voltage needs more cables and higher-current switchboards.
Worked example: 2.7 MW at 300 m
Assumptions of the example (all are calculation assumptions, not data from a real plant):
- Load: 2,700 kW at power factor 0.9. Apparent power: 2,700 / 0.9 = 3,000 kVA.
- Distance from the delivery point to the load center: 300 m.
- Option A: the transformer sits at the property line and 300 m is run at 480 V.
- Option B: 300 m is run at 13.2 kV and the 480 V transformer sits next to the load.
- Copper current density: 1.5 A/mm². Resistivity: 0.022 Ω·mm²/m. Copper density: 8.96 g/cm³. Only the resistive part is considered.
Step 1. Line current.
- A, at 480 V: 3,000 / (√3 × 0.48) = 3,608 A.
- B, at 13.2 kV: 3,000 / (√3 × 13.2) = 131.2 A.
- Ratio: 3,608 / 131.2 = 27.5, equal to 13,200 / 480.
Step 2. Copper section per phase (current / density):
- A: 3,608 / 1.5 = 2,406 mm² per phase, that is, several conductors in parallel per phase and a 4,000 A switchboard.
- B: 131.2 / 1.5 = 87.5 mm² per phase.
Step 3. Voltage drop. ΔV = √3 × ρ × L × J = 1.732 × 0.022 × 300 × 1.5 = 17.15 V in both cases.
- A: 17.15 / 480 = 3.57%.
- B: 17.15 / 13,200 = 0.13%.
Step 4. Resistive losses. P = √3 × ΔV × I.
- A: 1.732 × 17.15 × 3,608 = 107 kW, which is 3.97% of the 2,700 kW.
- B: 1.732 × 17.15 × 131.2 = 3.9 kW, which is 0.14%.
Step 5. Copper. Mass = 3 phases × 300 m × section × 8.96 g per mm² and meter.
- A: 3 × 300 × 2,406 × 8.96 g = 19.4 t.
- B: 3 × 300 × 87.5 × 8.96 g = 0.71 t.
Step 6. Short circuit at 480 V. With a 3,000 kVA transformer of 6% impedance (assumed) and an infinite network: 3,608 / 0.06 = 60,140 A, about 60.1 kA, not counting the motors’ contribution. The switchboards of option A must withstand that current.
Reading. Option A uses a voltage 27.5 times lower and therefore 27.5 times more current and copper, a drop of 3.6%, high for a main feeder, and 107 kW of continuous losses. Option B solves those points, but adds two medium-voltage cubicles, medium-voltage cable with terminations and the transformer next to the load.
When to stay at low voltage
Low voltage is reasonable when the load is small, distances are short and there are no large motors: the transformer serves a single load center and the switchboards carry moderate currents. It is also the simplest solution to operate and maintain. If the load grows, the comparison in the example is repeated with the new data; see how to size a plant transformer and the low-voltage distribution design.
When to bring medium voltage into the plant
It pays off when there are several separate load centers, distances of hundreds of meters, currents that call for many parallel conductors, very large motors or a planned expansion. The plant ends up with an internal medium-voltage network and several small transformers near the loads, with shorter low-voltage cables. The protection study of that network must be added; see the protection and control philosophy of a substation.
Checklist
- Supply voltage confirmed with the network operator.
- Total load, power factor and expected growth.
- Real distance to each load center.
- Current of each alternative and resulting copper section.
- Voltage drop and losses of each alternative.
- Short-circuit level at 480 V and switchboard capacity.
- Large motors: voltage and starting method.
- Equipment and staff available to operate medium voltage.
- Number of parallel conductors and space in raceways.
Need this study?
We compare the voltage alternatives for your plant using your actual loads and distances and deliver the comparison and the calculation report. We provide this engineering work for any country. See the engineering design and studies service and contact us.
Related guides
- Primary design of a substation: stages and deliverables
- Sizing a plant transformer
- AC voltage drop in cables
- Starting large motors: voltage drop and study
- Icw, Ipk and Icc of a switchboard
- Calculation report of a substation
References
- IEEE Std 141-1993, recommended practice for electric power distribution for industrial plants.
Frequently asked questions
At what load size does it pay to move from low to medium voltage?
There is no single threshold. It depends on the total load, the distance between the substation and the consumers, the size of the motors and the short-circuit level the switchboards can withstand. What you can do is calculate, with your plant's data, the current, drop and losses at each voltage and compare them. When the current calls for several conductors per phase or switchboards above 4,000 A, medium voltage usually wins.
Can the voltage drop at medium voltage be ignored?
Over plant distances it is almost always small, but it is still calculated. With the same current density in the copper, the drop in volts is the same at any voltage; what changes is its relative weight. In the example, 17.2 V is 3.6% of 480 V and 0.13% of 13,200 V.
Who decides the plant's supply voltage?
The delivery voltage is set by the network operator according to its system and the requested power, and it is a project input. The design decision that is yours is the internal distribution voltage: where you step down to 480 V or 440 V and how much medium voltage you carry inside the plant.